Home of the San Francisco Chronicle

Subscribe to the weekend Chronicle

powered by
Ideabooks
Photos
Products
Ideabooks
Discussions
Professionals
Users
The lakehouse came to life due to a planning constraint in the Lower Mill Estate community. The client wanted a living room with a large window overlooking the lake in the main house, but the rules of the estate's planning committee didn't allow a large glazed area in the walls of the historic barn and main house. As a compromise, Ramus designed this separate "living room" with open views across the lake.
by AR Design Studio Ltd
The client wanted the new structure to look like it floats on the water. The glass-encased living space provides 180-degree views of the water, nature and wildlife.
by AR Design Studio Ltd
Ramus wanted to keep the landscaping as natural and undisturbed as possible. This boardwalk winds its way to the main house. The path "creates a journey through the landscape," he says. The lakehouse itself has a very minimal amount of contact with the landscape, almost floating above the ground.
by AR Design Studio Ltd
The new living space is set up very simply. Ramus put the kitchen and bathroom at the rear, by the main entry. The entrance hall sits in between these two functional spaces.
by AR Design Studio Ltd
The small entry hall immediately opens out into a single open living space that looks out onto the lake through sliding glass doors. A balcony surrounds the entire home so the client can revel in the pristine setting.
by AR Design Studio Ltd
The structure uses the same materials as the main house, including light fittings and plug sockets. However, Ramus interpreted them in a more contemporary manner. "I suppose this means the material palette chose itself," he says.
by AR Design Studio Ltd
During construction, there were very few buildings nearby, making for an extremely private location. However, growth on the estate now means that residences surround the property, so the only private views are those that face the lake. Luckily, natural vegetation also helps to maintain privacy.
by AR Design Studio Ltd  
"The contemporary design of the boathouse sits in perfect harmony over the lake, and its use of glass reciprocates the emotions of the water," says Ramus.
by AR Design Studio Ltd
To create a sturdy structure over the water, Ramus had deep piles driven into the lake bed. The steel frame was built on land and then lifted into place on the water. "It was a nerve-racking day to see if it fitted," admits Ramus.
by AR Design Studio Ltd
Set off to the side, a glass cube surrounds Adirondack chairs as an ultramodern version of a gazebo. The gazebo provides completely open views of the surrounding landscape and protection from the weather. The all-glass structure has no visible fixtures or fittings; it's held together with industrial glue.
by AR Design Studio Ltd
The contrast between the historic main house and the new lakehouse is particularly striking from this overhead view.

"We wanted to create a beautiful juxtaposition from the old to the new," says Ramus. "The barn is so strong in its traditional style that we did not want to try and detract away from its beauty by replicating it in a neighboring building."
by AR Design Studio Ltd

Comments

Amanda Simons Hm... I'd rather see the barn and the main house. This structure doesn't fit here. I'm probably going to get some backlash for saying this, but I think preservation for preservation's sake should be valued. I can appreciate modern, industrial architecture, and I certainly appreciate the creativity and adaptability that was used to make this, but for me this distracts from the aesthetic value of the property rather than enhancing it. Call me old-fashioned, but this doesn't belong here any more than a log cabin belongs in Manhattan. Just my opinion though.
4 months ago · ·
Holly Marder Wow! Spectacular!!!
4 months ago · ·
gknee I can't help but think how great it would have been to at least have the exterior of the lake house in sync with the main house. I too love modern design but sometimes you just can't have both and have it jive.
4 months ago · ·
Lily Gahagan What an incredible view. Any chance the owners are up for an unexpected house guest?
4 months ago · ·
Sheila Schmitz Stunning. I appreciate the designer's comment, "The barn is so strong in its traditional style that we did not want to try and detract away from its beauty by replicating it in a neighboring building."
4 months ago · ·
Becky Harris Beautiful - it must feel as though you're sitting on a boat when you're sitting in the living room.
4 months ago · ·
midmodfan @Sheila: you're right!
I know that, especially in the U.S., people love to build new homes that look old, but in most other places around the world that is a no-go thing. The new structure is NEW and should look that way, imo. And the location is absolutely priceless.
4 months ago · ·
jazzcin I liked it a lot!
4 months ago · ·
Annie Thornton I'm really enjoying the trend of pairing historical architecture with contemporary additions. It shows respect for architectural heritage without relying too much on the past for inspiration.

I love how this house has deconstructed this by separating the two parts of the home. ..and I especially appreciate how "the contemporary space actually has the same basic structure, materials and specifications as the renovated barn and main house. " It shows a lot of thought.
4 months ago · ·
aeykelbo Hmmm.... I wonder how happy the neighbours are about this so flagrant evasion of the spirit of the planning committee rules. I get that people like to have their own spaces and do what they want with their own property, but in this case the effect is probably very dividing. E.g., some people here love the contrast, but for me it is a jagged, jarring eyesore that blights the landscape (especially from the air). But I guess heritage preservation kind of went out the window with the huge pool in the back yard.

I'm all for designing your own space, but if you just can't accept the governing aesthetic of your community, then maybe it's better to sell and go be hyper-individualist somewhere else. (Man... that horrible zig zag walkway has had a terrible effect on my mood!!!)
4 months ago · ·
Vanessa Brunner @aeykelbo If you take a look at the photo galleries on the Lower Mill Estate site, there are actually many other extremely modern structures in this community, so this structure doesn't stand out too much in this beautiful area!
4 months ago · ·
jkristamagee Wow! This is neat! I would be so so skinny with all the walking around lol. This is a big reason why I love this site- here in mississippi I can't say that I see much of anything that is unique- well except for a home in Magee ms that looks identical to a huge igloo and one other that stands out is a home in Brandon ms that looks like it is built from Legos - it's neat that so many homes are built like this in that area! It would be a treat to visit.
4 months ago ·
markjbecker Wow, love that structure, could live there! Couple things though, would much have been lost keeping it on land next to the lake? Maybe take the path straight off the pool and cross the pond at the narrowest point? Maybe make the profile of the building a bit lower? That path to it is just obnoxious. The two lawn chairs in the glass cube? Makes me think someone has an immune deficiency. Still that living room is great and the fireplace is super cool.
4 months ago · ·
rusty1 Love the structure a lot. The walkway sticks out like a sore thumb.
4 months ago · ·
Fine Art & Portraits by Laurel Envy, envy, envy! Ok, I'm finished. What a room, and I like the not-completely-straight path. I trust that all weather possibilities were planned into the height above the water? I think, from the dining table shot, that the windows are double with blinds between the layers? That would be good, both for insulation and light control. (the sun comes out at least once in a while there, yes?) The glass cube is iffy; don't put too much credence in 'industrial glue' when it comes to strong winds. My dream painting studio.
4 months ago ·
beary The views were wonderful, but the path leading to the home was thoughtful and stunning I would love to get to walk up that path ( It reminds me of the Oregon Coast!) and have a drink on the deck. Beautiful structure, great way to get the magnificent view! I love the old too, but if i could build a structure that took advantage of a waterfront like this one does, I WOULD!! Lucky people!
4 months ago ·
poeticmoma The path lacks fluidity. The structure is almost uninviting in this setting. A simple structure that complimented nature and was less intrusive would be more pleasing. Living on the water ourselves, I can only think of the materials sunk into the sensitive waterways for footings and the impact, as well as the water issues during storms. Not my cup of tea and a sad intrusion on the beauty of the natural setting.
4 months ago · ·
morgana44 Wow...just beautiful. What else is there to say.
4 months ago ·
Syr Tervs Reminds me of the house in the movie LAKE HOUSE.
4 months ago · ·
wandm Genius design. To be able to enjoy that gorgeous landscape throughout the year must be heaven.
4 months ago ·
strutis I come from a country where a house should be at least 100 meters from the lake for the nature preservation reasons. It makes me wonder where do these kitchen and bathroom sewer lines end up. Although I like the architecture and design...
4 months ago · ·
mcw2313 I wouldn't describe this juxtaposition as "beautiful" and the aerial shot was downright disturbing. I feel sad that this property has gone the way of so many other properties that have compromised their integrity for a water view. Having said that, I'm glad Houzz chose to share this house with us. It sparks reaction and makes us think!
4 months ago · ·
jangirouard Living on Cape Cod, where all construction is controlled with caureful environmental consideration, I want to know how sewerage is handled.handled. This building would never be permitted on Cape Cod.
4 months ago · ·
CAROLE MEYER WOW! Look what creative thinking can come up with....I love this whole place.....stunning!!
4 months ago ·
beary Poeticmoma, I think the path invite one to walk and meander to the little house. I don't feel it obstructs the view as it's not a large structure, and they have an expansive waterfront. I think if one was actually there, the overall feeling would be quiet peaceful.
4 months ago · ·
sclawson As for me, I'd move out of the main house and behold that glorious lake 24-7.
4 months ago ·
dwright548 I think it is wonderful…look at the Louvre and I.M. Pei's glass structure….old and new (modern) side by side…..it works!!!!!! Embrace the beauty of both.
4 months ago · ·
astraea I have a lot of glass on one side of my house, and the birds periodically fly into the sliders & windows .. so I don't know how responsible it is, to get up a glass "cube" in the garden, to protect 2 lounge chairs. I also wonder how hot it gets, sitting in there, and if the glass exacerbates sunburns.
4 months ago · ·
Vincent Murray I appreciate the way the lake house is set apart from the historic building. While the walkway appears intrusive, it allows a stroll through nature creating an experiecial walk to the living room. The gazebo is interesting as well.
4 months ago ·
drjosiepc1 The lake living room (with eating space!) is a clever, albeit I imagine costly, way of getting around the housing law. The glass gazebo boggles my mind. My very great reservation has to do with the sun. The glass would act like solar panels where I live and roast any one sitting there. In short, it would roast one. Since this is the Cotswolds, probably there is not much danger of roasting, given the weather.

Cleverness counts, but the results here seem to be like a sharp stick in the eye; the contrast is too stark, it seems to me. And I am no stickler of tradition and conservatism. Maybe at eye level (instead of from the air), it all works.
4 months ago · ·
lindapugh With all the planning stipulations in this community, I'm shocked that a bathroom & kitchen were allowed in this structure, especially since it sits directly above the water. The natural habitat, wildlife, & water safety should've been the primary concern here, not the owner's views from the deck. With this in mind, that wooden walk would've been far more attractive & unobtrusive had it been a natural stone path that wound around the lovely pond (is it natural? looks man-made), not a plank sidewalk built in a straight line from the swimming pool. The gazebo baffles me; design 'juxtaposition' aside, it looks more like a poorly functioning afterthought. Not a fan.
4 months ago · ·
drecwi Syr Tervs: I saw the movie Lakehouse and thought the same thing. Would like to know what it would be like in a storm.
4 months ago ·
kaz2 It's funny to read all the comments. It shows how different everyone is. I for one, love the lounge and that walk way to it.
I love love love the way the walk way isn't straight and you just meander along it. I'm wanting to do something similar at our place from the house down to a small deck through some native bush. : )
4 months ago · ·
Garden Structures Ltd I design and build garden structures and advise on planning all I can say is"Wow!"
4 months ago ·
wilke1223 Love it - boat-like.
4 months ago ·
Harcourts Manukau From a distance the design reminds me of a very modern houseboat however the interior shows a wonderful interplay of light and space that creates a most desirable living environment where you waste away the hours
4 months ago ·
ghostchairsandmore Watery and wonderful !!
4 months ago ·
mangay lucky owners
4 months ago · ·
ethangrath I Love all the glass but it's way to modern for me it doesn't look cozy and comfortable
4 months ago ·
Dove Cochrane It reminds me of the contrast and compliment of the historic Louvre and it's pyramid by I.M. Pei.
Old and modern can create a beautiful marriage of style. I love it.
4 months ago · ·
portpiro I don't have a problem with it. It's out in the middle of nowhere so conforming it to the style of the barn is less of an issue for me. Considering the weather in England I'm wondering how practical it is. Trudging up and down the path in the rain can't be fun. And I'm completely flummoxed by the glass cube. Stinking hot in summer and can't imagine why you'd want to sit out there in the rain. It wouldn't keep the midges out either which was my first thought..
4 months ago · ·
peetsoo I don't mind the meandering path and the property is gorgeous......but I can't help but wonder if the planning committee (not to mention the neighbors) is wishing they would have just approved the window in the main structure........
4 months ago · ·
msears3 While I like the idea of pairing a contemporary structure with an older structure in this case, I'm not sold on the elevation of the approach - it is reminiscent of a highway rest stop. Path is ok to me, I like the idea of it being mostly straight and especially going through the pond - I'd even put a chair or a stool there and watch the water's surface. The glass enclosure for the chairs? Nto so much. Pragmatic me thinks about mildew, mold and overall grime - constant cleaning. I'd rather pitch a tent or an embrella if bugs and privacy are a concern.
4 months ago · ·
yeok5904 Looks fab, would love to see in ten years when the planting has matured a bit and everything has settled down,
4 months ago ·
Mary Njeri Hi, i like the way you guys mix colors that come out so perfectly, i like every thing in this site, when i pan to build my house i wanna do a copy and paste from here, keep up your good job. thanx..
4 months ago ·
Tenshon, LLC Such a great use of the land. These structures really blend well.
4 months ago · ·
carlscra I have no problem with melding contempoary design with traditional. The images are wonderful showcasing a well thought out design. However...just an idea regarding the walk way...perhaps combining a more natural organic stone walkway from the main house onto the grass and utilizing the wood only for crossing the pond and trenches...may have helped the walkway blend in with the environment a bit more; perhaps appearing less jarring???Nevertheless... it looks lovely as it is. Great, thanks for showing your new space!
4 months ago ·
Vanessa Brunner Thanks everyone for this great response! It's always fantastic to read such diverse opinions from our readers. I spoke with the architect, Andy Ramus, who clarified a few things that came up in reader comments:

The Lower Mill Estate is a private estate in the UK that sits on an old gravel pit. There are 13 lakes in the 550 acre site, and most of the houses sit on the edge of a lake or over the water.

Lower Mill Estate has a team of ecologists who manage and advise architects on how to design each structure. This building in particular is extremely eco-friendly, with insulation and walls that allow for passive solar gain in the winter. The large overhangs and opening panels keep it cool in the summer, so the building rarely needs to be heated and cooled. The bathroom and kitchen waste and water does not dump into the lake — this is illegal in the UK. Instead, there is a hidden pump that moves it up to the main house.

In terms of design, all of the other houses on Lower Mill Estate are very modern. Material palettes tie the designs into the area, but the goal is to create a new regional vernacular. "The planners also recognize that old structures should be preserved and new structures should be clearly new and of the zeitgeist," says Ramus.
4 months ago · ·
salannie2002 I love it
4 months ago ·
almca Give this a couple of years, trees will grow up, the path that bothers so many will weather to grey and the landscape will be much more harmonious. That boathouse living room is gorgeous! It sits lightly, and probably blends in beautifully at ground level. The only thing that jars in my mind is that bright blue pool. A colour closer to lake or dam would be nicer. But maybe in the Cotswolds you need the cheerful blue to make you think it is warm enough to swim!
4 months ago ·
Mary Njeri Hi houzz, i admire you project esp with the houses you are doing on the sea.. keep up your good work.
4 months ago ·
sallyshepherd9 so out of the box...if you can dream it you can build it!
3 months ago · ·
Sign Up to comment
People found the photos in this ideabook after searching for:
The content on this page is provided by Houzz and is subject to the Houzz terms of use, copyright and privacy policy.
Copyright claims: contact the Houzz designated agent.