4 Obstacles to Decluttering — and How to Beat Them
Letting go can be hard, but it puts you more in control of your home's stuff and style. See if any of these notions are holding you back
Houzz Contributor. http://alisonhodgson.net/ Expert on the etiquette of perilous times. I love helping people figure out practical ways to support friends and family in crisis. I discovered Houzz after an arsonist randomly burned down our house and we lost everything. A home transcends four walls, and yet creating havens for ourselves and our loved ones, within these walls, is important work.
Houzz Contributor. http://alisonhodgson.net/ Expert on the etiquette of... More »
| Share: |
|
My husband and I began dating when we were still children. He was 16 and I was 15, back in the olden days when people still talked on the phone and wrote letters. By the time we got married and had three kids, we had almost 20 years of correspondence. I came across our box of cards and letters a few years ago and read it in one sitting. Afterward I had the urge to travel back in time and smother my teenage self with a pillow and maybe Paul's too while I was at it. Failing that, I considered burning the box. I called Torey, my sister, instead.
“Throw them away,” she said without a second thought. Torey is a neatnik and the tiniest bit twitchy when it comes to cleaning and organization. “If reading those letters brings you down, get rid of them.”
Next I called Nathan, my younger brother, and he recommended the opposite: “How many people in their mid-30s have a 20-year correspondence with their spouse? For archival purposes alone, you need to keep them.”
Finally I called Tanner, my older brother. We laughed about the conflicting advice Torey and Nathan gave, and then he was silent for a moment. “How do you know how far you’ve come if you can’t remember where you started?” he asked. That resonated with me. I tucked the letters back into their box, and there they remained, untouched, until the day they burned in a house fire. And I have never given them a second thought.
Looking back I can see I really wanted to get rid of them but didn’t think I ought to — that was the tension. It wasn’t that I didn’t know what I wanted to do, it was that what I wished to do conflicted with what I thought I should.
This is why decluttering (and losing weight and managing money) can be so painful; it’s the tension from the many feelings, often in conflict. Simply being aware of what’s underneath the surface can help us through. There are some common reasons we hold onto things we don’t want out of a sense of obligation; see of any of the ones here resonate with you.
“Throw them away,” she said without a second thought. Torey is a neatnik and the tiniest bit twitchy when it comes to cleaning and organization. “If reading those letters brings you down, get rid of them.”
Next I called Nathan, my younger brother, and he recommended the opposite: “How many people in their mid-30s have a 20-year correspondence with their spouse? For archival purposes alone, you need to keep them.”
Finally I called Tanner, my older brother. We laughed about the conflicting advice Torey and Nathan gave, and then he was silent for a moment. “How do you know how far you’ve come if you can’t remember where you started?” he asked. That resonated with me. I tucked the letters back into their box, and there they remained, untouched, until the day they burned in a house fire. And I have never given them a second thought.
Looking back I can see I really wanted to get rid of them but didn’t think I ought to — that was the tension. It wasn’t that I didn’t know what I wanted to do, it was that what I wished to do conflicted with what I thought I should.
This is why decluttering (and losing weight and managing money) can be so painful; it’s the tension from the many feelings, often in conflict. Simply being aware of what’s underneath the surface can help us through. There are some common reasons we hold onto things we don’t want out of a sense of obligation; see of any of the ones here resonate with you.
1. "It’s a family heirloom." Even if the value is only sentimental, how many things do you hold onto because they were your grandfather’s or your aunt’s, dentist’s cousin’s? My dear friend Sharon inherited her grandmother’s china. In the plus column it was beautiful, valuable and from a beloved relative. On the minus side, it wasn’t really Sharon’s style, and it reminded her of some painful parts of her childhood. She decided there were better ways for her to remember her grandmother, and wrapped up the china in a big box and gave it to a mutual friend who collects the same pattern and for whom it was a surprise and a delight.
2. "It was a gift." After our fire we were flooded with donations. In the first weeks, I sorted through truckloads of things people had given us. I was so thankful for the incredible generosity and, at the same time, there were so many things that didn’t fit or that we didn’t need. It wasn’t long before I got over any qualms I had about passing things on to various charities. Now I assume a gift is truly mine to do with as I please.
3. "I may need it someday." This comes up across the spectrum, from overbuying consumables to storing extra furniture. This could be the biggest one of all, and at the bottom of it is fear. A subcategory of this is: "I’m not actually sure what it is, but it may be important!" A few months ago I was sorting through a drawer in my desk and came across a random screw. It was thick and substantial; I knew it belonged to something. And then I recognized the old and familiar tension forming in the pit of my stomach with the thought, "Keep it! Keep it! You may need it!" I’m happy to say I reminded myself I had survived losing everything and was not going to allow an anonymous bit of hardware to freak me out.
2. "It was a gift." After our fire we were flooded with donations. In the first weeks, I sorted through truckloads of things people had given us. I was so thankful for the incredible generosity and, at the same time, there were so many things that didn’t fit or that we didn’t need. It wasn’t long before I got over any qualms I had about passing things on to various charities. Now I assume a gift is truly mine to do with as I please.
3. "I may need it someday." This comes up across the spectrum, from overbuying consumables to storing extra furniture. This could be the biggest one of all, and at the bottom of it is fear. A subcategory of this is: "I’m not actually sure what it is, but it may be important!" A few months ago I was sorting through a drawer in my desk and came across a random screw. It was thick and substantial; I knew it belonged to something. And then I recognized the old and familiar tension forming in the pit of my stomach with the thought, "Keep it! Keep it! You may need it!" I’m happy to say I reminded myself I had survived losing everything and was not going to allow an anonymous bit of hardware to freak me out.
by Justine Hand
»
Like it? Save it to your Ideabook »
4. "I paid a lot of money for it." That’s a big one. If you’re in the midst of a big purge, I don’t recommend trying to sell your things, for a couple of reasons. First, it will probably slow you down. Second, when you feel like you've wasted money on something you don't need, you probably aren't going to make enough from its sale to take away the sting. It may seem counterintuitive, but the most positive thing to do may be to let go, give it away and move on. It's a paradox that the more we let go, the more control we gain.
Like it? Save it to your Ideabook »
Ultimately, that's what this is all about: taking control of your home instead of being subordinate to your possessions. For some, when we talk about minimalism, it conjures up images of stark interiors, the idea of not having enough or of things being taken away.
To me minimalism is having what you love, but not a bit more than you can maintain. How that looks in your home may differ from how it looks in mine. It comes down to creating the home you long for. Life, like art, is all about removing and editing to make room for what you truly want and need.
Next: Not My Precious Books! Pain-Free Ways to Declutter Your Library
Previous: 7 Tips to Get With a New Minimalist Mentality
To me minimalism is having what you love, but not a bit more than you can maintain. How that looks in your home may differ from how it looks in mine. It comes down to creating the home you long for. Life, like art, is all about removing and editing to make room for what you truly want and need.
Next: Not My Precious Books! Pain-Free Ways to Declutter Your Library
Previous: 7 Tips to Get With a New Minimalist Mentality
Ideabook updated on March 14, 2013.
Latest Ideabooks
People found the photos in this ideabook after searching for:
View over a million photos:
Find Local Pros by Category:
Architects & Designers · Carpet and Flooring · Closet & Home Storage Designers · Design-build Firms · Fireplaces · General Contractors · Home Media Design & Installation · Interior Designers & Decorators · Kitchen & Bath Designers · Landscape Architects & Designers · Landscape Contractors · Specialty Contractors · Tile, Stone & Countertops
Find Local Pros by Metro Area:
Atlanta · Austin · Baltimore · Boston · Chicago · Dallas · Dc Metro · Denver · Detroit · Hawaii · Houston · Las Vegas · Los Angeles · Miami · Minneapolis · Nashville · New Orleans · New York · Philadelphia · Phoenix · Portland · Salt Lake City · San Diego · San Francisco · Seattle · St Louis





















I am a much more ruthless editor than my clients of course, but having a person assist in the process does wonders. My favorite saying is, "Okay, have a moment, but then let's move on. Don't dwell." I think the the most serious example of this was a client who saved EVERYTHING from her wedding. I'm not joking. She had been married 10 years and I uncovered a huge box of favors never given out, among loads of other things, and I said," X, you already have HIM, and photos, and the life you live now to remember that day by. This stuff is really too much." She agreed. We saved a couple mementos, made a beautiful (small) box, and she was unburdened.
It really can revolutionize your life if you're wallowing in clutter and never seem to be able to catch up with the cleaning, laundry, outdoor maintenance, bill-paying, etc.
I was never taught how to clean a house. Or rather, I was told to clean the house but never allowed to throw anything away. And it was impossible to clean around piles of STUFF. So all I ever really learned to do was shovel all the STUFF into hidden piles to give the pretense of having a clean house, when in fact the living room was the only clean room - and that only as long as the visitors were there. Flylady has taught me how to have an organized, tidy home without having massive cleaning sessions on Saturdays or panic attacks whenever anyone mentioned dropping by.
As for husbands who won't get rid of ANYTHING, Flylady has an answer for that: don't worry about his stuff. Declutter your own; settle into your own routines and family will begin to see and follow your lead. Literally, put your own (areas of the) house in order FIRST. Many if not most husbands and children start to follow the lead of the woman of the house when they see that she's practicing what she preaches, especially if she explains what she's doing and why she's doing it, and then doesn't preach but just sets an example.
I strongly recommend Flylady: even though I have a low tolerance for cute (and a lower tolerance for butchering the English language), it works and it's free, and you can't really argue with that. All the organizing information I have read on Houzz was either obviously lifted from Flylady (including some of her cutesy labels for things) or covered better by her system of sending regular reminders to her members via e-mail (she calls it 'Flywashing' - cutesy, see?). Because in fact you can read all the ideabooks and real books about organizing that you want, but unless you just get up and start doing it, bit by bit, you won't get anywhere. Flylady provides the way to get you moving, Flybaby-step by step (more cutesy), so eventually you look around and realize that your house is company-ready and it never seems to get all that dirty or messy.
We live in an increasingly digital age and this modern way of living is also pushing us to disconnect from each other in ways that resemble Grand Canyon leaps. Many kids live and relate soley through "social networking" on the computer, they bully, hate, take inapropriate pictures and basically embarrass themselves (and the adults aren't too far behind them). They do this because the small social ettiquettes we pass from one to the other, from parents to child, between friends, from generation to generation is quickly being lost for the sake of making our lives "easier" or less cluttered. To allow us the convenience of not having to deal with it. We are losing important parts of ourselves through these processes.
These items are actually part of the thread of who we are as individuals and families and friends. I sometimes come across old love letters from guys I dated and my husband and when I read them I am transported right back to the day I wrote it or got it or mailed it or put it away to be read again. My dad passed away 9 years ago and I still get choked up on certain days thinking about him. However when I see a card he wrote to me I see very vividly the day he asked me to be his Valentine's because my mom was in Canada and he had to give her chocolates to someone and my brothers were not interested. I see the card he touched, and picked for her and gave to me. I see his crooked handwriting. I remember sitting on the edge of my parents bed when he asked and when I gave him a hug and we ate a few pieces together. I could toss his card but I don't because I want that feeling of knowing that through time a little piece of me remains connected to that memory by touching his handwriting.
I also believe we can have a beautiful home that is lovinging created and built upon. Clean and warm. Inviting and charming but for me there is nothing like being able to call upon both my memories and to see my history at my fingertips. Alison I am sorry a fire took your letters but in addition to the memories the mementos matters as well.
I tell them to ask themselves one question "Do I absolutely love this?" if not, donate it to someone who will appreciate it. Obviously that question is a bit dramatic, but it's effective.
For some inspiration, here are some decluttering tips & photos:
http://www.interiordesigngreensboro.com/search?q=bookshelf+clutter
Gifts you don't like can go straight to the trash or freecycle.
I didn't tell the whole story: while my husband and I were in high school, his father died and my dad's business was embezzled causing my parents to sell our home to avoid bankruptcy. Those particular old letters represented one of the most painful times in my life. Rereading them brought sorrow and grief. They were not a beautiful reminder of our youth.
On the other hand I saved every single scrap of paper with my children's handwriting, especially anything which expressed their love for me. It was neatly stored in a medium sized Rubbermaid, the loss of which brought me to my knees. As did the little New Testament Bible my father inscribed with a prayer for me when I was three and I found going through things after his death. That was a treasured possession until I lost it in the fire. That would never be clutter.
Each one of us gets to decide what is too much or enough. My experience is that a lot of people struggle with being servant to their possessions, but of course not everyone is. Others have it well under control, just like my friend who can eat cookies all day, every day and never gain weight; it's just not an issue for some.
I don't think anyone walking into my home thinks, "Minimalist!" I hear "It's so inviting!" I have the things I love but it's what I personally am able to maintain. It's going to be different for everyone.
Thanks for commenting.
Maybe your mileage is different, but many people discover they've saved so much hay that when they want the heirloom needle they know is somewhere, they can't find it. That's certainly true for me.
I thought I was supposed to be like her and tried it, but I wasn't happy. I felt smothered. Too many things... even old journals were bringing me down.
I have begun doing the things you suggest which, by the way, are all so true.
I feel so much better, lighter and best of all, as you say, more in control.
This is a wonderfully written, lovely piece that goes to the heart and soul of the matter.
Thank you for it.
That also tells us something about what's wrong with our society: even as adults we are too often stuck in feelings of guilt, imposed by our families.
I am 30, my husband 33. We have been together since I was 17. I kept every note, letter and card he wrote to me. I think getting rid of these items would destroy me personally. I love reading them every so often. One little box in my closet is not causing any harm...or clutter.
As a teenager I always kept a diary. By the time I moved out at 18, I had probebly close to ten diaries filled. They all went in the garbage. It's not even funny how many times I regret doing that. There is nothing I can look at or read that will help me remember my thoughts as a teen so intimately. A quick decision that seemed great at the time, I regret now SO much.
I have five kids, so obviously I don't keep every art project or book report. Every year I save the 'best' art/projects until the end of the year, then I go through and save two pcs per child to put away. I don't have tons of boxes full of every piece of paper they ever wrote on, but when they get older, I will have something to show them...and their kids from their childhood.
I put an add on Craigslist for free stuff. A young man came and took away one and a half (full size) pickup truck loads of stuff. I have not missed it. Now I can actually locate hardware items etc. that I did keep when I need them.
Together, we have made some minimal progress, and some stuff has left. But it's not been without angst, discussion over the most useless tired item. I encounter this all the time with clients, and it is difficult because you can see the fear, the emotion, the anger, the confusion, the clinging to a time of life, no matter how wonderful, that has come and gone and will not return. I gently explained that "kids move on and that is evidence of YOUR job well done!", that they "will not come back for this stuff, they will not EVER go through it, and you have made yourself the custodian of clutter and its attending stress, and they give neither the stuff, nor your storing it,, nor this basement a thought" At that point, we stopped. That simple truth is too much, she is bordering screaming at me but containing herself. I will go down there and do the UNsentimental purge while they are away. I will stack all the sentiment, and toss the deceased decor in the dumpster in the driveway, and try to make some space and order. All I can say is she has a ton of company, and my bet is only a fire would remove the rest. If I had a nickel for each time I encounter this scenario...... I'd be filthy filthy rich. You can only do the tough love, if you can risk never returning.....maybe on the day the last lamp is plugged in, and the last picture hung.... maybe then i could really help.
We have few family members left and even fewer that want these things. Why do I need them? I know I have to scale way down and I have been thinking about it. Faced with the move, and encouraged by your article, I think I can accomplish this!
We are 60. This is our retirement home. We need a fresh, clutter free start. Alison, thank you for being the voice of reason!
He passed away in 2007. The garage was still an unorganized mess. Rather than sort thrugh everything, I just sold "as is" the tool chest and contents to a anyone who wanted it.
Some people are neatniks and some aren't. I am a neatnik, hubby wasn't. It really helps in a marriage if one of you is a neatnik otherwise you end up buried under clutter. Although packrats can get very angry if their stuff is thrown out.
However I need to say, some people are just born neatniks. Two of our children are neat as a pin, the others aren't and they were this way when they were young children.
Carrie
carrie@neatsmart.com
My Mom has passed on and the family house is being sold. I've stayed with her for the last 17tears and had a lot of 'stuff' from my old life as well. So now it's time to love what I have as I will be moving into a (much) smaller place.
Thank you very musch agaain.
Keeping it is nice, and reading it is good too. You won't change YOU, but you CAN change your surroundings and like the result so much, that the YOU that is the keeper ..... feels like you don't want the other surroundings, which are the result of the keeping! The first step to a change is beginning, and the realization that you will always need a certain vigilance when it comes to the keeping, storing sentimental you? : ) I wish you much good luck, and some major success!
Crabbygirl – Ah, the china! I wound up with 3 sets of “good china”, when my Mom died. As I have no children & my own china, I thought my cousin’s kids – young newlyweds – would appreciate not having to spend a lot on nice service-for-12 china .. but as you said, it “wasn’t their taste”. Only the Noritake bone china found a new home with a cousin!
Susanabc – Sometimes the “value” is more that a family member used, played with, or physically cared for something 100+ years ago, than its likeness of it. To have something actually created by a child, or the original sepia photograph, means more than their scanned versions .. although those are important to archive & share easily within a family.
I really wish I had that- it was such a clever idea and I loved those drawings.
And it's always funny when you're pushing your kids for better grades and they find that old report card of you or your spouses!
I don't regret throwing out some things from relatives that had no meaning to me personally.
On the other hand, the china that was my grandmother's was one of the few things my mother had from her mom before her stepmom sold everything of her predecessor that my grandfather was keeping for my mom.
I love bringing it out at Christmas and holidays. It makes me think of my mom as a little kid.
And my husband's grandmother's old pasta roller is back in use.
One of the things my aunt gave me when we went to Texas after my father died (he was living with his parents then) was a rolling pin for my daughter - it had been made by him for his big sister when she was married and she had used it for so long. My daughter loves having something from her grandfather and loved the story with it
One more category that I have is this: I INVESTED [money, energy and, most of all, aspirational wishing] in this and I really mean to ( insert your daydream here): paint, play the cello, sew marvelous original clothing, have a huge garden, camp in the Rockies ..... and someday ...
I find this all the more difficult to jettison because I "hung my hat on it" so to speak, back in the days when I had no time... and pretended that time was the only issue. So you ( I ) have to face the fact that i am not THAT imaginary person, I am me, and I have to make a decision if I do now want to be surrounded by detritus from every life phase.
EVERY SINGLE TIME, after we have helped them to de-clutter their homes and get it ready for the market, they tell me, why didn't I do that earlier? I love my home.
What they are feeling and loving is the sense of FREEDOM and that is priceless. De-cluttered and simple rooms are soothing and that is something we all need when we come home, since our world outside is so hectic and over stimulated.
Feng Shui practitioners believe change is energy, clutter prevents change. Our lives should always be changing flowing, if they become cluttered they become stagnant, and stop flowing and growing in new directions. Love houzz. Have to check out the space clearing article by apt.46 and flylady site. thanks.
I don't see decluttering as meaning that you must dump everything - only that when we hold onto too many things without considering their significance to us, we can get stuck in a bog where that stuff is preventing us from living fully now.
The china made me wince, but reading everyone's story got me to understanding.
And if a "pro" dumped my stuff without my permission they wouldn't be my pro any longer and I would sue them for theft.
It is saddening to me , that we have become a society that knows the price of the latest ' gadget/ phone/ laptop/ etc' ..but that places little value on the things that are, as you stated.. ' the thread that binds'...* sigh* and I attempt to hold onto all those things of ' value' to me... ; which is not to say that I dont have some modern conveniences.; I do have a few. But I am the ' dinosaur" that loves corded phones. Vintage anything... I even have a 1948 Kenmore Stove..whilst other people are gaga over Stainless Steel appliances. Not me. Give me something white and Vintage every time. I adore old china. I have a set. I I save momentos of things that are close to my heart. I also keep a journal..so that when I do leave this Earthly plane..I hope that in reading it that my daughters have a better understanding of Mom and will keep that journal, so that they can feel close to me when they need to....; you are spot on in your description of how this ' digital everything' is pushing the connection TO each other farther and farther away; I feel that as well. I see it... Its a sad thing , honestly...and lest anyone think I have a house full of junk and clutter.. : I am an organizer. I have been a Personal Housekeeper. When I would help someone ' organize'.. I DID NOT make them just toss things..( I shudder when I think of Peter Walsh, sometimes.lol ) We would discuss the object/ papers/ whatever it was; determine the best route for either saving/ donating/ passing on to a person that loved it.. you get the idea. I could NOT, in good conscience.. make people feel like I was MAKING THEM CHOOSE to do something that was not right for them !!! This is more successful( to me ) than taking that approach of " well, if you save THAT.. you MUST get rid of this..." RUBBISH. People are attached to things for reasons, and its up to THEM to figure out how much and why. THEN the process becomes easier .. to save/ get rid of/ donate/ pass on/ etc. Then THEY become better at keeping whats important to THEM. They can then determine from a certain point where their own boundaries lie. And the keeping becomes better, It becomes ' more selective' and it becomes organized and not overwhelming to them. Then its easier to maintain and keep things organized. To me, its about the ' lesson"..and not so much about ' "Throwing everything away" or " getting rid of things that are important".
Thank you Christine.. for your thoughts and your candor.. I believe a lot of people really DO agree and feel the same.. but alas, in this ' digital age' .. I often feel that we are also losing OURSELVES to ' popular opinion " and giving up what is important ( individually) for the sake of ' not being left behind'... or we dont want people to think " wow.. do you live in this Century ...?? ." ah well. I will keep my Vintage Stove and my corded French phone.)
Original copies are always best. We will never know which way technology may turn, or what devices may be used in the future. Just try to find a way to play a VHS.....now.
Files can be lost, deleted, anything can happen. If it means that much to you, nothing will make as much of an impact as the original document.
Showing my grandkids a letter from my husband thirty years from now will just not have the same value on a computer screen, even if you can still view it on there. A child's artwork? Will not even look the same, when scanned onto the computer. It completely removes all sentiment and meaning.
The idea of this "professional" service is to make that person happier in their home, not to make them comply with 1001 rules of order and acknowledge your superior organizational abilities and taste in decorating . The overall issue is - if you are at war with the person you are helping, you're not helping. I have had, by the way, to arrange cleanouts of hoarders whose home was going to be condemned - or whose children were removed - that was "war "- and they were faced with a clear consequences ( children in foster care, homeless or clean). Even then, I wouldn't be as disparaging of my clients. Cleanouts are not organizing. And "organizing' per se is not the core problem when it's at this level.
So we have put them in a sealed box (we can open it and reseal anytime we wish) and the box is marked: things to go to aunt Linda. My sister will take possession of the box should anything happen to us, and destroy the letters. Her husband was on a carrier at the same time mine was on the sub so she "gets" this issue. My kids have no idea what's in it, and would never open it since it is destined for someone else.
I too see both sides of this issue. There's junk clutter, and there's meaningful clutter, and which is what will vary with the individual. My husband kept every check he ever wrote, going back to the 70s. We have moved more than a dozen times since then and those dang checks came along for the ride! Finally last year we bought a new house, and. Even tho tis bigger than our previous house, we decided. It was a great time to get rid of junk. And guess what? The checks finally made it into the shredder! Yay! Small Victories!
I'm so sorry for your loss and wish you the very best in going through everything.
Regarding your collection?
Does it bring you joy?
Do you have the room to store everything?
You may consider purchasing some photo boxes or about that size if they don't make them anymore and sorting the letters into categories: each close family member could have their own box, and one for friends, one for acquaintances. Stack them neatly and if they're pretty, it could be a pleasing to look at and easy access.
I'm a writer, so letters and cards (more than just a signature!) were hard for me to part with. If this tells you anything, I had a small file with notes from junior high, but they were all organized and tucked in the larger box of all my childhood and pre-marriage mementoes.
Let us know what you come up with. I'm always interested in paper organization.
And you are so not the only one! Thanks for the update.
What to do with a glowing letter of recommendation written in 1938 for my father? I scanned it along with other letters and certificates and gave the originals to my sister -- maybe subconsciously passing the buck on the decision to toss them? Unfortunately, she passed away last year and I got them all back. I've shared the scans with all of his grandchildren; but, don't want to burden them with the physical copy. They're safer scanned. (I know I'll let them go soon, but it's somehow harder the second time around.)
So now when a husband or daughter suggests I have 'junk' I need to get rid of....grrr. I am also a vintage connesisuir. And I don't collect things. I choose vintage over new any day! I value the items for the integrity and quality of who made it. And they made them to last!
I also realize that for me there is a difference in a 'hoarder' and a 'collector'. I have often purged my stash....purge being a scale that I define. But I tell them hey...when I'm dead you can do with it what you want cuz I won't care anymore.
When my mother finally sold that house and moved into the new condo of her dreams I came from 2500 miles away and helped with the packing. The dozens of boxes that kept her papers contained not love letter but recipes and ideas for a job she had not been employed in for over 40 years and were all obsolete were all stacked in the garage. I arranged all her furniture and told her that her stuff was in the garage and she could go though it at her leisure.
Initially she balked but within two weeks exclaimed how wonderful her life in the condo has been. She loved how clean and uncluttered it was and the dining room table was always able to host guests.
tt has been over five years and she has not opened one box from the garage. I will deal with it at her death.but I am fairly sure those old recipes and magazine articles are without historic value.
Realistically, how much time do we spend agonizing 1 screw and if we're going to need it? Life is simply too short to spend time on some of this stuff.
Here's my tip on paper items. Make up a file and call it "Keep for awhile, then toss." When you come across ANYTHING paper-wise that you don't know if you should keep it or not, just put it in the file. After 3 or 6 or 9 months or a year, go through the file. There's some stuff I've had for over a year that's still in the file, but a with lot of it, the urge to buy it, do it, respond to it has passed, or the deadline is up--and I can just toss it and not give it a second thought.
When you finally do decide to get rid of something--especially if it's a bunch of somethings, it's just nice to get it out of your house. You feel lighter--like clutter has been removed from your mind.
The "not needed accessory decor" has BEEN PREVIOUSLY DISCUSSED AS "BURDEN" .... so you can relax. The act of having to DO it paralyzes my client. So she said with regard to those...."DO AS YOU WILL, I DON'T WANT TO WATCH". And i will, though it will make only a medium dent in the real problem. Given the size of the the thread today, my guess is if many walked into their storage areas, and could magically make some of the unsentimental clutter get sorted from the real keepers and tossed, there may be some takers of that instant magic. No guilt, no decision, no agony over it cost 8.99, or "it could come in handy" , or " gee, they looked just like real irises until they faded like that and got covered with dust... mmmmm lets see... dumpster or donation? " Let's be honest, isn't that at least in part why this thread is the size it is today? I should point out my client came to that after seeing some of her favorite things in their best light in the portion of her home just completed...hence the permission slip on the other STUFF.. Her sticking point on the sentimental is something else entirely. So .....down I will go, and I will create an "entertaining closet" for her at the same time, and when she returns she will be as thrilled with that progress as she is on the rest thus far. I will probably find some other treasure she doesn't even remember, to use where she can see it and enjoy : )
I understand completely the lovely sentiments you have about items with personal history and I share your concern that young people raised on electronics often lose touch with the story of their family's life. BUT ... That is not the clutter problem most Americans have.
When is the last time you bought a house? I've had circumstances in my life that caused me to move three times in six years. I looked at hundreds of homes in three different cities. In spite of all the talk you hear about "home staging," very few people do it. In house after house I've toured, the sheer amount of STUFF people owned often completely obscured sight of the structure. Who can tell if a home has adequate storage when the messages you get are "this home is a firetrap" and "this home has NO storage"?
Absolutely the hardest job I ever did in my entire life of earning multiple degrees and completing decades of a corporate career was moving my mother out of the house she and my father had built 50 years earlier. Mom HAD to move. She was completely unable to care for the property as well as the house due to illness and disabilities. Yet she was determined to stay there forever. Mainly because she didn't want to have to face dealing with three stories of possessions. She refused to cull her treasures herself, yet when I did if for her she stood over me whining and crying about every object. She owned 42 bud vases. That doesn't count full-sized vases. Does that give you a picture of what I was dealing with? And she was moving into an apartment. Yet, under no one's definition would my mother qualify as a hoarder. She was just a woman with a long life who imbued every inanimate object she owned with a charming story. And does she miss her objects now? I've asked her and get a sheepish, "Well, not really."
I also am the repository of heirlooms of family members long gone because I am perceived as the person who "appreciates nice things." Yes, people notice my nice things because I don't display that many of them and I do it carefully. I try and try to convince my nieces to help themselves to the beautiful sets of china, crystal, and silver that are stored in my garage. I beg at least once a year. Nobody wants them. I can't find anyplace to sell them either that would reimburse me fairly.
People SHOULD have objects to remind them of their families and their history. By all means digitize family photos, home movies and videos. Send copies to everyone in your extended family. I was moved to tears when a distant cousin recently gave me a single black and white snapshot of me as a toddler standing with my Dad in front of her parents' house. When a family member dies, try to make sure every person has something intimate to remind them of the deceased. Pass on a document, a favorite book, the family Bible, heirloom jewelry, a piece of artwork, recipes boxes, something in the person's handwriting, a vintage Christmas ornament. By all means, give them a beautiful vase. A vase, singular. Not 42 bud vases.
As for digitizing - you have to back things up, and store a backup offsite. Period. That is as true of photos as it is of copies of your tax returns.
And if you are storing things for the next generation, are you storing them properly? If not, many tings will be destroyed by the acid in cardboard boxes or wooden drawers, the moisture in a plastic tub, etc. This is never part of the conversation but should be. When I decided to give my cousin's kids some of my grandmother's crocheting, I picked ONE piece for each of them. They didn't need a case of crochet - especially since so many had those brown stains that come from storing textiles against wood. And I will send to the, archival ly stored, so it will last some more generations.
Two questions: Do you think the folks to whom you ever sent a card or note are saving those you sent them? Don't answer that, just think about it. Then... do you look at these, pull them out and savor them? If you do, the cards with a special note, save those. Just a hasty signature? OUT! The letters? Okay, bundle those and save. Possibly make a separate Christmas tree if that is appropriate for you, and decorate it ONLY with all the special Christmas cards/photos. Make a tiny hole punch...and HANG. Or you can do same with Hanukkah. Every year, you'd have a few week period to savor them, and add the one mailed in. But printing emails is a definite burden, and unless a legal necessity... maybe try to stop doing that, save ink too! Good luck to you!
And @ emeraldmist.. I understand YOUR thoughts also. I am sorry you feel that pain and resentment...about things just being ' thrown out'.. and I have cautioned the oldest daughter about that., as she now has two young children. ....; I also SO appreciate your love of vintage...made me smile, reading your post.. and yes, that last line is so true... and it gave me a chuckle. I will inform my daughters thusly..." hey...when I'm dead you can do with it what you want cuz I won't care anymore.".. Jolly good. :) God Bless.
As soon as it was cleared out and rearranged, I matted 2 large pictures on the cleared table. I wanted to mat these pictures for about 10 years. Now, I go to that room and just sit- it is so peaceful, yet full of energy for the future.
Gifts that come from my husbands side of the family always have strings attached. I know this sounds awful, but my and my husband's taste in home decor differ greatly from my mother in law's. My husband and I have found that the strings attached to these gifts (which range from things purchased new, to passed down from granny, to acquired at an estate sale) are actually trip wires that trigger an emotional response of offense and displeasure in the giver, when said gift is exchanged, given away, or sold. I'm pretty sure the moment we decide what to do with the "gift" in question, her eye starts to twitch, even from across town.
Anywho, I'm sticking to my guns when it comes to doing what I please with things given to me. Otherwise, where is the pleasure in having a home of your own, if someone else gets to decorate it?
My mother was also a neat nick who got rid of our things before we were done with them, and my daughter in law is now the same. I think it is unfair to give away things which belong to others , even though they are little children.
Decluttering should have its limits.
Just Your Style
When my mother passed away, I had great difficulty in letting go of her personal possessions, it felt like it was all I had left at the time. During grief counselling, my counsellor suggested i buy a beautiful box and keep in it the 10 things that gave me the strongest, fondest memories of my mother. Six years later, I can visit the box on her birthday, anniversaries and any time I want to visit with her. Her cardigan still has her smell! It was a great way of letting go and making me prioritise what was important. As an artist, I believe I am instinctively material, something I did not inherit from my dear mum.
Thanks for a great article Alison.
Ed and Ginny, Ginny and Ed. It is almost impossible to utter one without the other. Most tributes list a string of accomplishments, but if Ed and Ginny could speak, they would answer in unison only one: our family. They would say it was 54 years of marriage and truly happy lives. Dad was a salesman and traveled often while Mom held down the fort with three kids. They were a team in every way. Way back in the sixties, people did a lot less running around and weekends were for "good fun" like washing windows, maintaing the beautiful yard, or visits with grandparents. Unable to escape the "fun" you learned to love to clean! And Grammy told such great stories at dinner!
They were always a single voice. Asking Mom, "can I go?" only got you "go ask your father" A request to Dad, got you the same in reverse.
Never concerned with acquiring the newest, they saved everything. Dad could fix whatever was broken, and tweak anything to make it work. His way. Shaving polarized plugs to fit dated electrical outlets resulted in minor inconveniences. A swipe of the toaster with a damp rag could blow you into the adjacent dining room. " Remember!!! Unplug!!...then wipe!"
Ed was the mayor of the neighborhood, Ginny was a friend to all.They complimented each other in every way.They adored us, and loved the home they made together, but first, last, and always they loved each other best. They are together again, and for them, we are very happy. It is how it was meant to be.
Reading it again, just made me smile.... and I didn't have to dust. : )
We have one drawer in the kitchen where I keep spare 'parts'. Screws, nails, random found objects with no home. Every so often I go through and think, 'ok if I haven't needed this, I will get rid of it now'.
Would you believe as soon as I throw out the thing, within a day or two after, my husband will come looking for it, or even myself at times.
And this is not the case, one time. We are talking, this has happened so many times, my husband doesn't even laugh anymore....
I still do. LOL
This is a follow up to what I wrote earlier. After being left a widow in 2007, I am now rattling aroun in this 9 room house plus garage. I have decided to sell and downsize since children are grown and on their own, living scattered across the U.S. I am getting rid of more excess, this time inside the house. I have found a nifty house, but have to sell mine first. Bad time, but maybe, the Lord willing, it will sell.
I laughed out loud at the lady who had the fabric. That is a total weakness of mine, it's that one.
I make quilts and have a fabric stash you wouldn't believe, which I keep organized by color combnations and in a plastic boxes with snap on lids. I have a hard time staying away from fabric stores when they have sales flyers. I am totally addicted.
I told my oldst daughter who is the executor of my will, that after I die, just put the boxes on the lawn with a sign that reads " free to any quilter who is an addict to buying fabric".
However I am hoping to have it all made into quilts before then, the bad thing is, for every quilt I make, I simply buy more fabric to fill the boxes. Lol....
Y'all have a good day, and thanks for the laughs.
I get a viseral feeling about rusty, dusty or musty stuff because it may be the perfect book, old photo or complete a dish collection etc. Listening to what you all have to 'free' your space would be more than welcome to be sent to me. Please send your junk to me!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I'd love a go at it. My favorite place is an unvistited forgotten attic! Oh, the treasures! I am drawn to the vintage for one because of the hands that once used it. My imagination conjures up the life it had, who used it, what memories it holds. It's intoxicating! I make no excuses for my love of these things.
Hoarders are certainly not what I am talking about. Not being able to walk through your home or see your dining table....that would be a problem without a doubt. And they may need some form of professional help to lighten their load. But I do not judge them for it. That happens one day at a time not overnight. If you're living with filth and squaler......that's is a whole other topic.
Bopp Decker rules! ; )
Any suggestions?
1.. I have always built a classic wardrobe for myself, and am having maybe my last laugh, as grey and burgundy are back. I never buy anything I don't love, and guess what, my stuff is prettier, and certainly made better. I get compliments everywhere I go in my repurposed 80's burgundy, loose but beautifully woven sweater, with my tailored size 6 - 8 (who knows, they keep changing the sizes) grey pants. Along with my tribal jewelry collected from everywhere , but all handmade, not one person knows I didn't just get the outfit from Bloomingdales.
2. There is a difference between hoarders and marketers.
When I see a beautiful item, know where came from, what it is, and what it can be used for, if I can, I buy (at a good price). I have been able to furnish our homes with high end items by selling and trading. Yes, the garage is full, but frequently, it is empty. I like it full. And, yes, my car is in the garage, not on the street.
When I go to a new clients' home, the second thing we do is go through all the "stuff" they have jammed into drawers, etc. Often, there are items which can be framed or put into albums, given to relatives who want them, or, even, if altered by painting, for instance, and can then fit perfectly into the client's home, and , grandma's piece fits perfectly.
You certainly have to know what you are about while you are buying, but we never could have afforded the beautiful homes and furnished them as well, if I had not known to do this.
Again, I do not believe you should keep every goofy thing that arrives in your home, but, if YOU don't think t's goofy, and IF, it reminds you happily of Uncle Ed, you should have it.
Sometimes we get so caught up in taking pictures we don't appreciate what's going on around - and then we stick the photos in whole storage carts or on so many CD's. Huge storage issues. I've seen people with five 6-drawer carts of photo's.
Remember film? You couldn't edit - you got the whole roll back, warts and all.
I now do a lot of editing and get rid of shots that don't seem necessary. I don't mean the ones where the kids are all sticking their tongues out at mom, but the blurry, the ones that don't capture anything meaningful of fun or silliness. Lots less photos, easier to put on a CD in a computer to have a slideshow loop background. So they don't get hidden away because it's too much, there are too many to work thru.
btw, found the film rolls in a bag my husband had insisted he looked thru and there were some amazing photos! But still learned that the lesson is it's better to carry memories and be in the moment than looking at life thru a camera eye for pics that end up just accruing.
responses and guess whose they were? Yours! Well written, to the point and very
helpful as we'll be moving this year and going though all of the above mentioned
scenarios of all those who took time to comment. Oh.... to be a beautiful bird in flight
with no earthly baggage.
I wish you the very best in your new home along with the peace and serenity that come with having not one scrap more than you choose to savor, maintain and enjoy! It is odd how interior design is ALWAYS a process of editing and choosing. To get any one thing most always means leaving another thing behind. If this table, not that one. If this chair, not the other over there... clients can always cope with that concept. But when it comes to the rest ...THE LAND OF BURIED TREASURE, be that a stuffed linen closet, a tortured basement, a garage that cannot be navigated, all hell breaks loose! When I see them open and shut the door with "ugh!! I can't stand to go down there, it's too scary!!!" or OH NO!! Don't look in my linen closet, it's a disaster zone" , or in snow... "oh, sorry, I would have let you in through the garage but you can't walk in there...." you get the idea. They all want it gone, but the process is just too daunting. The most brutal of the truths is that this isn't Uncle anybody's treasure. It isn't love letters. It isn't even grammy's china gravy boat. It is crap. Tons of it, the result of a society which buys too much stuff, because stuff abounds. Cute stuff, cheap stuff, useless stuff. Too many gifts, too many afternoons browsing. Too much decor for every possible holiday, too much and too many of every article of clothing one can imagine. Even if it all were great stuff, it would still be more than could be used, enjoyed, or fully appreciated.
I am always stunned that when you finally get it GONE....lugging it to the curb or wherever... the result is nothing less than total gratitude. Tears of joy in many cases. In all these twenty plus years, not one client has ever called to say "I could just strangle you for making me toss that teeny little basket of fake ivy, that faded 19.99 picture, or the wobbly lamp with the yellowed and cracked shade"' Not one. Maybe they just like that freeing feeling! . I wish you "wings".
Kudos Katherine for saying that oh so scary nobody wants to mention it , its not gentle enough, there is always a reason to keep something or put it off or whatever word which applies ninety percent of the time.. the E!!! word... Excuses: ) And we all have them for some area of life. Uh oh..... duck for cover, here it comes, gonna get blasted now!! : )
So creative and original. A great use for 'useless' items, and a fond memory of your husband every time you see the pail. Inspiring!
Of course these shows are just that: shows.That said, I don't doubt that this happens in real life.
And you would be soooooooo right!!!!! Yes those are tv shows.... but life today in so many suburban homes borders on a chaos combined with clutter, that you can not even comprehend. Much of it is due to sheer volumes of stuff, and it afflicts those in every size home, and at every income level. I have been paddled on this site more times than I can count for the truth of what is out there, for the truth in how to cure it. How did it happen? Well despite a limping economy, we have goods that are far cheaper as a percent to total disposable income, than at any point in American history. You used to get a box of crayons and a couple coloring books and a bike. Today...bucket and buckets of colored markers, thousands of dvd's. You used to go to the library...now a billion books are at the disposal in cute kids areas of Barnes and Noble. Mom, Dad, and all the kids have forty to 100 pair of shoes and sneakers and flip flops....used to be you had school, play, and Sunday dress. So......... along with the average square footage of homes, and prosperity, came this GIGANTIC influx of stuff. But our brains are the same size, and our lives are busier.....do the math huh? It is a zoo out there. Doing design for a living makes one realize a whole lot of folks are drowning in a pile of their own making. No money left for the new sofa either....
I wasn't able to get organized until I retired. I didn't have the time or energy. I think at a certain age it gets easier to realize that, the moth eaten letter from my cheerleader uniform isn't anything I want to display and no one else would enjoy it either. I have finally given myself permission t live in the now and not for "later" when I might need this or that.
Thank you for all of your help in this.
Trying to "purge" the "stuff" from our home seems to be a constant battle, but every time I let something go, I feel SO much better, and if I can find a way to keep it AND throw it away, then I can avoid some of those feelings you were talking about. Thanks for a great article!
I think this is romantic too.
Forgive yourself the mistake, and find a consignment furniture shop in your area and settle for a half of what THEY sell it for, or put the items on Craigs list yourself, Or on E Bay, or see if a friend can use/pay an appropriate half price deal for whatever piece they may like. But do not be a slave to what was a mistake, and continue to punish yourself. In other words... you goofed, you won't get the $$$ back to 100%, and move on. It's the only way. Other than staring at the "mistake" for another few years: ) In the future, get design help, and prevent "mistakes", maybe. But moving on is key.
Maybe it is me, but for 150.00 x 12 months..you can buy 1800 bucks worth of fresh kinick knacks/ pillows every year. This is AFTER TAX MONEY. So.... it is really your tax rate PLUS, meaning more than 1800.00 dollars. Or it is a savings to an IRA for the long haul of life! Does this make sense to do? Stuff from your youngest daughter? Stuff you don't want to use in your home? Fabric... and you haven"t and won't use it?
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ I think we do a thing when the thing makes no sense, and then we keep doing it, and what we need to do is stop doing it. Maybe?
One of my new favorite quotes fits in here somewhere, perfectly. It reads:
"Don't look back...... you're not going that way."
Thanks for this valuable reminder!
I have been cured of my inability to throw away books , craft supplies , memorabilia i.e. program notes and tickets from long past concerts ... One very substantial but unfinished craft project that hadn't seen the light of day since the children arrived i was very upset about losing in the flood . A very wise friend asked me if I had a photo of me working on it .I did indeed . Then she asked if I had enjoyed the process of creating this piece . That I did . '' So then all you really need is the memory of that time no flood can wash that away ". We now when deciding whether to keep something ask ourselves would we bother to try and salvage this article in the event of another flood .Very few things pass this criteria these days !
Excellent article. So sorry about your home, but how wonderful that you all came away unharmed.
emeraldmist, you are so not alone, as comment after comment should prove.
Lori Thoreson, thanks so much.
Marty Perz, I'm going to be addressing that in some future posts. I know some others have said the best idea is to focus on your own stuff first, but that doesn't help if the spouse in question is already tidy. In general, my husband and I have found that making requests, clearly and with a loving and respectful tone, is helpful regardless of the issue at hand.
Thank you!
http://www.houzz.com/discussions/375677/In-trying-to-de-clutter-my-kitchen-top
With the innovation of the "cloud computing" our memories now float from house to house, without the added moving costs. Now, my husband and I watch our old memories, as well as new from our grand-children, as we listen to our 60's and 70's music on our Apple TV....
Thank you.
Becky
Oh, and now I live with easy to move or cheap to replace IKEA furniture, trendy Target or thrift store finds so I never feel guilty about redecorating on a whim! This year my color scheme is Red, Yellow, Orange because of the Playbills that I saved and am finally displaying on the wall... but NOW I have a great photo of all those Playbills so they may be tossed when I'm tired of that look!
On the other hand, if you get your older kids to watch, perhaps it will help them learn the lesson I learn whenever I purge a drawer or room - STOP buying so much junk!!!
Now, I stand there a minute or 2 and really look at what suddenly caught my eye and think - do I really need to spend my money on this and where will it end up in a year or two?
After that, if you still don't want to throw away paper items, consider this: shred the item, pick an area in the yard you want a plant or tree. Dig a hole, mix the shreds in with dirt, and plant a tree or flowering shrub. You'll have something to elicit your feelings in a good way (ie Grandma's tree or a Friendship tree) and it's not in the house!
He had some old pieces of handmade furniture,through our mom's estate,( RIP mom), letters and drawings from her Dad who drove a tank in WWI, our Dad's medical books from Harvard;his own photographs,camera and film, a passion.We divided up things,keep and not clutter; like the antique roll top desk,from his room growing up,which I am planning to use in my home office, as well as our great grand-father's oak medical examining table & medical bags he used on horseback, riding into the hills of Virginia to make house calls. No one in our family boasted, but we knew the value of"things' and that beauty and history is irreplaceable. All of us here,online, can't have a home office without a desk, right? I could never find one like this.Good news: it's perfect.Crate and Barrel may be good for our sofas and kitchenware,but we know how blessed we are and keep the few things left that are not only beautiful, but also tell a story; we pass it on to our kids as well as use them. Even if they just learn, & don't want the "things".
I understand how people my parents' age,90+ or are already gone, experienced a life affecting them forever; it was an age where they had very little to nothing new; simple living, like you & I all may want here, but it wasn't by choice. They still kept everything when the wars were past, yet living a 1950's family lifestyle! They & theirs' suffered a great deal of loss: loved ones, property and farms, careers,and a sense of safety they were now losing. Think about our own 9/11.
House-fires were common,Dad's side had two.In one, my Grandparents only saved my Dad,and 3 pieces of her family furniture.I inherited 1/2 of the gate-leg table from her parents' estate when she died. Where was the other 1/2? I took a trip to my grandmother's most recent hometown, learned through friends that it had been given by her sister to a church.My husband & I found it, covered in candle wax,once-stunning wood now darkened and bent; we explained the story, & humbly asked for it, then moved it, and used the little $ we had then to have it restored by a pro,w/ actual boards of antique cherry. It was built on my great-grandparents' estate, and I loved the old stories of this grand room and table of her parents' home with 20+ dining together(it had several lost/burned extensions).That and one pine hand crafted corner cabinet are the most "valuable" pieces I own, and I do not have many. I love the gorgeous and practical ones; we use them almost every day.I don't want the $.
I don't want 3 cabinets of jars w/ old nails,string, either,as my mother had, or a closet full of fabric for old rags, or a basement of things never sorted, or my attic-full. BUT we went through it all when she died,found vintage furniture;old furs,hand-sewn linens.Her dolls!my Barbies! I will keep them in a glassed cabinet from her.Everything was in mint condition.Amazing.We also donated things and had "the auction", keeping things to consider if we wanted..
Dad's medical books are in the old lawyers' cabinet in the office; you would have to seek 1 , and for $1,000 you can find it or get a reproduction through a store like Crate and Barrel. I do know it is a blessing to have it.
TIP: I learned when my friend kept a closed "memory box",(size of&used as a side table,well-made in leather), after her husband died, that there IS a way to contain smaller things we treasure. I have one for Mama, one for my brother. 75 plus 200 yrs. of history. And photos on disc :)
I want to use old lace,wedding photos,old keys& jewelry, in shadow boxes,simplifying the process for my kids! Hanging things also is great way to save space.Share,and keep what YOU need. Enjoy the things you decide to keep,it's work, and worth it.
And lol, keeping the old piles of receipts and checkbooks; that was once our problem, too.....so, yes, well for a few yrs. for auditing potential you have to, but still you can store them neatly and just shred those old papers! We have had to just gradually do it, quit putting it off, and now are now organizing the dreaded long walk-in closet since the floors ruined and replaced; now all must be back in with style and no more "sentimental journey" stuff; if not sure, keep it somewhere for awhile and then make up your mind. If you do want to consign, as I have before, go for it! Even 60/40 % seeming unfair gives you incentive to give up the stuff you are just holding onto. Thanks for everyone's input, I need it right now! Clothes are not the easiest, and closet space is never big enough, so making mine look good so I will get rid of the un-necessary!
I will be posting more Kijiji ads in the next week or so because it is so easy to find someone who wants the stuff and will come and get it.