Should I paint my custom, solid wood kitchen cabinets?
We have lived in our 100 year old home for four years. I am redoing my kitchen and would love a light airy look. My cabinets are custom made by the previous owner and I hate the color of the stain on the solid wood. I don't know what kind of wood was used but the color is awful. As you can tell in the picture, I have a lot of cabinets (27) and drawers (11) and the color of the wood is overpowering! Everything that I've done so far to lighten the look of my kitchen has not worked very effectively and I am stuck. Please let me know if I should take the plunge and paint the cabinets to achieve the look I want. Thanks
| Share: |
|
More Discussions


If not replacing countertops for now, I'd go with a creamy off-white.
If you aren't prepared to do all the work it takes to paint them properly, then hire someone.
Purge items that aren't needed and re-organize to declutter your counters. Change the hardware.
The painting will take years off the look of the kitchen. Good Luck.
I'll add my vote to getting rid of the scalloped trim. You could cut it off or add some crown molding over it. New light fixtures would help, too.
Yes do paint them but know that oak will need filling and sanding to get a smooth finish.Loads of prep work.
good luck
I used the Rustoleum kit in my last house, it took a bit of time, but came out beautiful. For pretty pictures of white kitchens and the reasons to paint, go to Maria Killam's blog.
the paint became soft in places where fingers touch around the pulls. I would do it different if again.
Personally, I think a dark stain, maybe more opaque to mask the wood grain would be great. Black would be stunning. Upgrade the countertops, replace the hardware and light fixtures, add more lighting, and you will have a showplace of a kitchen. Black would work with the age and character of your home, with white and an accent color. That would look updated and fresh as well.
Painting the cabnets an antique ivory or off white, replacing the handles withones that are simpthetic to the look you choose, if your unsure search the different themes in houzz to decide. Replacing the splash back will also bring the look together. Replce the ceiling light and I think you'll be very happy.good luck, have fun. Jenny.
Good luck - it's quite a job whichever you choose.
And then I would paint the island!
(Sorry - I'm a gemini - I always like both answers!)
Another thought - do you really need that much counter space? Could you remove/reconfigure a few cabinets to make them a pantry, i.e.stack two or three? You loose counter but keep the storage and end up with more room in the other part of the room - dining area?
Of course if all that is more work than painting the cupboards - paint it all. But then I would have 2 colours - perimeter one colour and island a different colour. Or all uppers lighter and all lowers including island darker.
Any way you choose, have fun and enjoy your (almost) new kitchen!
The best finish is that performed by a professional painter.
good luck
Like this one! It has yellow walls too.
It will look beautiful with your back splash which disappears now. I would also change the fan over the island, if the room needs a fan for ventilation then get one that hugs the ceiling and is close to ceiling color so it doesn't draw your eye up.
Hope this helps
Christine
You initially indicated that you inherited the cabinets from the previous owners that likely installed them in the 80's judging by the wood, details, and traditional overlay style with exposed hinges. Other tale tale signs are the vinyl flooring, ceiling fan, white appliances and laminate counter tops with wood edging. I can tell that you have no sentimental attachment to those cabinets. Having been in the cabinet industry for many years, I can tell you there is no guarantee that they are better because they were custom made. The construction process is different and may actually be substandard to many modular constructed factory made cabinets. With cabinets, you get what you pay for whether custom or factory made. I'm guessing the ones you have are pretty sturdy and you are not unhappy with the layout, or you would probably be considering a remodel rather than repainting. Or --your solution of painting may be strictly budget motivated. If this is so (as another poster indicated), this may not be the cheapest resolution if you want it done right and if you are paying someone else to do it. I'm surprised no one has yet mentioned refacing as an option that can be done to either change the wood look or a painted look. This is a solution that is in between painting and replacing when it comes to price.
I'm amazed at how many people thought it would be a travesty to paint over wood --especially those who suggested you stain them a dark color when you clearly stated you wanted light and airy.... jeesh! That oak recessed door that you have may not be the bottom of the barrel in actual quality, but I can tell you if you go to a big box store to purchase cabinets, there are two types that are the cheapest: White thermofoil (a shrink wrapped plastic white over particle board) and oak recessed panel doors that look like yours. Oak is the go-to for contractors and developers who want a wood look in moderately priced subdivisions and flip houses because it is cheap and they are banking on the public believing that because it's wood it's better.
How well the finish lasts, whether you paint or stain has a lot to do with the material. If it's water based, paint and stain tend to wear off more quickly --especially in areas that are exposed to water. The one good thing about paint is that you can always touch up. As I mentioned in my first post, semigloss is easier to maintain than matte finish because it doesn't show finger prints, absorb oil, and is easier to wipe clean.
You mentioned that you wanted to "lighten the look" of your kitchen, not necessarily update the look. As others have stated, eliminating the clutter will go a long way to achieving that goal. If you want to update the look, there are a lot of other things that need changing as others have mentioned -from switching out the light fixtures and appliances to replacing the counter tops and flooring. Whatever you do, make sure it is something you can live with. A good interior designer is worth their weight in gold if their motivation is meeting your objectives and not serving their own agenda. If you can afford it, you might consider hiring a design professional to help. They can actually save money by helping you to make savvy purchases and obtain services of quality and value than you can on your own.
Christine
Neverendingroom
845-988-7354
I did add crown molding years back as they had no tops & that made big difference.
I have 1940s wedgewood stove so am using inspiration from recent Houzz pic of Julia Child's kitchen!
Go with your gut & do what you like..if you can afford it :)
We changed a couple of the cabinets to allow for a couple new appliances. New counters, backsplash, sink, faucet, grass cloth and paint on the walls...a huge transformation. Trust me...you'll be ever so glad.
pulls. They look great, I have painted the ceiling a pale pale light blue. Frani916.
I've only convince hubby to let me paint the Kids' bath room linen cabinet and the breakfast nook wainscot. Cabinets are a pain to paint but so worth it.
What you can do is to change the color of the cabinets is to use a tinted varathane type of finish. Oak has a tendancy to yellow/gold over time. If you have a cabinet door somewhere that you can experiment on the backside, find a paint store like Daly's in Seattle and have them tint some varnish or varathane or (?). You can maintain the wood look using this process. You can change the color to almost a paint look with multiple coats. You cannot make a brown cabinet light in color using this technique, but you can take a lighter oak and darken it. We have done this when when we stain some wood and we cannot get it dark enough, we then put coats of finish on to work it to the desired color.
[houzz=
im knee deep in a kitchen reno in my current house (second pic) and while painting the cabinets seemed like a lot of work back then? i can honestly say it was WAY easier then this!! full gut kitchen renos in my opinion are what hell on earth feels like!
if u like your layout and the cabinets are solid? PAINT THEM! and consider yourself lucky!
[houzz=Custom Pull-Out Mixer Stand][houzz=Light Farm-Kitchen][houzz=Debra Campbell Design][houzz=Bistro Style Kitchen]
Be sure to properly prepare before painting this would include wiping clean and light sanding, a good primer is next and depending on the quality of paint it may take several coats with light sanding between each coat including the prime coat. I would recommend doing both sides of the door which in any case should be removed from the hinges as well as the hinges themselves. The frame should be done the same way, you may also want to consider doing the inside of the cabinets as well.
Another alternative may be pickling or a glaze wash, which may be less labor intensive then painting it.
Plan on a protective coat as a final coat.
For more information visit a local paint center and ask them, some may have brochures on faux finishing techniques which may prove useful if you go the pickling or glaze wash route.
Wishing you the best on your project.
-Richard