Fireplace
Is the fireplace concrete and if so how can that look be achieved in a more cost effective way?
by Dan Nelson, Designs Northwest Architects · More Info
| Share: |
|
More Discussions
| Share: |
|
Panels can be fabricated at 8' x 4' and be only 3/4" thick. Of course, the larger the piece the greater the cost per piece. Smaller pieces are easier to move and process. Tiles can be as thin as 1/2" easily. Some are pushing the envelope at 1/4".
You will have seams, but this can be used as a design element and it will save you a lot of cost compared to a three dimensional cast concrete surround.
Feel free to contact me. We are based in the Seattle area, but I have contacts all over the country if you need a fabricator.
Regards,
Vincent Cathcart
VC Studio Inc.
vince@vcstudioinc.com
I've attached a picture of some sample tiles. The little ones are only 4" square. Panels would simply be bigger, per your specification.
The second picture shows a wrap around mantle with a panel / tile below it. That tile directly above the fire box is approximately 36" x 12" x 1/2".
Vincent Cathcart
VC Studio Inc.
vince@vcstudioinc.com
Thanks for your input on this.
This particular fireplace was cast in a concrete surround.
Your thoughts on how to do it more cost effectively are great.
Another posibilty is to frame the wall and trowel on a a product like Milestone that has a cementious finish.
The finished product will look like concrete but will not hve the solidity of real concrete.
Thanks again for your interest in this.
Dan
( Dan, Beautiful work as always! Hopefully we'll work together sometime.)
Milestone has been around for a long time and works well. It does have a really high acrylic content so it gets a bit shiny. For a more natural look I would go with an Italian lime based plaster. The kind of sealer, and how many coats are applied has a lot to do with sheen.
Smaller areas do cost more if you are looking at a per sf cost. It takes just as long to set up and wait for product to dry for 50 sf as it does for 500 sf. Your fireplace surround with a coating like these would probably run around $1200.
You also have the option of using a micro topping which is a very thin and fine layer of concrete.
Both of these options mean you would need to frame out the wall, as Dan said, to achieve the desired shape. These coating are applied at only 1/16" to 1/8" thick. If you used the micro topping you should use a cement board base. You could screw hardi board directly to the wall for a minimal build (1/2" board). Any of these coating would work over it.
*Thought of one more. You could use one of the acrylic based plasters from Faux Effects. They can be tinted and troweled on. It could likely be installed in a day for about $900.
None of these options will look or feel just like cast concrete, but it can give you a similar look for less cost.
To have tiles cast to fit would be about half of the quote you received for the complete concrete surround. I attached a simple drawing based on your measurements to give you an idea of what you could do. A high quality construction adhesive would hold the tiles on well.
BTW - Their bid was very generous. A complete concrete surround of this size should have been at least $1000 more than you were quoted. Your region should be charging more than ours. I would be very cautious of anyone's costs that are too low. Quality takes time and experience, and therefore costs more.
The concrete sample picture looks a little blurry, but yes, we can do almost any kind of finish.
We can fabricate and ship, but you can likely find someone in your area to do a good job without the shipping cost. I do make it down there from time to time because we have several very close friends in the Laguna area.
We do have four concrete sinks at the shop's showroom that do not meet the specs for the redesigned product line. The size and drain assembly changed. We will be selling them off at wholesale. If you are interested please contact me directly.
Vincent Cathcart
VC Studio Inc.
vince@vcstudioinc.com
Thanks for checking in.
Dan
I wasn't clear if you were asking for Dan's email or mine. My direct email is in the signature of my posts.
Vincent Cathcart
VC Studio Inc.
vince@vcstudioinc.com
Vince ( I dont see the email.. Is it at gmail or yahoo). Must I frame the wall or can I maybe just put it directly on the wall as is to create a tiled look without losing space in the room by framing and adding more cost to the project? I am interested in the product you mentioned. Is that available at local home improvement stores or best to order online? You have me thinking about doing the hardi board with a microtopping (if only I knew what that was) . Perhaps its what they put my sample of concrete on that I like so much. Where do I get this? What does the microtopping achieve if on a board that is already flat? Is it needed to absorb the the product? Is faux effects a place that sells a venitian plaster? I obviously have a lot to research but I have used an acrylic gel medium on canvas board before to create thickness and texture and than paint over it. I am assuming its this type of technique your referring to. I am excited by the idea of making something and saving money. Do you have a picture of exactly the technique your referring to that is the least expensive and will give that wall a modern finished look. I was thinking of putting in a gas metal burner and the fireglass that glows. Is it necessary to even have a screen on the fireplace?
Dan thank you for your suggestions and if I could ask a favor. Its not often I get to talk to an architect so I was wondering if you could help me help my son. He is 15 and very smart. Very good at math and science and spacial thought. He can put together ikea products in a flash from the pictures. Anyway he is taking an architecture class in High school and wants to be an architect. What can I do as a parent to help him learn more besides what is offered in school, which Is very limited? Also is it necessary to go to college or through specific testing and licences that can only be prepared for in college? Please help me understand more about the process from your perspective and how I can help him.
It is great that your son is interested in architecture. It is a very rewarding profession.
However it does take a tremendous commitment to become an architect.
One must earn an architecture degree first and then work for an architect as an intern for two years before being able to a take the exams to become a registered architect.
It is useful that your son loves math and science, these areas contribute to a strong educational foundation.
I would really encourage your son to draw as much as possible to develop his visual eye.
I still carry sketch books with me when I travel. I draw and do watercolors of the places I visit. If you look at my Houzz site, I have posted sketches from a trip to Spain I took with my family several years ago.
I would also encourage your son to take History classes. Architecture is the reflection of the time and culture we live in. Having a sense of architectural history has bee a big help to me.
It would also be useful for your son to take public speaking. Many times it is necessary to describe our projects to groups of people and it is helpful to know how to give dynamic thoughtful presentations.
I hope this helps. If your son would like to e mail with more questions or thoughts about architecture please have him e mail me at Dan@designsnw,com
Take Care,
Dan
You can apply directly to the wall with tiles, plasters, faux finishes, and some micro toppings. Most of these will need a primer first. Framing the area out was simply a suggestion to create the look of dimension and mass.
These are all specialty products. If a big box hardware store has a knock-off or similar product it will be very low quality. Often they are sold only to the trade. At the very least, many suppliers will require that a certification class be completed so that the installer is qualified (or at least has a basic understanding).
You could use Hardi panels to create your own tiles. Cut them to size. Clean up the edges. Coat with the finish of your choice.
I don't want to promote White Cap (high prices) but I know they are all over the country. They carry Ardex products and probably Mapei as well. They both make micro topping and resurfacing products that would work on your Hardi panels. These are products that should be available to the public through a supply house (there should be others in your area besides White Cap).
Other companies like Color Maker, Duraamen, Elite Crete, etc., will want you to take a class in order to purchase their products. Elite Crete is the least expensive at only $250 for a two day class. Color Maker and Duraamen have a wider variety of products, but their classes are more expensive($600+ or -) and get more technical.
Faux Effects is a national company based in Florida. They have distributors across the country that sell products and provide training. Their beginning class is around two thousand dollars. It provides a basic understanding, and hands on training with around twenty different finishes. You leave with sample boards for a portfolio. They have a huge line of products, including a Venetian plaster. Most require the class to purchase them. They do have a line of products that the public can buy. That may be sufficient for your project. I order from Faux Masters in Yorba Linda. Juan has processed orders there for years. He is very knowledgeable and may help you figure out what products you could use without a class. They have a showroom where you can look at finishes, but be careful! Once you see what can be done, you may want the class :-) *If you call them tell Juan (or Mike Hoppe)
For the fireplace, it will depend on the manufacturer's specifications. Some form of barrier is normal just for protection.
My direct email is vince@vcstudioinc.com. It should be showing up below my name in each post. There is also a link to my website on my profile page that will have links to my email. My Houzz default email is vcstudioinc@gmail.com.
Hope that helps,
Vincent Cathcart
VC Studio Inc.
vince@vcstudioinc.com