powered by
Design Dilemma
Design Dilemma

need help with staircase design - replacing carpet

olivjoshJanuary 19, 2013
have dark maple smooth hardwood adjacent to tile flooring on main floor
intende to use dark hardwood on staircases and on 2nd floor
need to figure out a ways to design staircases which will complement
how to do risers- dark wood or white or tile
how to transition from bannisters etc
have 2 staircases one leading up to landing on 2nd floor from kitchen and 2nd one leading to upstairs landing from main entry- this is the one with the curved stairs. will the curved stairs need to be custom?
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Cancork Floor Inc.
Wow! I have the perfect cork floating floor that can be installed over stairs. You glue down the planks to the stair subfloor. The colour is called "Sunny Ripple" and it would be a beautiful compliment to the stained wood banister and trim and black metal accents!

My other option would be "Gemwood" which is an African black wood mimic!

I would then install the Sunny Ripple bevelled edge product (same colour but with a bevelled edge to mimic a hardwood plank) as the "dark hardwood" upstairs
    Bookmark   January 19, 2013 at 9:01AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Interiors International, Inc.
The cork is not a bad idea. However do not tile the risers. It will look odd.
2 Likes    Bookmark   January 19, 2013 at 9:05AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Barbara Griffith Designs
Cork would work, choose a color that is a shade mid-way between the color of the tile floor and the wood on the bannister.
    Bookmark   January 19, 2013 at 9:18AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Heather M
what does the "nosing" look like with cork? I've heard cork has a short life span. Is that a concern on stairs?
    Bookmark   January 19, 2013 at 9:24AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Cancork Floor Inc.
Cork "nosing" is not something you want for this. It rarely comes in colours other than "cork board" and can be more expensive than the flooring on stairs (it starts at $8/linear foot and it is DEAD-DOG ugly!). Stick with an oak trim that is stained to a complimentary colour. You will never regret going with oak.

Cork's lifespan can and has been over 100 years! US Library of congress has a cork floor that is now 150 years old. It is the owners' lack of proper maintenance that lowers the lifespan of any wood floor. Salespeople are strongly to blame for cork's lack of up-keep! I've spoken to 100s of flooring sales people over the last 2 years and less than a dozen of them know how to "sell" cork let alone maintain it. Only 3 sales people knew how/when to maintain a cork floor!!! That's less than 3% of all cork sales have had proper instructions from the point-of-sale people. I end up "fixing" the problems of "other people's" cork. But I don't mind...I love cork and will help anyone save the cork they have! I might lose a sale but I gain a friend.

Ok, that being said, cork flooring on a stair is considered a "low slip" surface. Once it is installed, you will need to refresh the finish of the cork every 5-7 years. This is done by adding 1 coat of water based polyurethane over the factory finish. You would repeat this maintenance for the 25+ lifespan of the cork.

Please be aware that some of the high-end cork floors (read: $6-$12/sf) have "ceramic" finishes OR Aluminum Oxide finishes. The salespeople will TELL you it has a lifetime wear-through warranty, but the reality is they still show wear and tear - micro scratches and filming because of scratches. The Aluminum Oxide finish (which is a health hazard for the installers because of the dust) is the most expensive and can NEVER be refreshed. Once it hazes (and it will), there is NO FIX! But...you will never 'wear through" to the cork!

And Wicander's Aluminum Oxide/Ceramic finishes are NOT ALLOWED to be sealed...they can not go in kitchens or bathrooms or entrance ways!!! AND they require frequent waxing (every 6 months) to maintain the warranty on this "Life Time Finish".

Makes you wonder!
    Bookmark   January 19, 2013 at 10:03AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Paint the risers white. We did that (with oak treads - sorry, no help there!), and it looks really sharp.
    Bookmark   January 19, 2013 at 11:32AM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
Ironwood Builders
You have a "captured staircase, that is, the skirtboards on the wall and below the balustrade are solid to the tread, not open, where you can see the edge of the tread and riser from the hall. The skirt, or baseboard of the stair system is already painted, so a painted riser would transition easily. I do think the transition from your wrought iron balustrade and oak bannister is a bit stark with the white skirt board. Depends on what the trim paint is in the rest of the area, doesn't it. We see a lot of white painted trim....consider the hall and stair as a separate area and paint the trim a different color...perhaps a taupe that will compliment your dark wood floors and new treads. If there is no millwork break between rooms, that is, traditional cased openings, the options narrow. The curved treads will need to be custom. Your hardwood flooring contractor can usually handle the installation. One issue in the use of engineered flooring is that the curved stairs will not happen. Real wood treads stained and finished to match are the only real option. Cork is not. If not, there are contractors that specialize in stairs, check your local listings, Yellow Pages actually still works!

Generally, any transition from tile to wood is a break in finish...that means that wood changes shape with moisture and season and masonry, i.e. tile...does not. There are some pretty sophisticated caulks out there that try to deal with the issue, more or less effectively depending on cost. Then you have to decide where the paint to tile transition happens...caulking is round by nature and wood and tile are square, therefore the paint to tile transition becomes more focal. So maybe no to tile risers?

Best of luck with your project! Let us know how it comes out!
    Bookmark   January 19, 2013 at 12:24PM
Sign Up to comment
Related Discussions
Need help choosing paint colors and floors/carpet
We own this English Tudor building with 8 suites. Three...
Need Help with Hard Floor Options Now That Carpet Has to be Replaced
I have a similar issue to the poster here, who posted...
Staircase carpeting
I wanted to know what you thought this staircase with...
Need help with staircase
Our entranceway is all wood, the stairs, upstairs large...
Need help with Staircase Design.
Floor to floor height is 9' between 2 floors 3rd and...
Devang Dadbhawala
More Discussions
U.S. Ceramics 3x6 compared to Daltile 3x6 subway tile.
We used U.S. Ceramics 3 x 6 subway tile in our kitchen....
Marilyn Wilkie
Green carpet dilemma!
We currently have gold on our walls. We r planning...
Dana Ellis
Day and night. When is better?
Your design may look absolutely different in day time...
Vanguard development LA
Blinds / screens for sliding doors
I have two sets of sliding doors. I need coverings...
Log Cabin Reclaimed
Finally get to build my own cabin,Core 10 roof,400...
Derrick Budd
People viewed this after searching for:
The content on this page is provided by Houzz and is subject to the Houzz terms of use, copyright and privacy policy.
Copyright claims: contact the Houzz designated agent.