Home of the San Francisco Chronicle

Subscribe to the weekend Chronicle

powered by
Discussions
Photos
Products
Ideabooks
Discussions
Professionals
Users
by fall50
3 months ago in Design Dilemma
Butting up 2 different hardwood floors
We have the orginal white oak hardwood floors throughout the first floor of the house. With the exception of the kitchen.

The kictehn is small only 125 sqft with apprx only 80 sqft showing as the rest is hidden by the cabinets.

We are considering using engineered hard wood for the kitchen floor Meaning two different species of wood be butting up against one another

I have heard varying opinions on butting up two dissimilar wood floors to one another. What is anyone’s experience with this?

Any input or suggestions would be appreciated?
Share:
 
gerryanne I definitely would not use another type of wood flooring. One of the first complaints you hear from potential home buyers on tv mention is the fact that the wood floors in different rooms don't match. I think it would look like you just ran out of wood. Somewhat of a hodgepodge. I'd use something completely different, like ceramic or porcelain tile. There are so many pretty ones out there.
3 months ago · ·
Ironwood Builders I'm a wood guy...and I agree with gerryanne. One continuous floor or two entirely different floors. Nothing says low budget like mixing real hardwoods with engineered floors....even if they cost the same (which they often do).
3 months ago · ·
judyg Agree, agree. Take a look at some of the new porcelain tiles available.
3 months ago ·
fall50 Not sure if it matters, but this isnt a open floor panel. Its your typical old "siloed" house where the rooms all have doors. Would the fact the kitchen has a door opening serve to alleivate the "hodgepodge look?

We have some tile we like but cannot find it in the size we like. Here is my post regarding this issue. Please let me know if you have any ideas on this front?
http://www.houzz.com/discussions/384649/Herringbone-pattern-and-size-of-tile-in-small
3 months ago ·
feeny May I ask why don't you want to match the white oak in the kitchen? I'm asking because white oak is such a great, durable choice of hardwood for a kitchen that it seems odd not to continue it.
3 months ago ·
fall50 Figured cost would be higher relative to enginnered? In addition to having to seal it stan it etc.
3 months ago ·
Kelly My home has Hickory 5' enginnered wood and in looking to complete the master, I was blown away at how expensive it is.
3 months ago ·
Lizabeth White oak is abundant , good wood and easy to locate. Price will depend on grade of wood and if you are purchasing plain sawn quarter sawn or rift. Since your area is small price should not be substantial. Buying new unfinished and letting your installer knit in new with old and sand it will give you the best look in a small house.

If you need to save I see nothing wrong with putting plywood under the cabinets and only using the oak where it shows. I would raise the lower cabinets with the plywood under because I like keeping my countetops at least 36 inchs but some would leave it.
3 months ago ·
Linda If you are in a vintage home, I don't believe that using a different wood in the kitchen is totally out of the question. In fact, it was quite common in older houses to have oak in the main public areas with maple in the kitchen. In my 1931 house, the kitchen floor is fir (original floor surface was linoleum, we finished the subfloor) and the rest of the house is quartersawn oak. It is an old house; kitchen is a separate room so why insist on having the same floor as elsewhere?

The best option is to get new wood and refinish everything to match. Just be sure to match grade, cut and species of wood which may mean paying more to avoid lots of shorts and uneven coloring.
3 months ago ·
Sign Up to comment
The content on this page is provided by Houzz and is subject to the Houzz terms of use, copyright and privacy policy.
Copyright claims: contact the Houzz designated agent.