sluggodog Hi there, not sure what your budget is, I would take out the shelving/brackets and put thicker, wood shelves, stain (can't tell if the wood can be stained from the picture) or paint it dark and put a new insert and mantel. I like the brick, it has a modern feel to it - and you can work with it for sure.
LM Designers Your brick is nice so I wouldn't change that. I would put in built in cabinets on each side with a painted finish to break up all the wood. You will gain storage and totally change the look.
sluggodog Gorgeous kitchen ! -- has more traditional elements vs modern, so I can see where the dark wood around the fireplace may not work with this look. Can you see the fireplace from the kitchen? And was there a budget you were thinking of ?
groveraxle I would start by removing all the tchotchkes from the fireplace and the shelves. Remove the mantel and hang the mirror. Style the shelves with modern objet d'art mixed among photos and books. Replace the black chair with something sleek and modern. That may be enough to update the look.
Interiors International, Inc. I love the look of sluggodog right side picture. It is very much what I was picturing. The stone is good on yours you just need a beefier mantel. Then loose the cheap looking shelves for ones more substantial like in the picture.
sluggodog Can you get the people who did your kitchen to quote you on some custom cabinets around the fireplace. Cost wise you might not be able to do all the way up both sides of the fireplace, but new bottom cabinets with glass to match the ones in the kitchen (maybe on a couple of doors). Then you can still do open shelving across the top. Ideally a new fireplace insert would be nice, but you can always buy a screen across the front -- there are some gorgeous one out there. If you do the open shelving, instead of painting behind the shelves, there are some gorgeous fabric wall papers -- some more ideas to throw at ya. :-) The first one is a bamboo wallpaper.
DIRECTBUY OF FORT WORTH Emser Tile has a couple of porcelain tiles that would like great on that wall and cover that stone. Eurasia or perspectives in the 12x24 size..
kayasmomma Love the stone, don't love the mirror. Paint the wood paneling a white/cream. Is there a reason your couch is covering an entrance to this room? Maybe some nice lighting as well!
handymam I agree that the fireplace is lovely as it is. It does have a modern look. Its the shelves and wall that are dated. Paint the walls and get new shelves. Lovely home!
Maybe some nice lighting as well!
rnthomas ~ do you have some ideas for what you want to do with this space?