SFGate

feeny I think cool colors like aqua would be lovely, but I'm worried that your granite counters already have a small backsplash and I'm not sure how a different color will look starting part way up the wall on top of that. I'd be tempted to take off the 6" backsplash (but keep the counters), and then add the tile backsplash going from counter to cabinets.

mbiber @feeny: Thanks for the advice. Arizona Tile said the same thing but also said it is very risky to remove the 6" backsplash as it may chip/break the main countertop and they're not going to be liable. I guess I may have to get a neutral tan/beige earthy color that would go well with the countertop color.

dchartley The 6" granite backsplash has to go if you want to avoid the kitchen looking short and squat with all the stacked horizontal layers...i.e. a line of dark cabinets, followed by a stripe of glass tiles, followed by a granite stripe of the existing backsplash, countertop etc. While there is some risk of damaging the counter granite in a careful, controlled removal process, the results of glass tile from counter to cabinet will be well worth the gamble. (I've lifted and detached an 8' x 4' counter slab, sliced it lengthwise, and reattached the pieces in a staggered height with no problems, despite lots of disclaimers by the granite installers.) Chose your glass tile color carefully, as glass in shadow (underneath a cabinet) changes color dramatically from the same sample with either LED or incandescent light. Mixing cool blues with the brown granite would be gorgeous...but so, too would be a monochromatic look keeping in the sand beige family. To that end, Ann Sacks Tile has a "sand" color that comes in assorted sizes which you can use in a straight set.

patricia2203 Hi,

I agree with previous comments about upstand removal and going for the sand splashback tile. May I suggest bringing in the lovely aqua or teal hue in the blind/shade fabric? It would really bring the space to life!

dlang I also agree, here's an example of a costly mistake. I have dark granite and light cabinets and the one small tile sample I selected was very close to the cabinet color but all the others were grayish. The glass tile sample was a lighter celery green then when installed it turned olive! Way too choppy, I hate the whole look but fear the damage it will cause by removing it.

Marie Meko, Allied ASID Since removal of back splash is risky what about installing glass tile vertical instead of horizontal for more height and to draw eye from splash. Stay in the neutral tones as others have suggested for the tile.

inkwitch I sympathize with your dilemma. If you are stuck with the granite backsplash, consider a glass backsplash that integrates some copper and other earth tones. There are websites where you can "build" your own backsplash colors. If you aren't adverse to a stripe instead of a random splattering of colors, you could create one with bands of colors going from light to dark in either direction. No more than 3 colors, but you have to like stripes as that is what you will end up with.

There are some earth-tone backsplashes that are so gorgeous, I'd almost alter my whole color scheme to have one! YOu don't have to settle for "beige."

Marcia Moore Design If you are afraid to tackle the granite removal, then you need to use a tile, stone or glass that is very similar in color to the existing granite to avoid the choppy look. Maybe rather than all glass choose a neutral stone and use glass as accent pieces set with the stone.

dlang I think the glass accent is part of the problem, I'd rather just use a single tone, and the stone made it look like brick when it was supposed to be subway

thuykly I agree with Marie's idea about the vertical height. Also you could have neutral beige glass or tiles that are are glossy/shiny rather than matt, to give the neutralness more life. If you want to brighten up the kitchen, accessorise with simple and bold aqua pieces, eg. Vase or bowl, tea towels, place mats. Just don't clutter! Good luck :)

rkmom I think glass mosaic with granite is often way too busy, and more horizontal lines are going to be too much. If you really want colored glass, something simple like this (Waikiki Chic 2) might work, but you don't have a lot of space between the backsplash and the cabinets. Otherwise I think a neutral tile of some sort would be better--you could have it installed vertically or on the diagonal to add some interest and break up the horizontal lines. For example, Gorgeous Kitchen Remodel.

butchicles how about stainless steel or smoky mirrors? simple and not challenging to the granite or small space available.

modeskixx My suggestion would be to not risk removing the back, but rather make the rest of your backsplash in same granite. Put a stainless edge on top of what you have now, and get either a mosaic pattern or rectangle pattern tile made form the same granite.You do not seem to have lots of square footage, so cost would not be crazy, and look would be both rich & classic.

glorfred One more idea. I had a similar dilemma when I remodeled my kitchen. I looked around for a long time and wasn't really sold on anything I saw. In the end, I installed mirror, and I love it! It is bright, and it opens up the space under the cabinets. Also, it is a breeze to keep clean, especially behind the cooktop area. Keep in mind that glass comes in all shades and colors, and when custom cut, it is seamless.

paulineledao I think the granite backsplash looks good just as it is with the wall painted white. It has a clean look to it. I feel introducing another media with the patterned granite would be a costly mistake. Leave it as is......

Andrea Colburn I would do stainless steel backsplash.

cblanda Actually a mirrored backsplash is modern, relatively inexpensive and looks terrific!

David Landy ASID CID NY State you should be able to remove the granite back splash with no problem... Just call the company who put it in and find out if it was siliconed into place... If so, with an extendable razor blade (available everywhere) you slice under the back splash to cut the connection.... do the same at the top where it meets the wall.... then you will be able to remove it with no damage....If it was cemented with say a Laticrete thinset, then that is going to be a job....Still follow the same procedure but use a VIBRATING CUT OFF TOOL such as a Bosch or Dremel or Fein with a flat scraping blade.... This will aggressively remove the adhesive or cement.... There is no pounding and thus no damage..... Whew !!!!

Now for the tile - Use an iridescent glass - 1" x 4" laid up in sheets, running bond pattern (look it up) .... This should cost you approx $17 - $28 per sq ft... The iridescent color will add zing to this mundane dark look....

the tile I describe in a different color can be seen at www.davidlandyinteriors.com
Good luck....
David Landy ASID CID
Past Pres. ASID NY Metro

David Landy ASID CID NY State Here is an image for you to see the scale that is appropriate.... I agree the backsplash of granite needs to be removed... It is time to "professionalize" this kitchen....

David Landy ASID CID NY State Opps - here is the closeup I forgot to include !!!

David Landy ASID CID NY State This tile has other colorways that are appropriate for you... this green / blue / off white is NOT the color for your kitchen - the scale and type are perfect.... Just select the right brown tones from the VIHARA COLLECTION - SONOMA TILE

Lyn Ross Interior Design/One Source Interiors Wow so many comments, I actually agree with many. A professional granite installer should be able to remove that granite backsplash. I suggest a glass mosaic tile splash which will bring some life to the back wall and not clash with your granite. With some under cabinet lighting it will really make the glass tile "pop". If you just do not want to remove the granite backsplash then build the glass mosaic on top of it bringing it flush with the granite.

nierman Keep the backsplash if you want, then a row of mirror or clear glass tile, then the top row touching under the cabinets can be aqua-shade that you like. The aqua will look best next to the dark cabinets than next to the grayish granite. And incorporate aqua in accessories too. (I love beiges, but I don't think they would do any justice to your kitchen at all.)

Tracey Conwell what about these colors? oops cant paste the photo on ipad. well looks like your backsplash slab goes back behind the counter. seems hard for a DIY project. try alternating squares of porcelain tile in ebony with reflective silver/pewter finish tile. this kind of look might work , incorporates the reflective quality of steel or mirror and repeats dark cabinets.

astroboy108 Absolutely remove the granite backsplash. This will make your counters and island top strictly horizontal planes, which will strengthen the horizontal lines of the cabinets. To balance it out, extend the wallsplash all the way up to the ceiling and above the wall cabinets, not just from the bottom of the wall cabinets down to the granite counter.

Use rectangular tiles and place them vertically to gain height. Treat it as a WALL application, which will balance all the horizontal planes and create uniformity and balance to the entire room. Your choice of wall tiles should stay in a balanced mix of very light creams, off-whites and whites.

Whites might sound boring, but the finish of the tiles (iridesent, opalescent) is what will really make the wall and your kitchen pop. Too much color on the wall will fight all the other color in the room and will lack cohesion. Basically, you want to create a neutral canvas so that you can add color(s) you love with the accessories you fill your kitchen with. Have fun!

Angela Sargenti You should get some of those tiles with fossils in them. They don't all need to have one, just have them scattered around. http://www.greenriverstone.com/products/tile-selection/centerpiece/?f=combo

drewdot I think you should consider natural stone to bring down the contrast. Check out Walker Zanger Shabui....it's my go-to stone for backsplashes and fireplaces.

swhorowitz If you can't/don't want to remove the back splash you can use back painted large sheets of glass in a color harmonious to the granite. Do not try a contrasting color because it will look choppy and loose its "modern" feel.

dipasapre What did you end up going with? I am going through the same dilemma but have the granite on our wall already removed; finding a matching backsplash is my issue!