PLEASE HELP. STRESSED OUT . NEED TO DECIDE TODAY.
OMG.. I have to decide today if I want to go with polished concrete or wood. My son REALLY wants wood and I really want to make him happy. I also want to make me happy and invest wisely in this house. I got a few boxes last night of wood plants and layed them out to see if i likes it. I should have done it long ago. I kinda did but with the idea of grue down at 3 bux a sq foot and it was too much. Now an thinking of bamboo click lock and do it for for $400 with home depot or handiman. Will save 1000s. Bottom line do I want wood? Do I want tile? Transitions to bathrooms? Or a concrete overlay for the whole house. Will post pics. Also see other pics of mine on the "need to decide on a floor discussion". How do I choose wood tone of floor? Is bamboo the way to go? Will I regret doing concrete overlay?
| Share: |
|
More Discussions


Concrete is a great material for flooring - we embrace and look forward to variations, irregularities, and the patina that develops with wear over time so the cracks and chips (if repaired and filled) can add to the 'beauty marks' on your floor. Concrete gives you great longevity, wear, ages beautifully, and is the same temperature as tile or natural stone.
http://www.modeconcrete.com/
Do you have to do the entire house with the same floor? Can you at least put wood on your son's floor?
Okay, I just realized this question was from 30 hours ago....what did you decide to do?
What's wrong with cement throughout?
If you must go to hardwood, then GET hardwood. Click flooring is so cheap looking and sounding...
Overall what is your design aesthetic -concrete tends to lean towards modern/contemporary.
PS: WHO'S PAYING THE MORTGAGE - YOU OR YOUR SON?
Just saying...get what YOU want...
How old is your son? It's not child abuse to "make" him live with a design aesthetic he doesn't like, so stop beating yourself up over that aspect of the decision. However, taking his feelings into consideration is appropriate. Do his room in wood if you can. But make sure he knows that a person who won't be his friend because of the type of floor in his house isn't worth being friends with!
The fact that few people in your area don't have concrete floors may just mean you're a trend setter! Talk to realtors to find out about resale value. What's in today may be outdated someday when you sell.
[houzz=Wood Look Porcelain Tile][houzz=Monte Napoleone Porcelain floor tile][houzz=Monte Napoleone 6x48, 8x48 1][houzz=Xilema Porcelain Floor Tile - Wood looking][houzz=Monte Napoleone 6x48, 8x48 2][houzz=Strand Porcelain Tile - Linear Stone Look - Moro Black - floor tile][houzz=Strand Porcelain Tile - Linear Stone Look Tile - Beige Tile - Floor tile][[houzz=Vintage Wood Planks- Porcelain Tile 5"x24"]houzz=Provenza Lignes- Wood Look Porcelain TIle]
But the reason I am posting is not to do with the specific design choice. I think that what is driving you crazy may be more the lack of a decision, than the issue at hand. Both of your options are good in their own ways. I think you should force yourself to go with one of them (instead of continuing to go back and forth) and then remind yourself afterward of the reasons for your choice, and you can feel good about whatever decision you have made.
#5 made me think of you :)
lets see. fear of making the wrong decision which costs lots of money and is is irreversable.
I love to shop at costco. I can buy whatever and if I dont like it I can return it. I cant do that with a floor.The floor was carpet and linolium ugly basic builder grade stuff. Its gone now and I have ugly concrete with stuff from where the tile and tack strips were and all the markings that looks like a slab before a house is complete. see pics I posted.
My son is 15. I think its more of him telling me what he likes better and what he feels goes best with our house. As for Tile planks. I am not crazy about them. If I did tile I would do this one abstract metalic tile I love but its too expensive and tile is cold. So if I do wood I have to do tile in the bathrooms but if I am going to walk on that hard surface I prefer concrete since its not as cold and less expensive that really nice tile.
Here are some pics of my very unfinished house. money is a big issue for us otherwise I would have a new kitchen by now as well. I have to make wise decisions in that I dont think I will have money to redo this in the future. I also talked to the realtor who sold us the house. She says wood and tile are what she sees. No one does concrete and while I dont care what others think I also want to increase the value of the house in case who knows what the future holds. If I ever need to rent it or sell it.
Cork floating flooring can be installed everywhere BUT a bathroom. That's where the cork glue down tiles come in! Cork is considered a "high end" floor finish because it is normally much more expensive than all the high end laminates. I have NEVER heard of a home buyer saying, "I love the house but the cork flooring HAS to go! Cork often pays you back over time. I've had sellers use cork when their property would not sell. They ripped out the "new laminate" and installed some of my most basic cork (only a little better than a cork-board look) and "Tah-Dah!" house sold in 10 days. I hear it over and over again about cork!
To give you a more finished look for very little money have you considered painting your existing floors? Then put on some inexpensive sisal area rugs (even really big ones in some rooms) which can also be painted/stenciled. Once you do that and put up your artwork, you'll feel more like it's "done" and you can relax.
You can always put something over your painted floors in the future...or not.
Enjoy your HOME with your FAMILY :)
I would be happy to explain the difference. There are some very wrong answers on that on the internet. Laminate is a image of wood or tile laminated to a particle board base. It is NOT wood in any form. It cannot be sanded or filled to repair. It is very suspect when it comes to moisture. It normal install is interlocking or glue together. It has a relatively durable surface but can be scratched. (Had it in my own home and had scratches everywhere). It is loud even with a noise dampening underlayment. It just doesn't absorb any sound. It CANNOT be mopped no wetjet no shark. Dust only and just adab of moisture if something sticky on it. Its very inexpensive and easy to install.
Luxury Vinyl- Is the image of wood or tile made into high composite tile or plank. Its flexible allowing for use on an uneven substrate. It has 3 ways to be installed. Glue,click or gravity. Same requirements needed on the substrate to install it as for laminate. Just no underlayment needed for a moisture barrier. Luxury vinyl is moisture proof. It can be mopped and is extremely resistant to scratching. Most of the click and lock and gravity styles now come with lifetime warranties. Its also very quiet to walk on and looks fantastic down. I have it in my showroom's playroom for the kiddos. Its been down 3 years now and they have to leave a mark one on it and not a bit of damage for the all the spilled drinks.
When installing either laminate or luxury vinyl the same basic floor preps are needed. Vinyl just doesnt have that worry about a "level" as a laminate wood.
Hope this helps.
P
Cork floating flooring (click together flooring), especially Forna Cork flooring (sold by Icork/Cancork) are long lasting/beautifully finished floors that are easy to install and easy to maintain. Unlike the lady who used Wicanders (I'm very upset with the Wicanders brand...can you tell - they sell their floors at astronomical prices and yet "hide" the fact their "high-end" finishes can not be exposed to water!!!), Forna floors are finished with a commercial grade water based polyurethane. Forna floors are considered "Extremely Low" VOC content. They are 7/16 inch thick. They come with a 25 residential warranty. Most of the planks are 1ft x 3ft and weigh 5 pounds/plank! The Forna wear layer is produced in Germany and used to produce a factory finish that can be used any where in a house (except a bathroom). Cork is soft but tuff. Think of Silk. It is one of the most beautiful products nature has ever produced. Soft yet stronger, pound for pound than steel. Cork is the same way. It bounces back from "injury". This means, if your sofa makes a small dent in the cork (over time), simply move the sofa few inches and allow the cork to "spring back" into place. If you drop a knife, and it sticks into the floor, simply draw the knife out, slowly, and the edges of the cork will seal itself (the mark disappears). If you/son gouges a small piece out of th cork, simply cut out the little bit of damaged cork, harvest a small amount of new cork from one of our "off-cuts" (this is why you keep a few extra planks from any job you do) and "transplant" the cork to your floor. A little wood glue and wax paper and a weight (a book does nicely) and you have created a perfect "patch". If you are worried about moisture/water (kitchen or entrance by the pool), simply seal your floor with the same water based polyurethane used in the factory. The 2 coats will give you a water resistant floor (fine for a gallon of milk being spilled and not cleaned up for 5 hours), but if your dishwasher explodes you may need a new floor. (That's the difference between water resistant and water proof). I can tell, that cork would be an amazing addition to your design dilemna! I know where you - and your son - are coming from! You want sleek, elegant, fashion forward and he's tired of walking around on a hard, cold floor! Cork will fix BOTH issues. Visit www.icorkfloor.com to see all of the flooring. They ship out of Kent WA. and can have a floor to you inside of 5 days...if you need them to. They ship out free samples. I think you will be pleasantly surprised by their prices and the looks that can be achieved with cork. If you want to speak with me directly, feel free to visit our Houzz page. You will find everything you need to to contact me directly. Stephanie
For bad knees, I (of course) would recommend cork flooring. You can look at a floating cork floor (same concept as a laminate floor except it is made with cork - 1/2" thick planks are the norm). Products sold by the "big" names in cork will start at $8/sf (depending on where you live). Icork flooring starts at $2.28/sf for the entry level floor (looks like groung up cork....but it is still several dollars cheaper than Wic......'s flooring!). Icork's floors are produced to European standards, which will still beat the CARB ruless right into the next decade (possibly 2 decades). Europeans are not allowed to use ANY form of solvents in the manufacturing process (that includes use of Urethane). Many North American floors are produced with solvent based products because they are still allowed in the USA. Some cork producers manufacture two different standards = High End cork for Europe and lower quality (cheap to produce) cork for the USA. Sad but true. Icork and Cancork do not make the distinction between the two markets. The same floor that is produced for Austria is sold in Kent WA. Be aware of the finish of cork...urethanes and water based urethanes do not wear very well on cork - it's too brittle and requires FREQUENT refinishing. Water based polyurethane has a much better profile with cork and only needs refreshing every 5-7 years.