Home of the San Francisco Chronicle

Subscribe to the weekend Chronicle

powered by
Ideabooks
Photos
Products
Ideabooks
Discussions
Professionals
Users
The first homelike impression of the museum, which is set back from a large grassy field on the Montauk Highway, comes when one moves past the east end of the building to reach the parking lot behind it. Here one sees the double gables that run the full length of the building. While also barnlike in the way these roofs overhang beyond the concrete and dark wood walls, the gable form, as we'll see, is a motif that helps arrange the interior spaces and give the galleries a suitable scale for the art.
by John Hill
Another first impression is how long the museum is: 615 feet, to be precise. The building, which runs east–west, hugs the ground tightly and appears to be more roof than wall; the former is dotted with skylights that give a subtle hint at what is happening inside.
by John Hill
Before we get closer to the building, it's good to point out the landscape next to the parking lot, which incorporates two parallel swales for storm water management. Not only do the swales reduce runoff into the sewer, but their layout echoes the building in the long paths they cut across the site. Bridges traverse the swales to allow access from the parking area to the building.
by John Hill
The west end of the building is similar to the east end — with the twin gable protruding beyond the walls — but it also features a porch that immediately serves the café and auditorium on this remote end of the building. Evident on these ends is the inspiration of vernacular architecture in the region, such as agrarian structures, as well as more abstract domestic forms.
by John Hill
The porch is fairly substantial, but given the length of the building, it's entirely appropriate. My visit to the museum was on a rainy day, but I could take shelter under the roof and enjoy the surrounding landscape, which includes a winery on the west side.
by John Hill
The roofs overhang along the long north and south sides, not just the east and west ends. These overhangs align with the concrete pad upon which the museum sits. Visitors walk along these sheltered walkways after making their way from the parking lot to the building. Underneath these zones, the inexpensive construction of the building is apparent: rough concrete, exposed wood structure and corrugated metal on the underside of the roof.
by John Hill
An exception to the "cheap" exterior is the continuous bench that runs along the base of the concrete walls. Also made of concrete but in a much better finish than the wall above, the bench is an inviting surface that is particularly suited to warm days (not the cool and rainy day when I visited).
by John Hill
The entrance is subtle except when the viewer is situated on axis with it, as in this photo. An outdoor space is cut into the 615-foot-long building, and parallel glass walls give a view to the other side.
by John Hill
Here is a view from inside the lobby looking back toward the parking lot. The entrance porch beyond the glass wall is very homelike, acting as a sheltered transition between the public outdoor realm and the indoor private realm. The actual entry is through the black door visible on the wall at left, meaning this glass wall is purely for views and natural light.
by John Hill
The built-in seating outside is carried through to the lobby, but it is executed in wood instead of concrete here. These benches are not as well integrated into the wall as the ones outside, but they are welcome nevertheless.

Also, the lobby is the visitor's first glimpse of how the two gables come together — the V form of the wood structure is the lowest point inside.
by John Hill
The spine along the middle of the building is broken down by X-shaped steel bracing that occurs every so often. This corridor, which feeds the galleries on either side, does not extend the whole length of the building (offices are on one end, and event spaces are on the other), but it still feels long. Therefore the cross bracing gives a rhythm to the walk that is not as relenting as the wood members.
by John Hill
One commendable aspect of this hallway of sorts is how it's used as a gallery in its own right; it is not just a corridor for the galleries on either side. The paintings are mounted at eye level and are small enough that they don't require a large space for someone to stand back and take them in. People can stand close to the art and let others walk by.
by John Hill
On either side of the central corridor/gallery are the main galleries — eight of them; they occupy anywhere from one to four bays, defined by the skylights overhead. These galleries are centered on the high point of the gable roofs that run the length of the building. The gallery shown here is the largest, putting on display the horizontal brace halfway down the space. (In the other rooms, the walls cover this little bit of structure.)

Even on a rainy day the galleries are bathed in natural light, meaning that on bright days the fluorescent lights running beneath the wood joists could potentially be turned off. Yet these lights serve a design purpose, especially in the corridor/gallery: Perpendicular to the wood structure, they reinforce the building's long plan and draw one's attention to the gable form at the end of the room.
by John Hill
About halfway down the stretch of the central spine between galleries is one large exhibition space that extends from the outer wall on the north to the one on the south. This would be the equivalent of the museum's great room. It is the only space in the museum where one can take in the full width of the building and its zigzag profile. Some skinny windows draw visitors to either side of the large space.
by John Hill
Here is a view inside one of the smaller galleries (two bays), where the homelike form is most apparent. Herzog and de Meuron, who have executed a number of buildings with pared-down gable forms, were influenced by the studios of artists living on Long Island. After visiting the studios of artists like Jackson Pollock, the architects tried to re-create their qualities — the gable form and abundant natural light (most of it northern light, but screened southern light also occurs) are their means of tying where the art is displayed to where it was made.
by John Hill
The museum, as should be obvious by now, is very minimalist, even though its structural components (steel columns and beams, wood joists, concrete walls) are all exposed. White walls and a polished concrete floor let the art come to the fore. My favorite architectural detail is a large wood handle on the black doors (at the entrance, café and offices). The handle is accompanied by its negative on the adjacent wall, a pocket that allows the door to be opened fully without damaging the wall or requiring a door stop that would have run counter to the minimalist aesthetic.
by John Hill

Comments

Becky Harris Really interesting and beautiful - recalls the long tobacco barns you see when you land at Bradley Airport in Hartford.

I think those bridges over the parking lot swales are check dams doing double duty as bridges. They slow down the water during a heavy rain to trap sediments and prevent erosion. What a very smart and beautiful design this entire project is within the landscape!
5 months ago · ·
John Hill Becky - You're right about the check dams, but they are separate from the wooden footbridges that traverse the swales...though I can't recall if the bridge used one of those concrete dams as a support.

The landscape also uses native plantings, which makes me think it will start to come into its own in the spring. Hopefully I can make it back in the warmer months when the sun is out.
5 months ago · ·
Dana Veach Exciting space...I love the contrast of almost cathedral like serenity and stark industrial power...(and I agree with Becky's "tobacco barn" analogy.)
5 months ago · ·
Fine Art & Portraits by Laurel From the outside, it looks like a commercial turkey shed; it improves inside. The hall is interesting with the wood and crossed beams.
I don't like the lighting cutting across the beam lines, and the lights don't seem to actually illuminate the art. The skylights should only face north, so that no sunlight can even touch the art. Sunlight eats paper and textiles, and of course fades pigments.
5 months ago · ·
Shannon Holman Nice photographs, John, and another well-written article. I'm wondering if you know how the architects planned the building's response to snow and rain gathering in the V of the roof-- butterfly and zig zag roofs lift the spirit, but aren't they prone to leaking?
5 months ago ·
tsudhonimh Definitely an "art barn".

I'd like to try scaling it down to a private residence.
5 months ago ·
John Hill Shannon - I was wondering that myself. Given the length of the building, I can't imagine a 1/4" per foot slope from the middle to the ends (a 6-foot vertical rise over a length of 300 feet!), so I figured it came down in downspouts within the corridor walls. According to a couple articles, the drainage is incorporated into the steel cross bracing, though I'd love to see a detail to see it how it works.
5 months ago ·
John Hill tsudhonimh - The original scheme basically did that, breaking down each gallery to a single pavilion:
5 months ago ·
Shannon Holman There are some interesting photos of the construction process at http://www.flickr.com/photos/parrishart/6163786722/
5 months ago ·
addisonsteel It reminds me of Tyson's chicken and turkey farms scattered throughout the midwest.
5 months ago · ·
scarbowcow Interesting that no one so far has said that it looks like a 'home' - 'barn' and 'shed' are what come to mind, apparently. As for me... my first impression was the long, wooden barracks at the Majdanek and Birkenau Concentration Camps in Poland. As someone suggested below, it improves on the inside, but from the outside, anything but 'home-like.'
5 months ago · ·
ssmakal The design involved more that just H&dM and Moyer and actually included the structural & mechanical engineers and landscape architect!


Planning:
Design Consultant: Herzog & de Meuron, Basel, Switzerland
Executive Architect: Douglas Moyer Architect PC, Sag Harbor, NY, USA
Structural Engineering: S.L. Maresca & Associates, Hampton Bays, NY, USA
Mechanical Engineering: Buro Happold, New York, NY, USA
Furniture Design: Konstantin Grcic Industrial Design, Munich, Germany
Landscape Architect: Reed Hilderbrand Landscape Architecture, Watertown, MA, USA

Consulting:
Geotechnical Consultant: Langan, New York, NY, USA
Civil Engineering: Nelson, Pope & Voorhis Engineers & Surveryors, Melville, NY, USA
Security Consultant: Ducivella Venter & Santore, New Haven, CT, USA
AV/IT/Acoustics Consultant: Shen/Milsom/Wilke, New York, NY, USA
Commissioning Agent: Dometech, Edison, NJ, USA
Concrete Consultant: Reginald D. Hough, Rhinebeck, NY, USA
Lighting Designer: ARUP Lighting (Andrew Sedgewick), London, UK
Lighting Engineer: ARUP Lighting, New York, NY, USA
Signage Design: LaPlaca Cohen, New York, NY, USA
Soil Engineer: D.B. Bennett, P.E., East Hampton, NY, USA
Surveyor: Saskas Surveying Company, P.C., East Hampton, NY, USA
(http://www.herzogdemeuron.com/index/projects/complete-works/326-350/349-parrish-art-museum.html)
5 months ago ·
Brothers Custom Works 615 linear feet of flat valley at the roof intersections - surely there is an effective drain system for this area - lots of expense for an architctural shape that is intuitively understood as vulnerable - and must be either self or otherwise maintained as clog free with art below.
5 months ago ·
captainsursea I'm sorry, but I cannot find any redeeming architectural value in this elongated rectilinear chicken coop.
5 months ago · ·
Becky Harris @John Hill - ah, now I see the bridge! I only saw the check dams before. The more I look at this, the more I fall in love with where the roofs intersect, on the outside and inside.
5 months ago ·
lynnes5 I realize the aim was to reproduce the lighting that the paintings were originally painted in. But this is a gallery and there should be some light directed toward the paintings. I believe the shadows from the beams in the "hallway" would be very distracting on the art. The building itself has beautiful spaces to display the art. It's just the lighting of the artwork that is lacking.
4 months ago ·
hamptontrainer Wish they finished off the exterior walls stucco/paint would do wonders for the building, the telephone poles in the parking lot are excessive & ugly, but glad to have the new faciltiy that was much needed. FYI- there are no sewer systems on the east-end, only septic.
4 months ago ·
lensguy The new Parish is an awesome structure, long, like Long Island, and it shares the island's east west direction. The barn shape reminds me of the potato barns that you can still find on the east end. Art mimics geography, beautifully done!
4 months ago ·
So Very Happy Art I saw the museum being built and was so struck by its length. I'm looking forward to paying a visit. It looks like a fabulous space.
4 months ago ·
Sign Up to comment
People found the photos in this ideabook after searching for:
The content on this page is provided by Houzz and is subject to the Houzz terms of use, copyright and privacy policy.
Copyright claims: contact the Houzz designated agent.