Need thoughts on kitchen layout/design...
1984 split level, upstairs kitchen. The first rendering is the current layout...the freezer door can't be opened all the way, and we have limited counter space, mostly taken over by a coffee pot, knife block, fruit bowl, stand mixer, and toaster.
The second two are our favorite idea for cabinet layout...see any issues, or something better? Ideally the counter for the breakfast bar would be curved, but I'm still researching that. The thing to the right of the support wall is a desk unit.
(The plumbing will not be moved; finished basement ceiling and limited budget, so no moving the sink).
The kitchen measures about 11'x11', and is completely open to the attached small dining room/iving room space. There is a window shown, and a patio door to the right. Space to store and countertops are our biggest considerations. All appliances (except POSSIBLY the fridge...but it's fine and matches) are staying, and are black, not stainless.
The last pic is of the cabinets we are considering (the wood, stain, and doors).
Thanks for any ideas!
The second two are our favorite idea for cabinet layout...see any issues, or something better? Ideally the counter for the breakfast bar would be curved, but I'm still researching that. The thing to the right of the support wall is a desk unit.
(The plumbing will not be moved; finished basement ceiling and limited budget, so no moving the sink).
The kitchen measures about 11'x11', and is completely open to the attached small dining room/iving room space. There is a window shown, and a patio door to the right. Space to store and countertops are our biggest considerations. All appliances (except POSSIBLY the fridge...but it's fine and matches) are staying, and are black, not stainless.
The last pic is of the cabinets we are considering (the wood, stain, and doors).
Thanks for any ideas!
| Share: |
|
More Discussions


Imagine a couch/chair area in the blank space; the half wall to the right is a stair railing, and that opening the stairs to the front door. The only way to get to the backyard from the house is through the patio door to the left, and out onto the deck. It's cozy and open at the same time.
The ceilings are vaulted over the dining/living area, and the window placement keeps it very open and light in there, even with the current medium oak cabinets...the ones we are looking at are one shade darker. It's a personal preference...i'd rather have a medium/dark natural wood kitchen that feels a bit cozier than a light or white kitchen. We are fixing to live in long term.
A plus would be that we could relatively easily recess the fridge a few inches into that wall, and get an almost counter depth look without buying a new one...
Where is the patio door in relation to the stairs?
I'm attaching a few snapshots of the space from the living room and dining room area.
The tiny wall to the right of the sink is structural. We could do something open there, but have tentatively planned to make it a built in desk/storage area with cabinets as that is what we use the space as now. We do need such an area.
Do the pictures help make the space easier to see?
If you closed off the entrance by the patio, you could have a U-shaped kitchen and move your dishwasher to the other side of the sink. It may clash with the oven door, but since the dishwasher is usually loaded, well after the oven has been turned off, the chance of needing them open at the same time is less likely.
Another option is closing off the hall entrance, and moving the kitchen entrance to where the dishwasher is, and moving the dishwasher to the opposite side of the sink. It's close to both entrances, so it should still feel just as convenient, but the added storage would be so worth it.
I agree with the above suggestion to close off the hall entrance. That could create an entire wall of storage space: fridge, pantry and storage cabinetry.
Then, move the sink and dishwasher (yes, move the plumbing - it will be worth the extra time and expense to have everything in the right place!) the ideal spot for the sink will be under the window.
This will create a U shape kitchen, with the stove in the same place it is now, centered at the back of the U, fridge and pantries to the right, sink and dishwasher to the left under the window.
The back and left of the U would have miles of counter space, and overhead storage as well. All the tall units (fridge and pantry) would be on the right, which is important as you don't want that visual bulk anywhere near the patio door or window.
We recently re did our kitchen - the right choice for us was to move it to the opposite side of the room! We had to redo plumbing, electrics, gas for the stove, everything. But it was worth it to get the kitchen layout that worked for us. You can read about it on my blog if you're interested www.thislittlehouse.com.au
Good luck!
:) Elise
Compounding our drywall issue for moving the sink is the fact that I LOVE having the sink overlook/face the dining room and kitchen. It makes cleaning up with kids so much easier, and makes cleaning up while entertaining so much easier, too. We really want a breakfastbar/extended countertop, too, for entertaining, counter space, kids doing homework, etc. We already use the little lip we have...
We are pretty attached to the two entrances as well...we lived in a tight u-shaped kitchen before and hated it. We were always falling over each other to get out, and with kids and dog, we don't want any less escape routes! I'm going to mock them up anyway, as maybe that drawback will be the only one and we will decide it's worth it.
Closing up the hallway entrance and leaving a WIDE u shaped kitchen might be a possibility, however. It would give a bigger open floorspace. No overlooking sink, and no breakfast bar, but it might be more counterspace?
I'm going to create some new drawings and attach them. Nice thing is the cabinets and granite are a (very generous) Christmas gift from the inlaws, so my husband and I may be able to swing a few new things like drywall done professionally instead of DIY like usual. :)
OK...here's one where I trimmed the pantry by the patio doors down to 12 inches deep; the round thing on the base cabinet is my poor, quick attempt of showing a set of open curved shelves to soften the transition from 24" to 12". I realized the fridge won't open all the way if placed against the wall and recessed, so I put a small pull out spice or something cabinet next to it for spacing and storage.
The second one is the view from the front door/up the stairs.
It is a 36" fridge...it is big. We use almost every space of it, however, as we eat almost exclusively unpackaged foods, and shop once a week. It is generally crammed full on Sundays, and the freezer is full, too. It's the biggest reason i'm reluctant to go counterdepth.
We can play with microwave height...I just put it at the same height as the old one (see photos). Probably a range hood height from the original installation in 1984! We are more than likely using a local semicustom cabinetry company, and so we have a lot of flexibility. I'll look up what it should be. Thanks for the heads up!
Would you do just a 3 inch spacer for the fridge, or as I drew and a pull out cabinet that is wider?
The fridge is about 31" deep. If we put it on that top wall we can recess it 3 inches. The right door will not swing more than 90 degrees open unless we don't recess, or unless we do some sort of filler between the right side of the wall and fridge. We have that current problem on the other side, and I hate it!
Only 6 feet of floor space between the counters
(in idea A and B, that is a glass fronted and backed cabinet for dishes...would it be better left out?)
Widen kitchen taking up a couple of feet into the dining area keeping sink on the bar w/DW. This will prevent fridge/DW conflict.
2) OR keep original width, move sink/DW to window wall. Put fridge where several have suggested next to hall doorway. You could recess it or not as it wouldn't be as big an issue with sink gone.
The door will swing free, leave approx. 2 inches to right of fridge cabinet for filler. What is the dimension from peninsula to stove wall?
When designing kitchen tell the cabinet people you need a base cabinet of approx. 18 inches, into which you can install a garbage pullout. Buy one at Lowes, they are a lot cheaper that way and you can install. Keep it near the stove area. Give your self good pots and pan drawers 24 inches at lest. Then a four drawer cabinet for wrap, dish clothes cutlery. near dishwasher.
The wall the fridge is against in Idea B is 28 inches; we can inset none, just a little, or all 3 inches back with our 31 inch deep fridge.
I'll work on plans that include actual cabinet placements next...
I Think we are going with Idea B, hopefully widened a bit. We actually like the 18 inch pantry instead once we think about it...the back 6 inches of our current one is unusable.
Let's see if I can get all the great cabinet placement suggestions in now!
DH and I have decided we want to keep the peninsula/two entrances, so this is the approximate layout. Dropped the next to the sink cabinet, might add a high 12-18" open shelf or glass doored cabinet along the ceiling of the pennisula.
The soffit is DEFINITELY leaving. Can't wait to take it out. Want to go to the ceiling...we have a lot of things that we don't use that need stored up there.
We were planning on a lazy susan in the corner...we will investigate all possibilities, however. (There are little or no actual cabinets marked out in the sketchup.)
We definitely want cabinet organizers...an over the fridge tray divider is on top of my list, too.
The layout for table setting vs preoaing will almost be petfect, too!
Mulling the rest of the questions in my head, too.
We are waiting to talk to an actual designer until we get a good idea of what we want and what price point we are at, but I'm strongly considering hiring someone separate from the cabinet sellers. We shall see...ive said similar before.
We have an over the range microwave. We don't have a budget for a drawer microwave, or a good place to put one. No range hood. I'm not a huge fan of them anyway.
Lots to think about...
I find the OTR microwave awkward - I'm only 5'3" and that puts any dish on the turntable at or over eye-level, plus if anything is heavy/hot it's an awkward reach over a hot stove. And when do your children start wanting to 'make it themselves' - or when do you want them to make it themselves! - an over the range microwave makes it harder (for good or bad ) for them to do so.
My neighbour has her microwave built-in to the pantry cabinet, so lower cabinet is pantry, then microwave at counter height, then more pantry above. You will need a full-depth pantry for that and you'll have to buy a hood fan, but there must be some fans you don't mind - even an under-the-cabinet fan.
Thanks for the heads up on the display being wrong; they are a custom cabinet maker who's work comes highly recommended, so I'm a bit surprised. Good to know and check out, though.
Good idea for adding cupboards on the back of the peninsula; I'm not sure we have space as the dining room is pretty small, and even extending the counters an extra 6 inches will cause a different. However, the existing island cabinets are 30" deep instead of 24" deep, so I will play with that and see how it feels.
"nos" really matter, and I hate just putting something unsafe and definitely a no right in her attention field.
For a below counter installation, I think many microwaves now come with child safety locks. Otherwise, is there a shelf of your pantry you could devote to a microwave? Or are any of your wall cabinets wide enough to accomodate a microwave that would work for you?
Fortunately, there are a lot of options now incl. microwave drawers. I'll attach a rendering showing what I've designed for my own kitchen.
it is possible to get some refrigerator drawers, too, put them on the outside perimeter, and let that be your beverage center.
it is also possible to have more than one sink -- a smaller one for (go ahead, laugh) beverages and vegetable rinsing, and a larger one for clean up of big pots and stuff.
regarding microwaves -- heh. i have not had a microwave for 15 years and do not miss it. having said that, what on earth do you really use it for?? for hot water ? get a special tap on your sink. for warming up leftovers? get a tiny one.
they are getting smaller and smaller. when they get the size of a toaster, i might get one. other than that, ... really? do you really use it? LOL
Here's a grand one -- can you put it in the pantry? that one i almost like....
:-) thanks again for a fun thread!!!
there are some folks here who are terrific about colors to recommend, hope they join the conversation.
the lighting: get under cabinet, some track lighing if you will have a soffit. etc. etc. it has all been said before.
but
the coziness you are looking for will come from a rich color, plus lighting.
:-)
Ana Williamson Architect
Dark Cabinetry Kitchen
not sure any of these appeal to you, plz ignore if not.
this one came from your ideabook (a very nice ideabook, btw!!!)
Craftsman Home
notice the warm colors and the lighting. i agree with you, this is terrific.
Now for future: 1. I have microwave which bakes and roasts as well. Therefore, we do not need the double ovens we had before. 2. One dish drawer holds as much as regular dishwasher, in half the space. One daughter put one dish drawer on each side of the sink..she is 6'2" with storage below for kids plastic items. Other daughter 5'7" put two dish drawers one below each other. For myself I have two (one in cooking area and one in clean up) in the kitchen and only one in the bar area. (we entertain a lot). I only run clean up area dish drawer every few days in order to have full load. 3. Future will be induction cooking...still new to North America... so if buying pots, get ones that use regular stove BUT also good for induction cook top. 4) if any walls are being opened consider installing gas pipe to outside BBQ in lieu of propane...assuming gas is available in your area. 5. Install water line in fridge area even if you do not require it now...will cost very little now, but a lot down the road. 6. Kitchen counters...stone, granite and marble will be out..too expensive and not environmentally friendly. Quartz, laminate and man made stone are more durable, less maintenance and budget friendly. Just pick a nice edge finish. Granite will be just like avocado and copper appliances... scratched, scuffed, stained and still working but dated... 7. Smaller refrigerators will be coming. Putting them close to use rather than a monster holding all. Fridge drawers will be in beverage or breakfast area. Under counter fridge and separate freezer in secondary living space, ie rec room, in-law suite, 2-3 person homes, small spaces (gives more counter space). Others have mentioned some of these issues as well. I am just saying, I have used them and they work well. I am constantly talking my four kids and the grandkids into experiments on space saving, storage, and new lifestyles. I have two grandkids in College and I have redone their dorm rooms (with all the restrictions) so they have every convenience and proper study environments. Hope these insights help.
The one custom place we are talking to that is surpisingly affordable actually does create different sized boxes to 1/16inch, so no issue there. We have priced out the big box stores, and even RTA as we have experience woodworking for other options, both more and less expensive than the custom. Haven't decided which route to go yet...
We will be putting in granite, as the person funding this expenditure is a stone cutter, and has informed us as such. Won't touch anything fake. I'm OK with it being dated; real stone and real wood are two things I don't find offensive even when "dated". We are staying long term, so resale doesn't matter. We will likely end up with scrap or a salvaged stone, so still environmentally friendly, just like our first house. And the wood floor is already installed and staying. It's solid oak, and has held up quite nicely so far. The only place we are taking it out is the bathroom... (that HAS to go...)
I definitely want the sink front fold down thingy. :)
We use our microwave a LOT. Oatmeal in the morning, every morning. We cook large elaborate meals on Sundays, and eat them for much of the week, warming in the microwave. We regularly "bake" sweet potatos and regular potatoes in there for a quick meal addition. When you work until late...
We have a brand new smooth top electric.
Many of these ideas are great for a much larger kitchen and house than I have; a sink next to the stove would be 2 feet from the other sink. :)
Montgomery, great pics. :) Lots to think about; with such an open floor plan, we need to think hard about colors and coordinating!
I did not accept the idea of having salt, pepper, sugar, etc built into the kitchen table which would pop up when needed.. I too did not have space for second sink, (thinking in corner to left of stove) but stove water tap is constantly used. I have no "corners" where cabinets meet in my kitchen. stove tap reduces need to carry heavy lobster and pasta pots filled with boiling water.
Met four times during construction to see progress, deliver faucets and hardware, sink, and dish drawers and appliance templates. Then, picking the finished wood stain colour was probably the most nerve wracking. Not too light, not too red, not too brown, not too dark, which of the fifteen Colours of white? .. Check online large paint mfg. and the have info of what colours to consider with N,E, S and W facing windows. The carpenter did 5 sample boards of various colour tones. Crossed our fingers and made a decision. Then I had the island painted in a different colour along with a matching free standing cabinet for wine and crystal glasses. Then the kitchen table (which is attached to the island) was stained in the cabinet colour. Have since painted kitchen wall darker grey to coordinate with stone backsplash.
Just wondering if you could tell me what program you use to do up your designs.
Thanks
Sara
http://houzz.com/discussions/339190
Next post is the backsplash inspiration pic:
Now for the hard parts; finishing off details.
1) counter height bar or a raised bar? If raised I'd do an open raise.
2) undermount or drop in sink? Drainboard? Why? I've only ever had the cheapest $50 sink from hd. Also, thinking of doing a sink and a half instead of a full double to save counter space and a little passage space by getting a 33 inch sink base.
3) 96" ceilings. We want cabinets to the ceiling. 42 inch shaker doors, or do 30 inch cabinets with 12 inch doors above to store extras/break it up. Possible glass...
1) For us, it would be raised bar. Hides the kitchen mess a bit while you enjoy dinner. I don't recall that you're using the bar for eating, right?
2) Undermount. I'll be surprised if you get many drop in votes at all.
3) I'll bet people who specialize in cabinets have suggestions there. I'd have to see a visual to know for myself.
2) Undermount sink for a cleaner look. No drainboard as you already have limited usable space around the sink; a drainboard would be "specific use" as opposed to "multi-function" space.
3) I like 42" cabinets but depends on what look you're going for. I had a kitchen with tiny top cabinets and they weren't very useful for storage--too high to reach and too small for anything sizeable. Glass front cabinets are nice if you have a few pieces of dinnerware you want to show off.
Something like this:
Another question... Inset or full overlay? I love the inset look, but what are the drawbacks? (Besides price).
IF one was to put an under the counter microwave in the final plan, where would one put it? I'd think next to the fridge, but I hate to lose the pots and pans drawers. Perhaps I could store them in the corner cabinet instead?
To summerize:
1) raised or counter height bar
2) under or over mount sink
3) answered. :)
4) inset or full overlay cabinets
6) where to put a possible under counter microwave
2. undermount sink - counter mess sweeps right into sink and no lip gets full of gunk
3.!!
4. full overlay - no silly frames that small items hide behind
5. could microwave go under the window - are there cabinets there or not? Or I think I suggested in an earlier post about microwave incorporated into pantry cabinet. Or think of it as an oven cabinet with only the microwave in it and the rest of the cabinet is pantry. Microwave is not behind doors. That puts the microwave at counter height, so away from tiny hands but not too high for a 10 year old to heat leftovers or whatever.
We could go under the window as well; have to play with the cabinets there.
Also, should we do a single or double sink?
Also, be careful with the depth. A lot of people assume deeper is better, but with a hi-arc faucet you don't really need a deep sink to get the large pots under it, and I find trying to scrub something more than 9" below the counter hard on the back.
And definitely undermount the sink.
I am not someone who cares about looking modern/dated; if I could, this house would be an old house, restored. However, Rio, I'm thinking that full-overlay would be good for the modern look as well; I LOVE inset doors, but last night I was thinking as I was trying to fall asleep that perhaps inset doors PLUS a craftsman style backsplash PLUS shaker doors in cherry would be too much "period" look, and NOT fit in with our house. I've got to keep what this house IS in mind; trying to make it something else will not look right!
Our house is 1984, and has a LOT of craftsman influence in the details/bannister/etc, but a more subtle approach would probably look better, right?
So, as full overlay is cheaper than inset, and I think there are good design reasons to go that way instead...I think we will go that way.
I'm leaning towards a sink and a half with a lowered divider; we use a dishtub for all of our handwashing, so two sinks isn't essential. I do, however, want a smaller sink footprint.
I say "meh" on the soft close hinges. Unless you really hate to hear cabinet doors slamming shut, they are an extra expense you don't need.
Your kitchen sounds gorgeous - have you picked your granite yet? I love love love rainforest green in a craftsman style room. It's actually a serpentine, but almost as hard a a granite. If I could do my own kitchen from scratch it would be shaker style, medium cherry, with rainforest green counters.
BTW - your cherry will darken over time - especially if your kitchen has a lot of natural light.
However, he's also funding this expenditure for the most part (they gave part of a down payment to BIL, and are "even steven" people, so we get a new kitchen), and doing the cabinets just how we want PLUS granite (even wholesale) might be too much. We are planning on doing salvaged oak butcher block ($5 a sf locally) either natural/waterloxed, or with a dark stain as a "temporary" but still nice counter for a few years if needed. Would rather make sure the cabinets are what we want and good quality first.
My kitchen has soft close hinges all around - it was great for teenage-boy-proofing the kitchen. Unfortunately the hinges on on the doors under the sink are shot. All other doors are fine. I think my kitchen finishes are pretty, but I also think think it's probably cheaper quality - kitchen was refinished by last owner who essentially flipped the house. It 's 30 years old so basically same age as yours, but smaller!
Microwave - I don't think it matters whether it's under the window or built-in to pantry. Your kitchen is not so large, nothing is more than 2 steps away. The only time fridge and pantry will feel far apart is when you are unloading groceries.
Sink - even with a dishwasher there are always pots and pans to be washed and rinsed and then set to dry - get a double sink. If you get the one with lower divider, let is know how you like it in actual use. They sound interesting.
I can't wait until you're actually doing the renovations - I hope you post some photos of the process and of course the final results!
Have fun!
You mentioned 42" high wall cabinets. I've seen it done but I usually don't because ceilings are rarely level. (When measuring, be sure to measure at several places). I use 36" cabinets, crown at the ceiling and a filler strip placed horizontally between them. The crown determines the width of the filler strip. Some manuf. offer 39" cabinets, too. (I'd still use the filler but it would be minimized). If it helps, I have a Mouldings Ideabook you can check out.
I was up many nights over all the decisions but so glad I researched all the details like you are doing. Oh and those Kohler sinks are beautiful but ouch on the budget!
Still debating about the desk area...
Dh just expressed interest in hidden hinge inset, which does look nice. Sigh.
And he has informed me that if his dad does the counter in granite we won't be doing undermount. I understand, as its a lot more work; going to talk to fil this weekend to see what he's willing to do. May go permanently with the salvaged butcher block. ($350 for the whole kitchen cut to size but not finished.)
I'm frustrated over the sink issue, as we need to decide. I am not buying a new sink until we decide, but we have a 36" drop in sink. I'd like to do a 33" cabinet for the sink and have a 12" cabinet next to it instead of a 9" cabinet... One more drawer that way. However...if we don't know what we want we
D better do 36".
Also, lazy Susan issues...do one or no? Doing that standard corner cabinet, but is a lazy Susan worth the extra couple hundred (for the good wood trays)?
You CAN do a 33" SB with your 33" wide double bowl, drop in sink because the sink cutout will be less than 33". That would allow you to do the 12" cabinet that you want to do. (If however, you decide on a std. 25" x 22" single bowl, drop in sink, then you'll use a 27" SB).
Hope this helps!
One other thing, will your cabinets be all wood construction? If not, be sure to upgrade the sink base, and possibly the cabinets beside it to all wood construction. You'll be glad you did if you ever have a leak.
You're doing great!
We just ordered; switched to inset after talking it over. Hope it all looks as good as my head!
Thinking oil rubbed bronze, but don't want an oiled rubbed bronze faucet. What should I use instead? Stainless? Thanks!
(And my MIL bought us a counter depth fridge...wouldn't take no for an answer!)
Assembling cabinets as we speak; our garage is so full!
Maybe black knobs would be best since it will match our black appliances, and then we don't have to worry at all about color.
Should think a bit about lighting, though that won't be replaced for a longish time. Currently a basic orb "boob"light for main lighting and a recessed fixture above the sink. There is a three lighted hanging light in a greenish metal in the dining area next to the kitchen, but I hate it.
It's been a busy spring break for the two if us!
The first two are of the template for the sink peninsula, no sink cut out marked yet, but the shape of the curved bar is there.
The second two are of the kitchen today, not all doors up, but cabinets are up.
The cabinet over the peninsula with the bulkhead still needs to be removed (and the drywall finished).
It's been fun...I love projects.
Just went to Lowes to buy the revashelf inserts we wanted...they'd dropped the price by $30 on one that I wanted, was clearancing off another at half price, had one we drooled over but was waiting on due to money for 1/2 price, and had pull out shelf drawers clearances for $30 each!
Plus, I had a 10% off coupon.
The savings basically paid for the new garbage disposal we discovered we unfortunately need...a nice change of pace!