SFGate

Wow Great Place I like the balance with 4 chairs. Using 3 just looks like something is missing. In general, you need 24" per barstool for comfortable "elbow room" at a counter, and it looks like your island is a good 8 feet long, so 4 is perfect!

houssaon Four works, doesn't it? Do the seats swivel?

posthill Four looks great and balanced.

Parisa Mh Thank you :)
Yes it is swivel , so looks like I lost the bet lol. Cause I thought 3 is fine and 4 is too much for our island, so my brother told me to put the picture in here and lets see what do you guys suggest ;D

Interiors International, Inc. 4 definitely!

EB Interiors Your counter can totally handle four, looks great.

Travis Robert Renovations We vote 4

Channy Bowman I'll say 3 so you get one vote :) (but I agree 4 looks great) :p

Parisa Mh Haha thank you guys for your suggestions ;)

larry1333 I LOVE 4!!!

tgreffin 4 for sure

myrielle 4 it would look perfect and there we help u don't listen to those who say 3pleaseplease for sure boo

Deborah Butler, Brickwood Builders We have tried 4 with a client at an island that was only 8' long and it didn't work. Not enough room to push the stool back and step away from the island when there were people on either side. so my vote is 3 for practical purposes.

juma decor 4 balance the space the best.

Darzy Four looks a bit crowded to me but it looks fine. I would probably use three (slightly closer together) but I think both look fine.

rachaelhz 4 :)

brittalovely 4