Home of the San Francisco Chronicle

Subscribe to the weekend Chronicle

powered by
Discussions
Photos
Products
Ideabooks
Discussions
Professionals
Users
by amibeauty
4 months ago in Design Dilemma
What to do with the rest of the fireplace, any suggestions?
I want to do something with the upper part of the fireplace. The bottom is black granite and marble. Floors are marble, build -ins are white wood and black granite. Any suggestions, what kind of tiles/stones to do?
Thanks
Share:
 
annoulaxeni Honestly? Bless the designer who can fix this. I look forward to seeing what the pros come up with. My layman's opinion is that rather than adding, you need to start removing.
4 months ago · ·
cyn222 Wow. Black and pink tones are throwing me. Black columns are so harsh . Not sure what look you are going for. Where you trying to match the floor tiles? The brass on fireplace is dated. I feel bad saying all this, but it's really intense. Just being honest.
4 months ago ·
amibeauty They are not pink.....they are exactly the same colors as the floors beige marble...because of the light look like this. Everything is the same color...and by the way the fireplace is done by designer.
4 months ago ·
cyn222 If it was designed by someone they should have been able to finish off the look. Time to fire them and get some real help.
4 months ago · ·
Robert Guenther Collection You should put a decorative piece of glass in that area, I'm a glass designer if you need help
4 months ago · ·
amibeauty I thought this discussions panel is for help and suggestions not criticize other people work....but I guess I was wrong :) Try to give suggestions and advise
4 months ago ·
Robert Guenther Collection How does someone put the product on this site
4 months ago ·
annoulaxeni Amibeauty, I realized that my comment was likely to offend whomever designed that wall, but I was hoping that wasn't you. And clearly you're not entirely happy with it either, otherwise you wouldn't be seeking advice.

And as hard as it may be to swallow, someone advising you to simplify rather than adorn IS a helpful suggestion. Past that, however, I'm the first one to say 'to each his own' and if this design pleases you, enjoy it in good health!
4 months ago ·
cyn222 My intention was not to be mean but to be honest. You design it the way you like it, not the way we like, but when you ask for help, you will get opinions that do not match yours. I hope someone gives you the help you are seeking. What is the style you are trying to achieve? Maybe that would help.
4 months ago · ·
Robert Guenther Collection Can I put product on this site to sell
4 months ago ·
amibeauty I am not offend at all...I appreciated all the opinions and I am looking for some solution. I don't like the fireplace either that's why I am trying to figure it out what to do with it. I would like to make more clean modern look. I bought the house with the fireplace look like this and they told me that designer made it...and I agree it's not good at all.
4 months ago ·
anthip Could you get some matching black marble and some how fit a mantle so that section looks finished? Can you afford to have it re-covered? Boxed in?
4 months ago ·
annoulaxeni Well, I'm relieved to hear you aren't offended amibeauty because I was just feeling very bad that I might have hurt you.

I'll still go back to what I initially said but I'll phrase it differently: I am amazed often what professionals can do with spaces that seem to us laypeople not to hold much promise. So I hope for your sake that several of the more talented ones who haunt this site chime in.

Until then, however, let me look closer and try to offer more concrete suggestions:

I think my biggest problem with this wall is the black columns. I find them harsh in color, pretentious in design, and lacking in any 'aesthetic integrity' by which I mean that their design seems more to be about what cuts were easy for the granite guy to make than what column details and proportions have proven over time to remain pleasing.

The wall would improve greatly if they were to simply be removed. Would that be possible?

Secondly, I realize I'm distracted by the innards of the cupboards beneath the granite shelving, but perhaps wrongly so: are there doors for those cupboards? I think they'd help hugely to simply/clarify.

Third, I find the entire wall 'heavy' (optically) for what else I can see of the room. The room appears to have low ceilings and little or no trim. That's not necessarily bad -- but I don't think it works well with this sudden burst of busy-ness. I guess what I'm trying to say is that in general I think for this to work you need to simplify it as much as possible. Obviously that would include whatever you're thinking of adding to that upper part which, in my humble opinion, doesn't need much further adornment.

There, is this any more helpful? As cyn222 asked, what are you trying to achieve? What's your favorite style?
4 months ago ·
amibeauty Yes I was thinking close it make it even and than do some grey,black, white stones/ glass tiles maybe?
4 months ago · ·
Robert Guenther Collection I can get this for you if you want
4 months ago ·
amibeauty Thanks I can get them... I am trying to figure it out is it going to be good with them first
4 months ago ·
cyn222 You could remove the black and install a lighter tone that compliments the marble. You could also build wood columns that go up to the ceiling but I would keep them to the edge of the fireplace. Also maybe a mantle. Paint the top out and your done.
4 months ago ·
amibeauty Thanks that's an interesting idea. By the way they are doors for the bottom cabinets. They are remove right now because they refinishing them. They are white clean look
4 months ago ·
Sign Up to comment
The content on this page is provided by Houzz and is subject to the Houzz terms of use, copyright and privacy policy.
Copyright claims: contact the Houzz designated agent.