Home of the San Francisco Chronicle

Subscribe to the weekend Chronicle

powered by
Ideabooks
Photos
Products
Ideabooks
Discussions
Professionals
Users
True to the golden ratio, dividing shelves into thirds tends to look best. When it comes to niches, I'm a firm believer in following this rule.

Tip: Most glass looks slightly green. If you want a whiter glass, choose a low-iron version, like starphire glass.
by Niki Papadopoulos  
This shelf makes use of three stone shelves rather than glass.

So, which is better? Personally, I like the look of glass. But if a shower niche is getting soaked and taking on soap spray every day, a stone surface will look cleaner longer.

Tip: Make sure the bottom of the niche and any shelves are slightly tipped toward the shower so they drain. Shower niches are super useful, but if they hold water after every shower, they won't look great for long.
by Clark Harris
A niche installation often depends on the tile choice and how the edges of those tiles look. Many times we miter the edges of the tile to eliminate the plain edge that many tiles have.

Here's an example of mitered tile corners. The top shower niche was built larger and then divided with a glowing shelf of starfire glass.

Tip: Starphire glass scratches easier than regular glass. Take extra care cleaning and working with this glass.
by John Whipple - By Any Design ltd.
I think odds tend to look better than evens in showers — groups of three, not two.

The scale of this niche is excellent. Notice how the shower niche has 11 glass tiles on the back. The glass shelf sits on the seventh tile down from the top — almost two-thirds of the way down. Sometimes this doesn't work out when you get onsite, but here the scale is superb.

Tip: Make sure you measure your favorite shower products. A nicely designed shower niche is great, but if your shampoo bottle of choice does not fit, it won't be of any help.
by The Sky is the Limit Design
If you sit on a bench, you probably want to access to your stuff. Keep things in reach and plan the niche placement to work for you and your kids.

Tip: If you have kids, assume that they will try to climb anything that looks like a ladder, so keep your shelving secure. Installing the glass or stone first in the niche and then setting the tile around it is far safer than siliconing a glass shelf into a finished tiled niche.
by Bill Fry Construction - Wm. H. Fry Const. Co.  
What a feature! This corner bench is obviously the focal element in the shower. When planning your main design points, a shower niche should not compete with your space's design. The use of glass in this niche makes for a subtler look.

Tip: Glass is usually affordable. But make sure you order your niche shelving with other glass items to get the most bang for your buck. If you're using three shelves in a niche, ask your contractor to order four. It's always nice to have a backup in case something breaks.
by Michael Tauber Architecture
This is a great use of space. Many of the little things needed in a shower can fit in a small niche. The low glass shelf doubles the footprint and creates extra room for lotions and potions.

Tip: Make sure the glass is tempered so it's safe in case of an accident.
by Reaume Construction & Design
I love the contrast of this shower niche. This hardworking spot is great for a squeegee. The shorter wall (often called a pony wall) hides the niche from the other parts of the bathroom. Some homeowners don't like to have their shower products on display. Hiding your niche down low like this can be a great solution.

Tip: If the niche ends up on display, then make it a gem!
by RemodelWest
The large glowing niche in my daughter's bathroom has a one-third split. The smaller top niche won't collect water — it's a great spot for a bar of soap.

Tip: When working with slabs for niches, you will need to specify to the stone supplier that the pieces be double polished, meaning both the top and bottom get polished.
by John Whipple - By Any Design ltd.

Comments

3D-Tile-Design - Bertram Tasch Hi John,

again a great article however I am missing one very common "edge-solution" in your informative ideabook. So please let me add this solution.

Often the tiles don't have a nice edge-finish like in picture #1 and #2. This is especially the case by ceramic tiles. And it is sometimes not possible or at least very hard to miter porcelain tiles. In such cases it is not a bad idea to go with a prefabricated edge profile. A small range of these edge profiles is available in hardware stores.

For those who are looking for nicer trim pieces they should check out the Schluter®-Edge-Profiles. These profiles are available in different shapes (Round, Square and L-shape), different materials (Stainless Steel, Brass, Anodized Aluminum, and PVC,) different finishes (brushed, chrome and honed) and come in many different colors. It is possible to go with the grout color to make it invisible and also to go with a shiny metal finish to make it as an accent.


► Schluter® Finishing & Edge-Protection Profiles for Walls & Countertops: http://www.schluter.com/139.aspx

Here's another important point:
Be careful when you consider to place a niche on an outside wall. This is often not possible because the walls are just not thick enough. There would be no more insulation where your niche is and this would cause moisture and mold problems inside your wall.

Regards.

3D-Tile-Design - Bertram Tasch
Maple Ridge, BC (Greater Vancouver)
http://www.3D-Tile-Design.ca
6 months ago ·
John Whipple - By Any Design ltd. Personally I feel the Schluter accent you recommend "Cheapens" the look of the shower niche Betram. The picture of yours shows a poor shower tile layout and not much symmetry.

Do you understand the "Golden Ratio"? Consider this when you are chopping down that center course of tile.

We have never found a tile we can not miter. It is work. It is hard. But this is why I have an apprentice..... lol Seriously are you serious when you say sometimes it's not possible to cut a miter? I've never seen it.

Most designers I know cringe and the term "Schluter Profile" - yes I know they are needed sometimes but there are so many other ways to tile without them.

I think your project would have looked nicer if the Schluter profiles where install the other way - so that all that shiny metal was less visable on the face of the tile. Perhaps the face of the profile on the inside of the niche would be better.

I also find that a Schluter Profile does not look great unless the cuts have been made with a chop saw and a non-ferrous blade. Even still all the metal in two niches I feel it takes away from the look of the stone or tile.

My thoughts.

JW
6 months ago · ·
3D-Tile-Design - Bertram Tasch Hello John, I know the "Golden Ratio" and I agree with you regarding the tile layout. The niches are very small too but in this case the owner built the shower and niches by himself so we had to deal with the existing openings, as well as with the tiles and the Schluter-Profiles he already bought a long time ago and he was not willing to change anything. What else could/should I do? Ripping everything off against his will? I guess you wouldn’t do this neither to one of your clients. If I had to build it from scratch I would tile it different. – for sure.

“…Most designers I know cringe and the term "Schluter Profile" - yes I know they are needed sometimes but there are so many other ways to tile without them…” I know and I have the same experiences with some designers. I didn't say that Schluter-Profiles are the solution in every case and for everyone however it is another option. And finally it is not the designer it’s our client who is using his bathroom a couple times a day and he should love it - not just the designer!

Everyone has its own taste and style and this is good so, otherwise we all would drive the same car, would wear the same clothes and we would also eat the same food. But what would we do with our spouses? We could not have the same spouse? ☺ I think we should always respect what our clients like and let them decide what they want. A good designer helps the client with his decisions and does not only “stamp” his own style to the home of his clients like a very popular TV-Contractor is doing this with the clients in his show. - Every bathroom and every floor have the same tile pattern.

“…I think your project would have looked nicer if the Schluter profiles where install the other way - so that all that shiny metal was less visable on the face of the tile. Perhaps the face of the profile on the inside of the niche would be better…” I also agree, however in this case it was a rounded profile. (Schluter-Rondec) Furthermore this profile goes all around the perimeter as well as around the curb. So it matches with the other corners.


You are also right about cutting Schluter-Profiles. I never ever used the Schluter-Shear to cut these profiles and I never will. First of all this shear is intended to cut only PVC-profiles and second, using it squeezes the profile together. And when doing miter-cuts they don’t fit very well together. However some tile-setters don’t know about this and cut every profile with this plier like this guy did. - Poor customer.

Cheers Bertram
6 months ago · ·
John Whipple - By Any Design ltd. To further improve the look of a tiled niche consider rolling or folding the tile in the corners. When you roll a tile you make a cut and then use that same cut on the next tile in the puzzle.

You can see in the first picture that we cut the tile - made a new micro bevel on the cuts and lined them up so that the grain or veining in the tile runs around the corner. This is not much work and makes for a very polished look.

The other pictures will show some progress and some action shots.

JW
6 months ago · ·
bubblyjock These ideas for niches are also suitable for incorporation in kitchen design, I suspect - thanks, John - solid article as usual!
6 months ago · ·
textileaholic Planning stud placement for niches is beyond important too. I luckily walked into my under-construction new bath in time to see the niche 2/3 over to one side of a wall rather than centered. Rookie mistake.
6 months ago · ·
Bill Fry Construction - Wm. H. Fry Const. Co. Nice story John, and thanks for including one of our images. Just wanted to add that there are a number of pre-fab niches in various configurations that are ready to tile that our Houzz readers might not be aware of. Here is just one example of many companies that makes these: http://www.tileredi.com/products_files/Redi-Niches.php
best, Rhoda
6 months ago ·
John Whipple - By Any Design ltd. Thanks for your comments everyone. Rhonda I left out ready made shower niche designs because for the most part they are poorly designed. I find many do not have the required slope at the bottom to be even a consideration.

The pre-made niches from Tile Ready appear to have this slope and that is nice to see. What do you think about these niches of theirs? I'm not a fan at all of this companies (tile ready) shower pans and have read countless complaints online. We just finished redoing a tile ready base and built the client a customer shower pan after he junked the pan he ordered.

I'm a huge fan of Noble Company but do not like their ready made niche for the same reason. No pre-slope on the bottom.

When building a shower niche it's great to have a topical waterproofing process. This I think makes these ready made niches not so helpful. If you are building to "Code" and not "Industry Guideline" it is easy to bang in a ready made niche between the studs but this is not the best system for your home. If one is going in insist that some vapour barrier or something is done to prevent moisture from exiting the niche or shower wall.

JW
6 months ago · ·
John Whipple - By Any Design ltd. @ textileaholic - Tile layout is king in any shower renovation. Did you read this Ideabook of mine on the subject?


My newest love in tile niches is lining them up with one wall and running them in behind the adjoining wall. In the picture below you can see what I'm talking about. This niche will have some fun features like a side lit LED option.

I will also be using the niche's bottom as a ledge for a wooden board that will span the shower and rest on the lip of the tub deck. This will make for a removable board that can act as a ledge. The client has asked me to make one for the tub as well so it can be a ledge to leave reading material.

JW
6 months ago · ·
textileaholic I didn't read it but I will now! I love the look of niches you designed above - they look artful and intentional. I designed mine to be centered, but my contractor had other ideas. Good thing I happened to be home before the walls went up.
6 months ago ·
Hometown Building/Intercept Make sure you put as much shelf space as possible. Also try an include them in the over all tile design. Francis Jones, CKD, BD
6 months ago · ·
woman6 How are the glass shelves mounted in the tile alcove shown in the photo by Nicki P.?
6 months ago ·
Hometown Building/Intercept The glass shelves are set into the tile by the tile installer.
6 months ago ·
John Whipple - By Any Design ltd. Here is a new Chromatherapy shower niche taking shape here in Vancouver. The light output is fantastic the the white shelf is back lit where the colour comes in from the side.

All of this tied into the air tubs Chromotherapy system so the room glows as one - in any shade you wish.

JW
4 months ago · ·
Lanecraft Lane and Coach Houses Inc Great niches John, thank you for a fine article! ...So many otherwise beautiful showers and tubs are marred by the unavoidable clutter from various soap and shampoo bottles and brushes and sponges that people use on a daily basis. Shower caddies that fit over the shower spout are convenient inventions for those baths where there is no other option: they reduce clutter and help organize items. But what a difference if a bath or shower space can be designed with niches that are then well-built with great proportions, drainage and edge detailing! (see image below from my recent laneway house completed last year in Vancouver; I worked with the tile size to proportion the niches...unfortunately necessary framing forced the niche further to the corner than I would have liked, but it was a decent compromise).
And good discussion regarding Schluter profiles. Bertram makes some good points. I used to hate them myself and also felt that they cheapened the look, but I've made my peace with them over the years and have come to value firstly the usefulness in covering and also protecting tile edges and secondly the detail and highlights that come from a well-considered and well-installed profile.
I truly think that most of the bad rap has come from poor installations and sloppy corner cuts. What better way to turn someone off of something than to show them a bad product!
However when considered and installed carefully, a schluter-like tile edge can add truly beautiful detail to a bath or shower, be it in a niche or on an outside corner or simply to end the tiled area on a wall. It's like the period to a sentence in some cases.
So the design is of utmost importance, as with most things, but without proper execution of that design it will be a mess. A great tile installer is absolutely essential, and in the past year I've found the best tiler I have ever met. John, since you are local, I'll give you his name: Petru Adoamnei ("Petrax Renovation") and his work is impeccable. Give him a call at 778.320.4527 to quote on your next project. It's obvious you have a great tile setter but I am super picky (my father was a stone mason and craftsman) and I have never seen work as good as Petru's.
...love the chromatherapy image btw!
Thomas
4 months ago · ·
John Whipple - By Any Design ltd. I see about one nice Schluter profile instal for every twenty that are butchered. I'm going to do a new ideabook on how to install these profiles with skill and what tools to use for a perfect install.

We are installing some as we speak on a tub deck and I have documented the process to share later here on Houzz.

We do everything possible to remove them from our projects. But sometimes the client just does not want to pay for the extra work of mitering the tile.

JW
4 months ago ·
John Whipple - By Any Design ltd. Thomas the picture you posted has just the factory edge showing (tile edge) in your niches. I personally do not like it when tile setters do this. I also like the same shawdow reveal where the tub meets the tile. In your picture this element differs from the short wall to the long wall.

Do you have examples of your setters work where these details are factored in. I'm always looking for top quality setters.

My apprentice and I have started tiling our own projects since I can count on so few of my subs to pull of these barrier free projects with the right level of skill and the proper products.

JW
4 months ago ·
Lanecraft Lane and Coach Houses Inc John, I like how exact you are! Good on you. And you're right very few can pull off the precision that you speak of. I chose that particular image for the niche design more than the execution of the particular detail that you critiqued...as with your experiences I've had to keep looking for trades that can do work that both I and the client are happy with. Unfortunately I did not know Petru when I did that laneway house otherwise I'm certain it would have been ever better! The client does love that particular bathroom by the way; since the tile factory edge of that particular tile was of a high enough and consistent quality choosing to expose the edge is an attractive detail (in my opinion) which speaks to the slab nature of the material and conveys a sense that the material is monolithic.
I'll attach another image from our most recent laneway house now that shows Petru's fine work, niche design and attractive tile edging. I would call that one perfect enough! :-)
4 months ago · ·
Christine Bell My tiler is saying I can't have a niche with the tiles I chose (8"x4" white subway tiles from Lowes and also tiny square glass border tiles) -- what can I get him to do and how?
4 months ago ·
John Whipple - By Any Design ltd. Not sure the problem but a skilled tile setter can achieve almost anything. I'm off to work right now but can look at some pictures tonight. Could you email what your trying to achieve?

sales@no-curb.com

Have you seen this idea book?





JW
4 months ago ·
Mike Griffin How does one go about adding these type of shower shelf niche's into a bathroom wall above the vanity next to a mirror? Or to build a "sinked in wall" to hold a towel back to incorporate space saving design?
4 months ago ·
Hometown Building/Intercept Hey Mike! Using existing space is always a plus for remodeling and convenience. First calculate the depth of the wall you are going to cut into to make sure it will give you the space you need for your towel. Next, make sure that there are no plumbing pipes running up through that space. Around a vanity you have vent pipes, main stack and possibly water pipe that might feed other plumbing fixtures. Also check to see if there is any electrical feeds going through the area, these may be minimized in the cut out space by keeping them along the side or in a back corner. Locate wall framing and exactly where your recess can go. Mark it on the wall and make sure it is where it will be useful to you. If you can, cut a pilot hole to see exactly what, if anything is in the way. Cut the hole and finish with materials you elect of some kind of an insert. Good luck! Francis Jones, CKD, CBD, Hometown Building
4 months ago ·
calikym Commenting here so I don't lose this information.
3 months ago ·
ankelly301 We are going with shower niches and I can't wait. I like the clean look of the backsplash being a similar color and glass shelves. I am also going to do an niche over our toilet as well.
9 weeks ago ·
joanmcd How do we build shower with niches on the outside wall side, which happens to be concrete block? Old wall has been taken down to block. Also. Where to place niches in relation to a built in bench?
4 weeks ago ·
Bathroom Tile Shower Shelves Please check out my easy to install and clean niches and shower shelves. Mark Daniels Bathroom Ideas
3 weeks ago ·
Hometown Building/Intercept joanmcd- is the block wall surface going to be shower wall surface. Are there any walls adjacent to the block wall. Niches can be on any wall in the shower. Also there is no real relationship between a built in bench and a niche. In fact, making it convenient to the bench might be uncomfortable for other uses in the shower. Francis Jones, CKD, CBD-Hometown Building
3 weeks ago ·
Sign Up to comment
People found the photos in this ideabook after searching for:
The content on this page is provided by Houzz and is subject to the Houzz terms of use, copyright and privacy policy.
Copyright claims: contact the Houzz designated agent.