SFGate

michigammemom I would suggest leaving the front gable unadorned.

handymam I really think the star screams something you are not trying to say. The house, which is absolutely gorgeous, appears craftman, but the star says country. It detracts from the beauty.

I think that house design is just perfect otherwise. Would love to own that home!

wmpj When I see a star like that, I think of Texas. I think you can only get away with it if you live in Texas. Since this is for publication, I'd suggest getting rid of the star.

violinist3713 I would get rid of the star and add the false window. I agree with wmpj:the star reminds me of texas

dbdecorate I like the idea of putting in the window, like the one over the garage. It would balance out the gables and not make it look like some kind of product placement advertising, which I believe the star creates.

SPACIALISTS It boils down to clients preference, so it works both ways depending on your clients needs. I would recommend removing it.

CMR Interiors & Design Consultations Inc. Replace with a window

johnsoncab Yup.......Texas. Use a false window for publication.

Michael Kilpatrick Design Open it up as an opening - no window and then vault up the ceiling over the porch so that light will spill down into the porch and the front door and windows. Paint the vault a white that is lighter than your trim color.

lindylou2 False window to match the one over the garage to add symmetry. Beautiful house!

Judy M Either way, just lose the star.

kmkh "if I stay there will be trouble, if I go it will be double"

The Clash had it right - if it stays it will be double (trouble)

Kieran J. Liebl, Royal Oaks Design, Inc. MN Kathy, best comment yet!

Eileen A. go!

246butterfield False window and get rid of the star. Beautiful home

JWinteriors Replace with false window.

JUL313 Gallery I am from Texas --and yes it screams Texas. Have you thought about opening it up? I am not sure how to explain,,, but leave your original concept there and make it an open triangle, perhaps with some rafters in it for a design. I am a painter not an architect, so I am sure you are mildly confused at what I am trying to say.

Kieran J. Liebl, Royal Oaks Design, Inc. MN I get what your saying. Thanks!

DIAspoton star bad. window good. vaulted ceiling for more natural light in the house = best.
killer facade.

Stoneshop Yes, get rid of the star. It is too taste specific.

BEAUTIFUL rendering, by the way!

Jeff Hibbard Design Services Perhaps replace the star w/ an oval window. That allows you to keep the extended
gable end and brackets.which I like. Is the rendering done on softplan?

Jayme Hobbs "And so you've got to let me knnnooowww....., My answer is a wiinnddowww!"

eggfoosushi The star as it currently looks has got to go.
The design is nice. I think the main aesthetic problem with the star emblem is that the colour is such a contrast to the rest of the house it makes it stand out in a bad way. Only the star, the chimmney and the front window baskets are coloured in a contrasting burgundy brickish red against the rather bland yellowy green tones of the rest of the property. It may be worth altering some aspects of the colour scheme slightly

tkclifford Bye-Bye star!!

The Color People Unless you live in Texas, lose the star. In Texas its cool.