Get the Scoop on Finding the Best Paint for Your Money
Scoring the best deal on paint for your home may have nothing to do with advertised specials
Houzz Editorial Staff
Houzz Editorial Staff More »
| Share: |
|
Picking a new paint is kind of like picking a new toothpaste — they all look the same but can massively differ in price. How do you know which one is right for your house? Although the cheapest option may seem attractive, more expensive paints are higher quality and come in more brilliant colors.
We talked with three paint professionals to get the scoop on which is the better value.
We talked with three paint professionals to get the scoop on which is the better value.
| What makes some paints better than others? All paint has the following ingredients, says Karl Schmitt, vice president of marketing research and design at Sherwin-Williams:
|
| Like it? Save it to your Ideabook »
|
| What makes a high-quality paint? For those who have used both high-quality and less expensive paints, the difference between the two is clear. "Some cheaper paints look chalky or more plastic-like," says Storey. "Also, how the paint feels, or the 'hand' of the paint, can make a big difference aesthetically." More expensive paints can be easier to apply, hide imperfections better, last longer, have more vibrant colors and make washing easier — all due to the higher-quality ingredients in each batch. If you're looking for a single type of paint that's "the best," it depends on what you're looking for. The Paint Quality Institute evaluates paint on different qualities according to brand. Some brands are better at hiding flaws, some on flow and leveling, and others on adhesion. Each brand has its own unique balance of characteristics. If you want to play it safe, choose the top-quality item from the brand you're interested in. Still hesitant about spending the extra cash? Buy samples of several different types of paint and see if you can tell the difference. "While a gallon of Fine Paints of Europe paint might cost you $40 per gallon, the coverage will be superior, and you may be able to cover the surface in fewer coats and stretch the time between costly future repaints," says Storey. Buying a good paint won't solve all your problems, though. "A good paint job is only as good as the preparation," says painter Alex Davison. "That tends to be approximately 60 percent of the work. A quick prep with the best paint won't last." |
Do low-VOC ingredients make a difference in price?
Today, Environmental Protection Agency regulations ensure that paint companies produce most of their product with low-VOC (volatile organic compounds) content. Low-VOC paints used to cost more, but that's not necessarily true today. Low VOC "is one of many elements in the formulation of a paint product, and it is the overall quality of ingredients and formulation of those ingredients that impact the price of the product," says Schmitt.
Tell us: What are your favorite paints to use? What is your experience with different brands and price ranges?
More:
How to Paint Interior Walls
How to Work With a House Painter
Today, Environmental Protection Agency regulations ensure that paint companies produce most of their product with low-VOC (volatile organic compounds) content. Low-VOC paints used to cost more, but that's not necessarily true today. Low VOC "is one of many elements in the formulation of a paint product, and it is the overall quality of ingredients and formulation of those ingredients that impact the price of the product," says Schmitt.
Tell us: What are your favorite paints to use? What is your experience with different brands and price ranges?
More:
How to Paint Interior Walls
How to Work With a House Painter
Ideabook updated on Nov. 26, 2012.
Latest Ideabooks
People found the photos in this ideabook after searching for:
View over a million photos:
Find Local Pros by Category:
Architects & Designers · Carpet and Flooring · Closet & Home Storage Designers · Design-build Firms · Fireplaces · General Contractors · Home Media Design & Installation · Interior Designers & Decorators · Kitchen & Bath Designers · Landscape Architects & Designers · Landscape Contractors · Specialty Contractors · Tile, Stone & Countertops
Find Local Pros by Metro Area:
Atlanta · Austin · Baltimore · Boston · Chicago · Dallas · Dc Metro · Denver · Detroit · Hawaii · Houston · Las Vegas · Los Angeles · Miami · Minneapolis · Nashville · New Orleans · New York · Philadelphia · Phoenix · Portland · Salt Lake City · San Diego · San Francisco · Seattle · St Louis


























With that said, to me the most important step is the prepping and IMO none the of the new water-based paints on the market today (no matter their cost) can measure up to the standards of any oil-base product period which I feel is still really the best for woodwork, doors and trim!
P.S: As mentioned, I generally used oil base products on doors, wood work and trim and to cut down the odour always added a tsp. of vanilla extract to a gallon of paint which conquered the smell and another option was to place a small bowl of amonia in the enclosed room overnight which acted like a sponge and eliminated the odour by morning.
Footnote: Fast forward ..... YES I am still very much alive (at least I think I am) from once using oil-based products and don't suffer from any respiratory ailments. Ü
|ˈprīmər|
noun
a substance used as a preparatory coat on previously unpainted wood, metal, or canvas, esp. to prevent the absorption of subsequent layers of paint or the development of rust.
have had poor luck with many brands and long for the days of the montgomery wards or sears 'good stuff'. Is there any good paint sold in CA anymore?
We have tried many brands from low to high end. Behr's new line with built in primer didn't perform the way we had hoped at all, we actually needed 4 coats of a cream color to repaint a light aqua wall, so much for the "built in primer". Sherwin Williams has been good, and in our experience, Glidden has been the worst...quite chalky, dull and spotty. Hope that helps.
I've used paint with 'built in primer' in the past and hated them. It's worth the extra step.
I would also love to see a how-to article about painting old wood floors that have been painted before. What type of paint is best, how many coats, sealer, etc.
Almost all new tract homes in N. Ca are painted with Kelly Moore or Dunn Edwards. It covers well and is low cost, thus in the competitive market of new house painting, where the cost of paint can be the difference in procuring a contract and not, it is favored by Painting contractors.
www.unearthedpaints.com
Best
It was only months until the marks began to appear, and indeed, most of them did come off with SoftScrub or other gentle cleaners. But alas, when the light hit those spots, you could see every one of them glaringly, as the finish had changed and stuck out even worse than had I left the spots alone. I will never spend the extra money for Aura, when the light hits the scrubbed spots, it's by far more glaringly noticeable than having left the dirt on. I'm not sure what the answer is, as I've found the same holds true for BM's regular eggshell finish. The next time, I'm opting for a drop-dead gorgeous grasscloth, or a scrubbable faux grasscloth vinyl!
Besides renovating a falling down casita, we're also repainting a 50 year old home that my husband's parents built. Those taking care of his parents' house had the house repainted about four years ago, just after we moved here. The painter was not a professional and didn't do a good job AT ALL, and the paint he used was poor quality, so from the beginning the streaky walls really bothered me -- and the color (a murky goldish yellow) was depressing. So last year we finally bought SW paint and I'm slowly working my way through the house, painting it room-by-room. We don't get out there very often so it has taken a year to get about half the interior done. I was THRILLED to find the pale aqua I chose covers the murky goldish yellow in ONE COAT.
The walls of the casita are so wonky that we went with an eggshell white that covers a multitude of imperfections :) It is taking two coats, since it's going over raw cement (well, I did put two coats of sealer on before painting), but two coats is totally sufficient. It has brightened up the small space considerably!
I can't say enough good things about Sherwin Williams!
This time around, at my insistence, we're using Benjamin Moore. What a difference! One coat coverage and the color is deep -- if that makes sense. In the long run, we'll use less paint, so the cost is about the same.
Paint is one of those products where you get what you pay for.
I too long for the old oil based paints. When we moved into this home 36 years ago we had it professionally painted with SW in oil base. We did not paint the main rooms for close to 30 years. Yes it need to be painted but it looked better, and cleaned better, than the new paint did after 2 years. (And, I raised 4 kids in this house.) We used Behr from Home Depot, and the same professional painter, the second time and I have hated it almost from the beginning.
We just bought a house together...and will be using Benjamin Moore. Back in the '70s, I used Benjamin Moore for a house exterior and Dutch Boy for the trim. Big lesson on the difference between cheap and good.
I have not seen any mention of flat enamel paint.. I have been told it's THE finish to use on your walls. Flat finish, for good looks & concealing of flaws, but it is scrub-able!
Any experts or experienced, with flat enamel feedback?
1- Color Palette
2- Low VOC (we have parrots, no toxic paint fumes)
3 - Semi-gloss, gloss, easy to scrub walls (see reason 2)
3- Ease of application, cheap paint means extra coats, Ben Moore paint one coat is fine
4- Husband uses it also, for painting lines on tennis courts.
Great paint, it is expensive, but you get what you pay for. If you are going to take all the time to clean, prep and then paint, don't waste your time with cheap paint!
I have used Benjamin Moore successfully in different types: Aqua Pearl, Aura bathroom & kitchen, and their standard paint in satin. Natura seemed watery to me.
I have also used Pratt & Lambert. I love their colors.