Painting perfectly good wood trim?
We are buying a small home that was built in 1962. It has wood trim throughout. Would it be a crime to paint it? It would also be a lot of work.
| Share: |
|
More Discussions
| Share: |
|
If your style is more traditional, I would recommend replacing the trim with new, wider and more detailed mouldings in a paint grade, and then I'd paint them. I would also replace the doors with a panelled style and paint them, and add new knobs and hinges.
If you want to keep the trim and doors, they're going to be a lot of work to prime and paint, and they won't look very decorative even when you're finished.
It depends on what feels best for you.
Sorry!
I think this house is a special case where it absolutely suits the architecture, and I hope Marilyn can work with it.
Cynthia, my decorating is very eclectic due to having inherited some nice antiques and also some more modern things. I remember the 70's well since I was in my 20's back then. I have no nostalgia for most of it. But I love color and am not afraid of it either. We will have color in this house. :)
I can't wait to see the floors refinished.
We replaced it at no small cost and I never regretted it.
The brick exterior had also been painted white.
We had it sandblasted off.
We sold it after owning it for less than 3 years. we put it on the market.
It sold in 21 days and we recovered our costs and made a substantial profit.
The only thing I'd add now would be some really beautiful drapes. Your pair of windows would look sooo elegant with nice rods and rings and pleated lined panels... I'm a curtain fanatic, so please forgive me since you didn't ask for comments... Here are some beauties!
But, it is the lack of neutral space in the area that has to be addressed. You could paint just the doors and leave the trim the color it is. Maybe you could do something fun and paint each door differently. Put a big number or name on each one. Or wall paper the area around the doors and paint the doors only in a complimentary color. Something bold like red, deep purple or black. Make a statement.
MOST IMPORTANTLY! KEEP YOUR BATHROOM DOOR SHUT!
Aja, I know that just because you have wood trim it doesn't mean you have to go to retro decor. It depends on what style of wood trim it is. In the example you showed, the trim is wide and detailed and historic looking, and it suits the elegant decor in the room. In Marilyn's house, the trim is narrow and streamlined and it's typical of a certain period and style of the 1960's. Retro style was new then and the interior furnishings complemented the architectural detail. So for an authentic look, this retro trim would look very much at home with retro decor. That was the point I was trying to make.
But this opens onto the other rooms which Margaret shared photos of (which are a little further down if you read all the messages on this thread). The hallway doors and trim cannot stand in isolation from the other areas of the house.
your point?
the same thing can be said of the second set of photos posted by Cynthia Taylor-Luce.
I strongly disagree.
The simplicity of the wood trim is what makes it so versatile.
You may be viewing it in the context of the 70's.
Many of us were not even born in the 70's. and therefore, bring no preconceived opinions to the discussion.
View it with a fresh eye.
We have a dialogue with the person who posted the question, and it's up to her to accept or reject our recommendations. The point is not to argue with or try to convince other people who post.
Furthermore, that is akin to suggesting wall to wall shag carpeting instead of wood floors.
Therefore, Aja, I should point out that you need to cease to addess personal comments to me because I won't see them anyway.
For older wood trim, my mother- in - law who still lives in her original 60's ranch home with this trim says wipe it down with vinegar and warm water.
I think it is lovely.
And what beautiful trees!!
And you are so right!!
65 years old is the new 55!
I find keeping up with my grandmum difficult.
♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥
Fantastic!!
But if you can have yours removed and donate it, I think that might be a good solution.
I just thought: the current plain molding is not near as good quality as what you have and the doors match the trim. Will you paint the doors, too? If you do the walls and ceiling yourself, you could hire a professional to refinish the trim.
I bet this house was painted white to sell it. With color on the walls, the natural trim will look a lot better.
So I am back to try to keep it.
Good luck!
Every room needs painting and of course the carpet needs to be torn up. The house has hardwood flooring except the kitchen. We will hire someone to refinish the floors. The bathroom needs a total rework. The window location interferes with the shower wall. I would like to replace the tub with a large walk in shower with an open area to the right so that the window would just be on an open wall. Maybe a built-in cabinet in the corner. I would like to see all of the bathroom walls in a white subway tile and a black and white ceramic floor. The toilet and the vanity should be replaced as well. I found a source for discount tile.
We will replace all of the kitchen cabinets and appliances ourselves. This will be our second diy iKea kitchen. We will either go with ceramic tiles on the kitchen floor or maybe a laminate tile. We should be able to redo the kitchen for under $8000. We also want to build a small banquette into the corner of the kitchen.
Lots of fun ahead. Thanks again for all of your input. I just believe that I want to go with white trim and I don't want to go to all of the work of prepping and painting the old narrow stuff . Painting it off the wall will be so much easier than doing it on hands and knees and then worrying about paint getting on the walls and floor and vice-a-versa. Also the sander won't be bumping into the trim when the floors are refinished.
So:
1. tear off all of the old trim, saving it as much as possible for donation.
2. Have the floors refinished.
3. Paint the new trim in the basement.
4. tape butcher paper to the new floors for protection.
5. Paint the walls.
6. install the new trim and touch up the nail holes.
Since you have decided to redo the trim, I would definately go for as wide as you can afford for the baseboard. Be sure to be careful with the carpentry--scarf (cut at an angle) and stagger the joints and cope the inside corners and miter the outside corners. Also traditional window framing vs. the more modern mitered framing is practical and actually easier to install, especially if things have settled a bit and are not perfectly square. The most recent issue of "Old House Journal" has an article on the topic. This might be a nice opportunity to install some deep window sills as well, which I really like, and to beef up the insulation around the existing windows, which is typically the source of draftiness, not the window itself.
Make sure you hire someone with experience in finish carpentry or do a careful job yourself. I would consider drawing out the details to scale to pick the right size and combination, and doing a test area before committing for the whole house.
I recently redid a room in my Victorian with 1x8 baseboards and 3/4 inch quarter round on top and shoemolding, which came close to the simple orignal moldings. Unfortunately I allowed my tenants to do the work to pay for back rent, and I will have to redo it because they used butt joints and it looks horrible, despite my instructions. Still an improvement over the horrible plastice skinny molding it replaced though. Lesson learned-- do your research and always supervise if you want it to be done right.
BTW, prepainted trim will still need to be painted or touched up after installation, especially if it is built up of multiple pieces. Keep the primer and first coat thin for the best results.
Where do you want your eyes to be drawn? As it is, all you see is what SHOULDN'T be the focus of your attention.
White walls are ok if they are a soft white. What I'm seeing is very sterile looking.
These are general guidelines and my opinion only.
Good luck.
Just for a trip down memory lane, here is a 1958 detail. House with the same narrow trim, same doors. The difference between that house and yours is that the walls were custom colors in flat paint, and the baseboards and moulding around the doors were painted to match in high gloss finish. Easier to wash the gloss finish with all the children folks had during the baby boomer years.
Congratulations on your new home, and best wishes to you and yours.
my thought is one should consider the three items together, floor/wall/trim....it should be one composition
Below are more pictures of the house we are buying and remodeling.
The L shaped upholstered banquette is a great idea.
Will the table be in the same colour beech as the counters?
Are you saying the floors and the walls won't be that lime green?
The black & white checkerboard tiled floor will be so cool.
Be sure to check out Schumacher for the fabric.
and your Saarinen Round Dining Table
You don't have to sell me on "outdoor" fabric!
The fabric you chose is great!
My grandmum taught me so sew at age 9. I can spend hours in a fabric store!
I worked one summer while in college at an upholstery shop and learned so much.
I designed and made my wedding gown with the help of of mom and grandmum.
It required hours of handwork.
Growing up, there was always one home where all of the kids hung out after school and on weekends.
I remember pizza and movies and a dozen kids cluttering the family room floor with pillows and blankets everywhere.
I remember pool parties and cook outs, and a kitchen in shambles as we waited for the next batch of cookies, yet somehow the home survived and to this day, I love to visit.
You don't see those homes in the magazines, but that is the kind of home I want to make.
Go to the Houzz page where the photo is displayed.
Copy and paste the URL into your comment box on the thread.
Picture of breakfast area I like.
Still didn't work. This is all that posts. Do I have to click on upload a picture also? I do use a MAC.
Traditional Kitchen design by Chicago Kitchen And Bath The Kitchen Studio of Glen Ellyn
"So:
1. tear off all of the old trim, saving it as much as possible for donation.
2. Have the floors refinished.
3. Paint the new trim in the basement.
4. tape butcher paper to the new floors for protection.
5. Paint the walls.
6. install the new trim and touch up the nail holes."
Tanks for the door treatment idea. I lived "mid-century" and really don't want to return there. I have no good feelings about the period design-wise though we had a pair of Eames recliners that we loved.