Home of the San Francisco Chronicle

Subscribe to the weekend Chronicle

powered by
Discussions
Photos
Products
Ideabooks
Discussions
Professionals
Users
by Gavin Kennedy
2 months ago in Design Dilemma
Rift and quartered or flat sawn white oak
I just purchased 1000 sq ft of plain sawn 4" white oak planks. Now I'm obsessing about the differences between flat sawn versus rift and quartered (both look/design and quality). Help me live with my decision or stop me at the pass (I can change my order, if very soon). Is R/Q worth the extra cost? Will I not even care when it's all laid? Design dilemma indeed. Thanks in advance Houzzers
Share:
 
Kaplan Architects, AIA I really like the rift or guartered oak much better than the plain sawn. I think it is worth it. The plain sawn can have a very busy grain.
2 months ago ·
feeny I do love quarter sawn white oak. That's what we have (original, 90 years old) in our house, and that's what I'd use again if I were building one. It not only looks more beautiful (because the grain isn't so busy), but it is also even more durable.
2 months ago ·
Ironwood Builders If you know and understand the difference...it matters.
2 months ago · ·
Lizabeth No one but you can answer this question. Does rift sawn fill your heart with joy when you look at it?
.
2 months ago ·
Gavin Kennedy Honestly, I need to see a room full of both. I lean toward R/Q...maybe my heart sings??
2 months ago ·
Lizabeth Gavin,

Out on an limb here but perhaps you don't get it about rift sawn. One can see the grain pattern in a one foot by three inch piece of both side by side. Plain sawn has 'cathedrals" and rift has straight grain and diagonal rays with what I consider more "depth". You could visit a cabinet supplier and see the difference in two cabinet doors.

Some foks are more visually sensitive than others. There are structural issues which contribute to it's stability beyond it's beauty as well.

My point is the difference in the wood is very apparent and one does not need to see a room of it to discern the different aspects. A cabinet or tabletop of each should answer any question you might have about each type.
2 months ago · ·
Sign Up to comment
The content on this page is provided by Houzz and is subject to the Houzz terms of use, copyright and privacy policy.
Copyright claims: contact the Houzz designated agent.