Home of the San Francisco Chronicle

Subscribe to the weekend Chronicle

powered by
Discussions
Photos
Products
Ideabooks
Discussions
Professionals
Users
by kayanee
3 months ago in Design Dilemma
If you were me, would you distress this antique piece?
I LOVE the look of antique furniture that has been painted and distressed - sort of the farmhouse, French country look. You know, a little old teal paint peaking out, maybe some white, etc - while still seeing sanded parts of the wood color. I got this buffet at a steal, only $200 - it's not a family heirloom or anything and I'm seriously thinking of distressing it but I'm having a hard time convincing myself to attack it. Do you think it would look good distressed?
Share:
 
Aggie Purvinska It's certainly very beautiful as is! If you like the distressed look, go for it, the only problem I see that there are lots of flat areas and the distressed look needs a bit of a "tooth", like the ornate areas, to look good. The beauty of the figured veneer will be replaced by paint, so that's something to keep in mind.
3 months ago · ·
Design & Decor By Shelley Oh my this is a beautiful piece indeed..Please do not paint it..The wood grain is so beautiful. My advise is if you would like to try distressing an antique find a piece that isn't in the greatest condition and try restoring it with a painted distressed look..This piece is much to beautiful to paint..Just my 2 cents..
3 months ago · ·
michigammemom I'm with Decor by Shelley. The wood grain is the basic appeal of this piece. I'm guessing you could easily make a profit on this lovely antique if you preserve the original finish.
3 months ago · ·
kayanee Thank you ladies, I do like the tiger oak, I think you've convinced me to leave it as is. I like the suggestion of finding another piece in not so great shape and experimenting on it...
3 months ago · ·
Jayme Hobbs I also feel that it is too nice to paint...glad of the choice you have made!
3 months ago ·
bubblyjock It's a late 19th century, early 20th century piece, North American (so really not French country, or farmhouse either - sorry!). Not particularly unique or valuable, and if it has no emotional meaning to you (i.e., family heirloom), then feel free to do with it as you choose.

It looks to be in great condition, and has some fine features, like the feet and some of the wood turning, and the wood grain itself, which has been carefully matched one side to the other, for a pleasing symmetry if you like that sort of thing (they did back then - it's all about the taste and style and fashion of the time, right!). Sometimes the original manufacturers' stickers are still on the back or the base, or the underside of a drawer.

It's not my taste (I prefer Georgian), but I certainly wouldn't distress it - I'd flip it to someone who appreciates its qualities for what they are (imagine it in a sweet little Arts & Crafts home, with all that old oak trim), and buy something with less quality if I wanted to beat it up and play with various "paint effects"!

As D&DBS says.....just my 2 cents....
3 months ago · ·
Fix It NOW!, Corp. This IS a beautiful piece! And you got it for a great price as well. I agree with both of the ladies above. It would be a shame to destroy such a well preserved piece, but if you have your heart on painting it, I would suggest the following:
-First clean the entire piece with paint thinner and fine steel wool to remove any dirt and wax.
-Paint the buffet with a good coat of shellac. This will keep the paint from seeping into the wood completely, in case you ever want to go back to the wood grain.
-Then paint, possibly thinning the paint a little to reduce brush marks and provide a very smoothe finish, applying a second coat if needed, or a second color.
-Then I would lightly sand off some of the high points, like on the decorative moldings and the edges. If you've used a second color, make sure that you're exposing some of both colors, and down to the wood in some places.
-If you go down to the wood in some places, you may want to consider clear coating the entire piece to protect those areas. If you don't like the glossy effect of the clear coat, you can rub the whole thing down with fine steel wool and wax, and then buff.

Good luck! It would be fun to see a picture of the finished product.
3 months ago · ·
Design & Decor By Shelley I thought I would attach a picture of a pretty little dresser that has been distressed..You may want to start small..As I mentioned find something that needs re-finishing..Good Luck..
I would certainly value bubblyjock's knowledge of this piece..The $$ value may not be substantial however, it is still very beautiful and if it fits with the rest of your decor just leave it in all it's splendor..
3 months ago · ·
kayanee That is the look I like, I'll just keep hitting my salvation army and see what pops up! I find great buys there!
3 months ago ·
bubblyjock @ Shelley - did you - dunno what to call it - re-finish that greeny-blue chest of drawers? It's gorgeous - and must have been a lot of work!
3 months ago · ·
bubblyjock @ kayanee - look what I found!

http://chrissiescollections.blogspot.ca/2012/07/milk-painted-bufet-turquoise.html

Hope that helps you decide (I really dislike that "distressed" effect on that buffet in the link - just too contrived - jmo).
3 months ago · ·
Design & Decor By Shelley @ bubblyjock, No I am afraid not..I saw this piece for sale..You are right it would have been alot of work but of course the end result is well worth the sweat..
My intention was to display what beautiful results you can achieve when distressing furniture..
3 months ago · ·
bubblyjock Ah - thanks.

I think the piece of furniture chosen - obviously enough - has an affect on the final look. The piece you posted - 18th century French-ish - looks very good indeed, whereas the piece I posted - imo it was too clunky to pretend to look well-used (oak is simply too tough to ever become distressed!), and she'd really wrecked it with wildly inappropriate handle thingies, etc.
3 months ago · ·
Design & Decor By Shelley @bubblyjock..I agree! Keep it simple!
3 months ago ·
Patricia Pelgrims It is a beautiful piece of furniture. Too good to paint it IMO.
We have lots of aniques (farmhouse style) in our house and I have been toying with the idea of painting some. Up till now I haven't had the courage and I don't think I will bother, because the wood that has been used is so beautiful.
To offset the furniture, I painted my walls in a cream/almond colour instead and used some bright coloured object d'art and vintage glassware to decorate the dressers.

If it would be a small-ish piece of furniture, cheap and cheerful, that is an other thing all together.
3 months ago · ·
kayanee @bubblyjock....Oh yeah, now I see I don't want to paint it!!! wow.....that even looks somewhat like my buffet before it was painted. I'd like to try my hand at some small pieces, little chests, etc . And I agree on the handles that were used, too distracting.
3 months ago · ·
pinkbs101 YES YES DO IT. You can always refinish it if you don't like! Throw caution to the wind and do it , I finally did a big piece in my home and I love it!!
3 months ago ·
Barnhart Gallery It may be American, but the fleur de lis is iconic French, so it's a nice choice for you, and a great bargain with that lovely grain. I'm not a huge fan of oak unless it has an exceptional grain, and this does. I hope you can make it work as is, and yes, experiment on something else. Totally your call though; do what will make you happy.
3 months ago · ·
Sign Up to comment
The content on this page is provided by Houzz and is subject to the Houzz terms of use, copyright and privacy policy.
Copyright claims: contact the Houzz designated agent.