Mary Poulos Interior and Exterior Design I would stay with a traditional silver frame. Rectangular to balance the cabinet below. and to go with the faucets.
green_tea00 You should probably go for oval mirror with a small silver frame or if you want to add more color you could get an oval mirror with no border and paint a preferably blue design around it.
http://www.potterybarn.com/products/7710833/?catalogId=41&bnrid=3382507&cm_ven=MSN%20Shopping&cm_cat=Shopping&cm_pla=Feed&cm_ite=MSN%20Shopping