Raised panel or flat?
Attached is present kitchen and design for new kitchen and image of (overlay) cabinet front with molding and color that we are using. I am trying to decide 1)if I should add a raised panel to the doors and 2)If I can put the molding along the edge of the 36" drawers which will be stacked: 5", 10", 10". (i.e. molding would be around edges of drawers with nothing in center if we go with flat panel), or try something like attached photo of stacked drawers.
Thanks for ideas!
Thanks for ideas!
| Share: |
|
More Discussions


The drawer fronts look more detailed with moldings s shown.
This kitchens has so many wonderful possibilities in detail. I love it.
I'll try to answer your questions. First I'd like to clarify some terms. Molding is applied to the outside of the door or drawer or the inside of the stile and rails. Stiles and rails are not applied to the door in most cases but are the door along with the inside panel which is either raised or flat. (See image) (image credit www.waltzcraft.com)
Door and drawer styles (as opposed to 'stiles') can be mixed in a kitchen but there should be some coherence between them. In the end, if it is done right, unless a person is really looking at the finer details, he/she won't even notice those differences. The whole kitchen will FEEL comfortable and right. Those differences though have a huge impact on that FEEL by giving it texture, depth and visual interest and harmony and will produce a flush of feeling. The average person won't know where that feeling comes from. They might interpret it as layout or color or 'taste' but it's much more than that. It's lies in bringing all different elements together and making them fit together like they belong together.
Now to address your question about drawers 5", 10" and 10". Whether you CAN use a raised panel or flat panel or whether you can use molding outside or inside the stiles and rails depends on the widths of the stiles rails. If the style you choose uses 2 1/4" stiles and rails, which is typical--one on the top and one on the bottom, that totals 4 1/2" inches, leaving only 1/2" for a flat panel. Obviously that would look ridiculous and be a catchall for dirt. So there are two ways to address this. If these cabinets are custom made (and I hope they are) you can have a solid blank on the 5" drawer or you can request that the rails be made thinner than the 10" drawer stiles and rails. If you were to go with 1 1/4" rails, that would add up to 2 1/2", leaving you 2 1/2" for a flat panel. A raised panel will not fit in 2 1/2". Your 10" drawers could have the normal 2 1/4" stile and rails and that would leave you with 5 1/2" for a flat or a raised panel. The 'raise' of the panel differs in different door styles. Between the stile and rail and the raised part of the door might be 1", 1 1/4", 2" etc. If you were to go with a 1" space to the raised part of the panel all around, the flat part of the raised panel would be 3 1/2" and perfectly acceptable. (10"-2 1/4"-2 1/4"-1"-1"). Notice that in the picture, the rail is smaller than on the door.
If you have a full overlay door, which means no part of the cabinet frame is showing, you will have more room to express the door style (The top drawer would be more than 5"). The more cabinet frame that is showing the smaller the drawers and doors. That would give you more options to use use the molding on the inside of the stiles and rails.
Do I understand correctly that the color of the whole kitchen is the silver distressed door? It looks silver on my screen. Is that actually the color?
Also, the set of blue drawers can be mixed with a raised panel door but I would put the same molding in them. (They are called a 5 piece drawer with a flat panel)
If you tell the cabinet maker what you want to do, he will be able to tell you if it will work.
This is going to be a beautiful kitchen and I love all the details!
Also, there will be toe kick. I measured the induction pots we'll be getting and nothing is higher than 7 3/4 inches. The drawing is inaccurate here. Only 3 drawers. Sorry, I don't know what a false front is, but what we're doing seems to work. Again, thanks so much for sharing your thoughts... I hope you'll weigh in on the distressing!
2) in a small drawer, there isn't often room for a raised panel. the rails can be modified as explained above, but still very tight. It also limits the size handle you can use as the "footprint" can be too large and they won't seat properly.
3) an applied molding can create a deep well on a small front, that when using a shallow knob or handle can actually jam your fingers.
4) there is quite a bit of detail in this kitchen concept, so like others have suggested I'd go with a flat panel door. You can always add additional appliques to that panel.
5) get a professional to build this kitchen. they will adjust the finer details and transitions so that everything with fit properly & work efficiently as with comment above regarding kick plates etc.
Senior Designer~Urbana, Victoria, BC
I'm anxious to see your color sample! And will check back.
Personally I feel the quantity of detail is consistent with a kitchen of this design, and I wouldn't hesitate to use both flat and raised panel as in the pictures; such as flat panel where the knobs wouldn't otherwise fit properly and raised panel where they would fit. But to each his own.
@Ironwood. Thanks.
@wowww. An applique is a decorative carving that is added before the cabinets are finished and really shows up well when a glaze is applied.
Raymond Enkeboll designes, carry the best products I have seen.http://www.shopenkebolldesigns.com/legacy.html
Another good company is Outwater Plastics
http://www.outwatercatalogs.com/lg_display.cfm/catalog/Master_2012/page/508
I'm also wondering if anyone has an idea for what to put above the backsplash, under the hood. If you look at the rendering at the top of this discussion you'll see the design we plan to use for the marble backsplash above the cooktop, but we've actually planned to keep painted drywall btwn the backsplash and the cabinets and hang the antique plates you can see in the photo of the present kitchen.
Appliques are often used on range hoods, at the top or around the bottom, or in the center front, or front corners of range hoods. A vertical applique could be use on the wall corner cabinet.
Carved 'aprons' can be used at the bottom of range hoods. The pictures are of aprons from Raymond Enkeboll. They can be cut to fit and can be used at the bottom of any cabinet as long as enough space is left for the toe kick. Nice places to use them are under cabinets that are focal pieces, sink bases, stovetop bases, at the bottom of island cabinets or pantry cabinets.
There are many more applications. If you go to the Enkeboll site and click on "Showcase" you can see how things are used.
http://www.sonomatilemakers.com/brochures/STM_9.pdf
www.whiteriverinc.com
The rest of the pictures are from White River Inc.
Pic 1: appliques are used over the sink and refrigerator White River Hardwoods 800-558-0119 | Kitchen Gallery | Hardwood Mouldings & Arch 1
Pic 2: over the sink. Also, carved legs are used on either side of the sink cabinet. They can also be used on either side of the stovetop cabinet, or on the island. White River Hardwoods 800-558-0119 | Kitchen Gallery | Hardwood Mouldings & Arch 2
Pic 3: on either side of the open cabinet (in your kitchen, they could be used on either side of the island drawer cabinets. White River Hardwoods 800-558-0119 | Kitchen Gallery | Hardwood Mouldings & Arch 3
Pic 4: Corbells (the carved braces on the left) and heavy legs on the left (Corbells could be used under the range hood while the heavy legs could be used on the island) White River Hardwoods 800-558-0119 | Kitchen Gallery | Hardwood Mouldings & Arch 4
Not all of these components go together. But if a person likes one or two, other components can be picked out to match and bring everything together.
I made the first one, but they can be purchased. Rev-A-Shelf makes the one in the second picture. Probably other companies do as well.
If that is the case, you have a flat panel on the top and a raised panel on the bottom. The moldings appear to be quite different. Are you saying this is the drawer that the manufacturer suggests with that door?
Cost might be an issue, but if the manufacturer is willing to do it, do you think you would prefer to have the drawer look the same as the door (turned sideways) except with a flat panel? so that the moldings would look the same? The 'meat' around the outside of the drawer should be thinner than the door, so there would be enough flat panel on the inside.
This drawer is different than the blue doors at the top. Is the picture of the blue drawers at the top just to show that the cabinet style is 'inset'? or do you actually prefer the way the drawer front looks?
Here is a diagram showing what I see in my mind when you speak of molding on the drawer.
The other two drawers are just regular drawers except the same piece of molding was put on on the top of the drawer is now the inside of a part of a drawer.They are like the SECOND and THIRD drawers in the blue picture you posted on top. The second picture shows you how they did this.
Do I understand correctly that the look you want is like the second and third drawer down on the blue picture you posted? So that it looks thicker around the edge of the drawer?
If you wanted it to look thicker around the edge like in the blue picture you posted, I would suggest that you:
1). Ask them if they can make a 10" door in the style you have chosen. If they can do that, then you should be able to get a 10" drawer that looks just like the door with either a raised or flat panel.
2) The top drawer is too small to do that. Just as in the blue picture you have posted. If you look close you will see that it is different. That's because it's too small to do what they did on the bottom two drawers. You can get a 'flat panel' drawer front, just like the top drawer in the blue picture--where molding was applied around the outside (and if they do that, it should look like the same molding they used on the doors you have picked).
If they can't do those things, I would stick with what they have recommended to go together.
Hope that helps.
As far as the cabinets being inset in design, they would have to hold back the drawer front a little bit from the front of the cabinets if the molding was too deep so that the molding was what was flat or nearly flat against the edge of the cabinet.
We're making progress though.
On the brown drawers. is this what you would like the bottom two drawers to look like?
Fabulous. Very unique. I love it! I compliment you for your vision and Quality for offering this style.
The top drawer looks squashed--that is why the trim looks narrower on the top and bottom--but I think this is enough to get the idea.
I would definitely ask for a mock up though to make sure it is exactly what you are looking for and that the trim is handled the way you envision it. The mock up should include the cabinet front and three drawer fronts. It will cost something for the mock up but would definitely be worth it. If you are paying for the mock up, tell them you want to keep it. That way you will have it to compare other purchases with for color and style.
So now, if we go back to talking about the perimeter doors and drawers again, the drawers are designed like the door fronts: molding "centered" with flat panel. I considered putting the molding on the perimeter of the drawer (like the island drawers) ONLY on the TOP drawers along the perimeter EXCEPT the three drawers under the cooktop. After drawing them both ways (which I kept erasing unfortunately), I thought the drawers looked best all the same, like the door fronts. You're great at mixing styles. What do you think?
So that means the 4 drawers on the left of the sink, the same 4 drawers that will be put on the dishwasher which is to the left of the sink, and the 2 bigger drawers below the cooktop. What do you think? :-)
Quality's way of handling it has probably been designed to fit the product line they have designed and may be a great one. Before deciding though, you'd have to nail down the perimeter design. If you decide to put the cabinet door on one, I would suggest thinking about matching it with the perimeter cabinets. Just a suggestion.