Classic Design: The Language of Columns
Tuscan, Doric, Ionic, Corinthian — Greek and Roman design still has a place in our homes. But which style to use, and how?
My name is Bud Dietrich and I am an architect located in the Tampa Bay area of Florida. I am licensed to practice architecture in Illinois, Florida, New Jersey & Wisconsin and I am a certificate holder from the National Council of Architectural Registration Boards (NCARB). Since 1996 I have worked from my home office and provide full architectural services exclusively to the single family residential market. My passion is to transform my clients' houses into their homes. I strive to have the "new" home accommodate my clients' lives without fighting them at every junction. I look to add curb appeal to encourage a beautiful streetscape. And I design any addition to look and feel like it has always been there.
Our projects have won numerous design awards as well as having been featured on television...
My name is Bud Dietrich and I am an architect located in the Tampa Bay... More »
From high-end luxury homes to the most basic spec-built home, it seems that a traditionally designed house has to have at least one column based on designs from antiquity.
Around 2,500 years ago, the Greeks invented what have become known as the classical orders. These orders (Doric, Ionic and Corinthian) were adopted by the ancient Romans, who simplified the Doric to make their own order, the Tuscan. The Romans also combined the Ionic and Corinthian to form the Composite, or fifth classical order. Each order had a distinct meaning. A building designed using the Doric order would have been quite different in tone than a building designed in the Corinthian order.
Each order had a distinct meaning. A building designed using the Doric order would have been quite different in tone than a building designed in the Corinthian order. The same holds true today. While a grand palace may warrant the Corinthian order, Tuscan might be more appropriate for a small home.
What is a homeowner to make of this? Where would one use, say, a Doric in lieu of a Corinthian column? And are there rules for scale, proportion and detail? Here are some ideas to help you sort it out.
Around 2,500 years ago, the Greeks invented what have become known as the classical orders. These orders (Doric, Ionic and Corinthian) were adopted by the ancient Romans, who simplified the Doric to make their own order, the Tuscan. The Romans also combined the Ionic and Corinthian to form the Composite, or fifth classical order. Each order had a distinct meaning. A building designed using the Doric order would have been quite different in tone than a building designed in the Corinthian order.
Each order had a distinct meaning. A building designed using the Doric order would have been quite different in tone than a building designed in the Corinthian order. The same holds true today. While a grand palace may warrant the Corinthian order, Tuscan might be more appropriate for a small home.
What is a homeowner to make of this? Where would one use, say, a Doric in lieu of a Corinthian column? And are there rules for scale, proportion and detail? Here are some ideas to help you sort it out.
1. Tuscan-style columns. America's most popular classical order since the Colonial era has been the Tuscan. Developed by the ancient Romans as a simple, clean and "virtuous" order, it's no surprise that the colonials would use the Tuscan to add style and tradition to their buildings while maintaining those puritanical sensibilities.
Private Comment
| If you're looking for some gravitas, pair the columns at mid-span and create a three-column corner. This will work especially well when with larger homes where the columns must compete with all the other architecture. Private Comment
|
Tuscan columns often come factory-produced for lower cost and easy site assembly. Usually made of a composite material, the columns will be low-maintenance and last a long time.
Private Comment
Whether used on the exterior or the interior, the Tuscan order adds a touch of classical formality and traditional "always been there" feel — without the overall stiffness of the Doric or the exuberance of the Corinthian.
Placing the columns at an opening between rooms makes the transition from one to the other all the more special.
Private Comment
Placing the columns at an opening between rooms makes the transition from one to the other all the more special.
The Tuscan can be livened a little with the addition of fluting and pedestals. Paired up, these columns are used as points defining functional areas in what appears to be one large room.
Private Comment
2. Doric: Distinctly Classical. The Doric was the simplest as well as the most masculine of the original Greek orders. There are minimal decorative elements and, in its original form, no base.
Here, the Doric order is used to lend a distinctly classical, antique and formal quality to the project.
Private Comment
Here, the Doric order is used to lend a distinctly classical, antique and formal quality to the project.
Certainly the Doric order wasn't devoid of decorative embellishment. Fluting of the column shaft as well as some decorative elements at the capital can soften what can be a plain and almost severe design.
Private Comment
| 3. Ionic: Large scale, high style. Moving to the next order, the Ionic is a bit more luxurious than the spartan Doric and Tuscan. As such, it's best used where a little more polish, high style, and bigger scale is warranted. Also, Ionic capitals visually ease the transition from column to pediment. The way the capitals flatten and stretch out make for a nice transitional element. Private Comment
The scale of the column should also be in tune with the scale of the overall architecture. More often than not, classically inspired columns are too thin, making them look like silly toothpicks rather than the robust reminders of antiquity they are. When in doubt, adhere to the 2,000-year-old rules for scale, one of which is that the column height should be seven times the column diameter. |
| In rooms with richly appointed finishes and details — such as this wall with sconces and larger architectural moldings and trim — using a simpler Doric or Tuscan column would seem out of place, like a discordant note in a musical composition. The Corinthian (next) would be out of place here as well, as its exuberant richness would detract from the elegance of the space. Private Comment
|
4. Corinthian: Rational exuberance. The most exuberant and luxurious of the orders are the Corinthian and Composite. Seldom used in modest homes, these orders are richly detailed with plant-like capitals, fluted shafts and richly detailed bases.
The Corinthian is the appropriate order in a room that exudes an intricacy of surface detail and a richness of finish.
More: When a Column Doesn't Look Like a Column
Arches Frame Welcoming Spaces
Private Comment
The Corinthian is the appropriate order in a room that exudes an intricacy of surface detail and a richness of finish.
More: When a Column Doesn't Look Like a Column
Arches Frame Welcoming Spaces
Comments
Traci Rolz says:
It pains me to see classical columns being replicated in newer homes.
4 months ago ·
Like
njmodernist says:
Of course, to be perfectly consistent, those Doric columns should have triglyphs and metopes in the architrave, and the Ionic a frieze.
4 months ago ·
Like
safbham says:
I have a particular dislike for columns in a home... I tripped on the base of one and gosh did it hurt... they are so out of place and a poor concept for dividing a room...
4 months ago ·
Like
cadsaxl says:
beautiful examples - thanks for bringing the architectural info along with them
4 months ago ·
Like
Jamie Jay says:
Someone had a column fetish in the 2nd last photo, imagine how much more open and elegant the hallway would be without those ionic columns which are not even needed for structural support !!!
4 months ago ·
Like
Jean Corey says:
I love these beautiful columns. I hope builders continue using them more.
4 months ago ·
Like
Alan Brookman says:
If you're speaking the language of classic design, the last of the Tuscan examples is a prime example of a mistake: columns support beams, and there they do not. The other pictures all show very good (and proper) use of columns.
4 months ago ·
Like
mmsalg says:
Columns look great but they can be obtrusive if not done well. The beauty is, you can made them exactly as you want them. If you need help or have questions, this is a great place to go for answers and makers who can get the job done www.custommade.com.
4 months ago ·
Like
Lisa and Leo says:
This idea book reflects a profound lack of the fundamentals of Greek and Roman columnar language. Whether one's personal taste is pro- or anti-Classical columns, no one should be subject to an elevation of the poor examples we see here.
4 months ago ·
Like
Today's Articles
